Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to Chaos Vanguard Dimension. We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features.

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Dark Nephthys Ruling; XC Chat Log
Topic Started: May 26 2008, 11:16 PM (15 Views)
Zenrei
Member Avatar
Vanguard Leader of the Reckless Swamp
[ *  *  * ]
rei_hunter : so i'm fine with it
Zenrei : Say I special summon Dark Nephthys to the field, my teammates say that I miss the timing for Card of Safe Return because Dark Nephthys' third effect is not optional.
rei_hunter : woot
rei_hunter : poison types
rei_hunter : hmm
rei_hunter : okay lets go my lovely ho-oh
AmonRa : They're right.
Zenrei : I told them it doesn't matter because it starts a chain, in which I fit Card of Safe Return in before the third effect hits
Jaden_Yuki has joined #rulings
Jaden_Yuki : for dasher's effect can u tribute tokens
ShotgunShogun : Yes.
Zenrei : So I don't see how I miss the timing on my Card of Safe Return when the effects are separate.
rei_hunter : WTF
rei_hunter : Drapion knows Ice-fang
rei_hunter : >.>;
Zenrei : If they were together, like it's special summoned and then it destroys a card, then that'd be fine, but since they're separate don't I get priority anyway?
Karl`sleeping : Zenrei, I don't think you understand how card of safe return works.
AmonRa : CoSR is always optional...
Zenrei : I know that.
AmonRa : ...if the SS effect is mandatory, CoSR misses the timing...
AmonRa : ...see the DW rulings
AmonRa : So no draw.
Karl`sleeping : After a chain resolves, if the last thing to happen was a summon, you can use card of safe return's effect.
AmonRa : And you lose CoSR thanks to Nephthys
Karl`sleeping : In this case the last thing wasn't a summon.
GeneralExodus : Amon he talking about dark nep
GeneralExodus : no the the regular one
GeneralExodus : not*
[GB]Darkhero : Yea blubber neck >:[
GeneralExodus : lol
ShotgunShogun : =/
Zenrei : What about when it's not Special Summoned by its own effect, I can still get CoSR because Dark Nephthys effect happens when the chain resolves, right?
AmonRa : Well, you still aren't drawing.
AmonRa : CoSR always misses the timing
Karl`sleeping : Wait..
Karl`sleeping : :/
Karl`sleeping : amon
Karl`sleeping : that answer is wrong
Karl`sleeping : When this card is Special Summoned, destroy 1 Spell or Trap Card. <- This effect starts a new chain..
AmonRa : Unless the UDE/Netrep rulings were reversed, CoSR always fails to activate if a monster effect is activated by that monster being Special Summoned from the Graveyard.
Zenrei : Exactly, that's what I mean.
Karl`sleeping : AmonRa..go get said ruling.
Karl`sleeping : It doesn't exist :/
Zenrei : Because the way I see it, if I use Monster Reborn to SS it, the chain resolves, I call priority on CoSR, and then Dark Neph can go after, right?
Karl`sleeping : There are rulings that specify about dark worlds using their secondary effects, but in this case it's different because it's a seperate chain
Corpse : I don't see how priority has anything to do with this situation.
Zenrei : Priority allows you to put a card at Chain Link 1.
GeneralExodus has Quit IRC [ Ping timeout ]
Zenrei : So since both Dark Neph and CoSR can be activated, I could Priority CoSR so that it doesn't miss timing
Zenrei : Because it's a new chain
Karl`sleeping : it wouldn't mis its timing even if meph was link 1
rei_hunter : my next battle is a Fire type :o
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
« Previous Topic · Table of Chaos · Next Topic »
Add Reply