Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

WE WANT A FAIR GO FOR OUR AREA, MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND MORE THAN 4 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM

Want to talk all things Wests? Click here for our Facebook Page
Poll Only
Group 6 - Season 2011
Topic Started: Nov 5 2010, 09:46 AM (134,509 Views)
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
mickrobbo
Jun 4 2011, 09:17 AM
sounds like a plan not a bad ground to watch footy at picton been there once this year already and loved it :correct:
so BD or itchy who will be running to the bar for me out you 2 bludgers :laughing: :cheers: :drink: :drink:
Picton will have the Bar flowing, come down a watch 3 great games of footy, at Victoria Park Picton, Sunday games are at 11.30, 1pm and 2.30pm, Picton has the best club house so lets fill it with Red and white and have a few VB's (got to look after the sponsor) :drink: Michael Robertson, I would love to catch up with ya, my shout first :cheers:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Fence sitter
Jun 3 2011, 09:44 PM
I feel you pain doggies girl, BUT think on the other hand, what if the Eagles dropped 40 point players to 3rd grade to save points in 1st and Reserve, if I remember the Oaks was doing this and put 100 points on city, it's a sad position but if clubs like the Bulls or Bowral started buying players what would you say, a line needs to be drawn in the send and no players at 40 points should be playing 3rd Grade, if you are looking at stepping up next year, get the players then, but I bet you players won't step up when it comes to it! You won the comp last year and you would probably win it this year without that player, I know almost everyclub has been whinging about this player, probably not to you or the Appin club, but every G6 club has raised there concerns, any clubs supporting you on this issue?
We got hammered last year for having a 40 point player in 3rd Grade, he played 6 games of the bench for our Bundy Cup in 2008 but was regarded as a 40 point player, whats different to last year to this year!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
doggiesgirl
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
we know all about 40 point players and he did not help you win the comp last year...its not about how many points the player is worth its about his playing at a higher level, some clubs have 40pt players for 2pts if they have played at an elite level they will be finding another team to play in..I believe 5 clubs in 2nd div have these players and will be used in his defence..
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
doggiesgirl
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Blue Devil
Jun 4 2011, 11:03 AM
Fence sitter
Jun 3 2011, 09:44 PM
I feel you pain doggies girl, BUT think on the other hand, what if the Eagles dropped 40 point players to 3rd grade to save points in 1st and Reserve, if I remember the Oaks was doing this and put 100 points on city, it's a sad position but if clubs like the Bulls or Bowral started buying players what would you say, a line needs to be drawn in the send and no players at 40 points should be playing 3rd Grade, if you are looking at stepping up next year, get the players then, but I bet you players won't step up when it comes to it! You won the comp last year and you would probably win it this year without that player, I know almost everyclub has been whinging about this player, probably not to you or the Appin club, but every G6 club has raised there concerns, any clubs supporting you on this issue?
We got hammered last year for having a 40 point player in 3rd Grade, he played 6 games of the bench for our Bundy Cup in 2008 but was regarded as a 40 point player, whats different to last year to this year!
I am sick and tired of all the politics..how do you expect Appin to stand up next year when they took a player away and 4 more will walk with him...Group 6 want us to build to play at a higher level but you dont get any support from them....lucky if we make it through the year..shame really ...anyway i have had a gutt full of all this do-do.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
doggiesgirl
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
doggiesgirl
Jun 5 2011, 12:23 AM
Blue Devil
Jun 4 2011, 11:03 AM
Fence sitter
Jun 3 2011, 09:44 PM
I feel you pain doggies girl, BUT think on the other hand, what if the Eagles dropped 40 point players to 3rd grade to save points in 1st and Reserve, if I remember the Oaks was doing this and put 100 points on city, it's a sad position but if clubs like the Bulls or Bowral started buying players what would you say, a line needs to be drawn in the send and no players at 40 points should be playing 3rd Grade, if you are looking at stepping up next year, get the players then, but I bet you players won't step up when it comes to it! You won the comp last year and you would probably win it this year without that player, I know almost everyclub has been whinging about this player, probably not to you or the Appin club, but every G6 club has raised there concerns, any clubs supporting you on this issue?
We got hammered last year for having a 40 point player in 3rd Grade, he played 6 games of the bench for our Bundy Cup in 2008 but was regarded as a 40 point player, whats different to last year to this year!
I am sick and tired of all the politics..how do you expect Appin to stand up next year when they took a player away and 4 more will walk with him...Group 6 want us to build to play at a higher level but you dont get any support from them....lucky if we make it through the year..shame really ...anyway i have had a gutt full of all this do-do.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
doggiesgirl
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Blue Devil
Jun 4 2011, 11:03 AM
Fence sitter
Jun 3 2011, 09:44 PM
I feel you pain doggies girl, BUT think on the other hand, what if the Eagles dropped 40 point players to 3rd grade to save points in 1st and Reserve, if I remember the Oaks was doing this and put 100 points on city, it's a sad position but if clubs like the Bulls or Bowral started buying players what would you say, a line needs to be drawn in the send and no players at 40 points should be playing 3rd Grade, if you are looking at stepping up next year, get the players then, but I bet you players won't step up when it comes to it! You won the comp last year and you would probably win it this year without that player, I know almost everyclub has been whinging about this player, probably not to you or the Appin club, but every G6 club has raised there concerns, any clubs supporting you on this issue?
We got hammered last year for having a 40 point player in 3rd Grade, he played 6 games of the bench for our Bundy Cup in 2008 but was regarded as a 40 point player, whats different to last year to this year!
Fence sitter he was registered to play for Appin and accepted to play in where ever they wanted us to play which was 2nd div we dont have another side to drop 40 pt players down to..clubs hide under the radar its not about the points cause we play under our points each week it is about players who have played in higher levels this player is a 40 point player for us but take for eg eagles may have an elit player in their side who is worth 2 points as he has played with there club for 2 years should that player be playing in there 2nd div when he has been registered to play in reserve grade or 1st grade...its all to bloody political...there is nothing written to say that the Appin player cant play and if they set a precedent it is only to include players that register or change clubs from the date it is set not those they have allready allowed to play by accepting there rego form which clearly states 2nd div and that he last played toyota cup and had to be cleared from that club this legal document has been signed by the player the club secretary and the group secretary ..this has to be resolved and very soon.. by the way dont feel for me feel for him he is the meat in the sandwich .....
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
doggiesgirl
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
mickrobbo
Jun 3 2011, 10:18 PM
no 40 point player should be playing 3rd grade end of story bring him back when you get 1st grade you will kill off smaller clubs dominatine lower divisions get real appin people seem to be over you and the way you operate your club its valley 09 all over again the group has to act bottom line appin has more excuse to go up grades then a fat kid caught with other kids lunches at school please the dribble about rebuilding is boring you won 3rd grad last year and are still there adding in now 40 point players come on move on be real like all other group 6 clubs this aint the jl
hey mick you going to sponsor appin next year so they can play 1st grade..How much do you think a club needs I believe around $100,000 well thats what other clubs tell me it costs them.

kill off smaller clubs you are an idiot mate not everyone can play at 1st grade level and why should they not be allowed to play footy..its park footy mate...all of it is park footy except some clubs pay their players money to play for them even in 2nd div and thats why so many people are upset on here, Appin dont pay their players and are whipping the arse of clubs that do..

And while Im at it clubs are here to develop there juniors and to provide a club for them that they want to keep playing with when they are older. This does not happen over night, this area will grow over the next ten years and hopefully we will be able to provide more then a 2nd div for them then but at the moment 2nd div it is...

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
doggiesgirl
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
mickrobbo
Jun 3 2011, 10:21 PM
doggiesgirl
Jun 3 2011, 08:49 PM
40 point playa
Jun 3 2011, 08:17 PM
mickrobbo
Mar 28 2011, 08:39 PM
super coach
Mar 28 2011, 07:59 PM
take your hats off appin by your forth year you should be a first grade side.i have been going over old posts and read that bowral wasted all their money on there club house and they will be in first grade by year 2014 long way to bowral keep trucking boys. APPIN take a bow
hey supercoach if you saying you are a firts grade side tehn why not play first grade :dunno:
if your club is smart you will make money no point hiding in lower grades it looks soft and seems you blokes are jacket hunters
me mate reckons you got big backrower who hides out on the wing running at little blokes and has won palyer of the year in the group for years why aint he playing first grade is scared he might get found out and tested
i got mates in cambelltown and they were taken 1200 on the gate at milton park ingleburn last few seasons no fenced in ground so it can be done :rofl: :rofl:
stop hidin boys and make the move up 4 years in you blokes are kidden hope the highlands boys towels ya up they are small town you blokes have ctown to pull from so big call putting do do on that club striker :finger: might come out that way sundy at have a squizz do you sell beer :drink: :drink: out therenot coming if no beer :drink: ill even pay me 5 bucks and not sneak under the fence :rofl: :rofl:
hi guys I hear all these rumours you all say you want Appin to be in first grade in 2012 stand up Appin run at the barry beef of oakdales pack. Appin are preparing for 2012 and one bloke decides to have a whinge about a 40 POINT PLAYA- how can a club build when we only have 3rd grade players? We get some decent players and you guys wont them to walk away from a good little club. This player joined the club wanting to play with his cousins and he dosent even play a full game.

Why would this player come back next year if we told him sorry champ you cant play here any more.

regards, 40 point PLAYA
Good on ya 40 pt player..well said the Appin club are trying to have a 1st grade reserve grade and under 18s for 2012 but it is a bit hard when the group and other clubs dont support you...all i hear is whinge whinge whinge Appin this and Appin that..its Appins 4th year in the comp and are trying so hard to have a 1st and reserve grade next year 2012 but when players are pulled from under our feet makes it hard...Come on group 6 support our club and wish us well in achieveing this...if you keep up with theses antics we will still be playing 2nd div next year...we are not the only 2nd div club in the comp there are clubs out there not even thinking about a 1st grade and have been playing 2nd div a lot longer then us..give us a little credit ...Appin club is a good little club please dont try to destroy it..we are trying so hard to get ahead we need sponsors in order to pay our first grade players...hard these days to even achieve that...as braveheart would have said you can take away our players but you will never take away the pride we have for our club, .
your club is winning by 30 each week and you still want more with this 40 point player will you not be happy unless its 50 each week you win by :finger:
you talk of the jl maybe thats where your club should be cause thats how your sounding like appin :letmesee:
I think you ought to go in and have a look at the results of each game Mick
wow 30pts each week and then have a look at what other teams are winning by...
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
doggiesgirl
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
mickrobbo
Jun 4 2011, 06:16 AM
footylover
Jun 4 2011, 03:03 AM
mickrobbo
Jun 3 2011, 10:21 PM
doggiesgirl
Jun 3 2011, 08:49 PM
40 point playa
Jun 3 2011, 08:17 PM
mickrobbo
Mar 28 2011, 08:39 PM
super coach
Mar 28 2011, 07:59 PM
take your hats off appin by your forth year you should be a first grade side.i have been going over old posts and read that bowral wasted all their money on there club house and they will be in first grade by year 2014 long way to bowral keep trucking boys. APPIN take a bow
hey supercoach if you saying you are a firts grade side tehn why not play first grade :dunno:
if your club is smart you will make money no point hiding in lower grades it looks soft and seems you blokes are jacket hunters
me mate reckons you got big backrower who hides out on the wing running at little blokes and has won palyer of the year in the group for years why aint he playing first grade is scared he might get found out and tested
i got mates in cambelltown and they were taken 1200 on the gate at milton park ingleburn last few seasons no fenced in ground so it can be done :rofl: :rofl:
stop hidin boys and make the move up 4 years in you blokes are kidden hope the highlands boys towels ya up they are small town you blokes have ctown to pull from so big call putting do do on that club striker :finger: might come out that way sundy at have a squizz do you sell beer :drink: :drink: out therenot coming if no beer :drink: ill even pay me 5 bucks and not sneak under the fence :rofl: :rofl:
hi guys I hear all these rumours you all say you want Appin to be in first grade in 2012 stand up Appin run at the barry beef of oakdales pack. Appin are preparing for 2012 and one bloke decides to have a whinge about a 40 POINT PLAYA- how can a club build when we only have 3rd grade players? We get some decent players and you guys wont them to walk away from a good little club. This player joined the club wanting to play with his cousins and he dosent even play a full game.

Why would this player come back next year if we told him sorry champ you cant play here any more.

regards, 40 point PLAYA
Good on ya 40 pt player..well said the Appin club are trying to have a 1st grade reserve grade and under 18s for 2012 but it is a bit hard when the group and other clubs dont support you...all i hear is whinge whinge whinge Appin this and Appin that..its Appins 4th year in the comp and are trying so hard to have a 1st and reserve grade next year 2012 but when players are pulled from under our feet makes it hard...Come on group 6 support our club and wish us well in achieveing this...if you keep up with theses antics we will still be playing 2nd div next year...we are not the only 2nd div club in the comp there are clubs out there not even thinking about a 1st grade and have been playing 2nd div a lot longer then us..give us a little credit ...Appin club is a good little club please dont try to destroy it..we are trying so hard to get ahead we need sponsors in order to pay our first grade players...hard these days to even achieve that...as braveheart would have said you can take away our players but you will never take away the pride we have for our club, .
your club is winning by 30 each week and you still want more with this 40 point player will you not be happy unless its 50 each week you win by :finger:
you talk of the jl maybe thats where your club should be cause thats how your sounding like appin :letmesee:
Sorry Robbo dont want to cuaz any trouble but if this player couldn't make it and he had his best go at it then who are we to say he can't play with his family or friends then good luck to him if you can't play with people you like and have fun then why play at all ???
i disagree footylover this guy was in storm 20s last year now in 2nd div as a 40 point player there are crl guidlines for 2nd div competitions and 40 point players are not in the spirit of the 2nd div comp be it with family or not it defeats the purpose of having a 3rd tier comp and mercinary teams stacking up to win them like valley did in reggies 09 :finger:
mmm 4 games 2009 storm under 20s.. did not play 2010.. 16 rep games in whole footy career.. harold matt & sg ball total 12 games...these are the stats given to me mmm I should of asked you robbo you seem to know all.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
mickrobbo
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
can somone give doggies girl a medal for number of posts in 1 day and doggiesgirl instead of writing and telling it on the forum explain it to the group 6 committe in writing the forum will get you no where
end of the day you have a rep player player 2nd div which aint in the spirit of 2nd div your team is strong enough and will win without him as you did last year
100k for 1st grade boy looks like my odds of you getting a 1st grade are on the money then and i hear appin have no intention of runiing 1st in 2012 thats why your happy stacking up 2nd div
anyway good luck and tell it to the people who care i think the forum has heard enough of the issue time to talk bout footy again

off to picton today to watch 2 100k teams run around should be a good day and blue devil will be broke by time i leave today :laughing: :drink: :drink: VB a plenty son flowing today :drink: :drink:
Edited by mickrobbo, Jun 5 2011, 07:52 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
mickrobbo
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
doggiesgirl
Jun 5 2011, 01:10 AM
mickrobbo
Jun 3 2011, 10:18 PM
no 40 point player should be playing 3rd grade end of story bring him back when you get 1st grade you will kill off smaller clubs dominatine lower divisions get real appin people seem to be over you and the way you operate your club its valley 09 all over again the group has to act bottom line appin has more excuse to go up grades then a fat kid caught with other kids lunches at school please the dribble about rebuilding is boring you won 3rd grad last year and are still there adding in now 40 point players come on move on be real like all other group 6 clubs this aint the jl
hey mick you going to sponsor appin next year so they can play 1st grade..How much do you think a club needs I believe around $100,000 well thats what other clubs tell me it costs them.

kill off smaller clubs you are an idiot mate not everyone can play at 1st grade level and why should they not be allowed to play footy..its park footy mate...all of it is park footy except some clubs pay their players money to play for them even in 2nd div and thats why so many people are upset on here, Appin dont pay their players and are whipping the arse of clubs that do..

And while Im at it clubs are here to develop there juniors and to provide a club for them that they want to keep playing with when they are older. This does not happen over night, this area will grow over the next ten years and hopefully we will be able to provide more then a 2nd div for them then but at the moment 2nd div it is...

you cant pay 2nd div players appin :finger: :finger: smoke and mirrors you will find
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Highlander
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
doggiesgirl
Jun 5 2011, 12:14 AM
we know all about 40 point players and he did not help you win the comp last year...its not about how many points the player is worth its about his playing at a higher level, some clubs have 40pt players for 2pts if they have played at an elite level they will be finding another team to play in..I believe 5 clubs in 2nd div have these players and will be used in his defence..
Well if we have one id love to know who???

Smile doggiesgirl you guys somehow manged to get an away game moved to appin with 3 games!!! All cant be bad!!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
mickrobbo
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Highlander
Jun 5 2011, 08:52 AM
doggiesgirl
Jun 5 2011, 12:14 AM
we know all about 40 point players and he did not help you win the comp last year...its not about how many points the player is worth its about his playing at a higher level, some clubs have 40pt players for 2pts if they have played at an elite level they will be finding another team to play in..I believe 5 clubs in 2nd div have these players and will be used in his defence..
Well if we have one id love to know who???

Smile doggiesgirl you guys somehow manged to get an away game moved to appin with 3 games!!! All cant be bad!!
asked me mate at the bulls if they had any and he laughed :laughing: more like 40 schooner players he reckons :drink: :drink:
8 3rd graders from last year mac fields 6 from union get that up ya rah rah league taking ya players and 3 never played before and 6 under 18s fom last year and one from we get beat 90+ each week inglebyebulldogs so sounds like a true 3rd grade side :correct:

good luck today highlander i reckon an upset on the cards at appin today now th playing talent has been evened out :cheers: be a few sunk :drink: on the bus back to bowral if ya roll em today :winner: :winner:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Highlander
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
upset hmm not to sure bout that!! We will have a go
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
footylover
Jun 3 2011, 04:45 PM
Fence sitter
Jun 3 2011, 04:37 PM
Fence sitter
Jun 3 2011, 04:30 PM
tc6_11
Jun 3 2011, 04:07 PM
Rumour has it that Oakdale have just signed a new player.
He is in the 40 point category too
Well who is he, I will ring my dad, he will know!
And you guys say my dad knows nothing, just phoned dad and he said it is Nick Taylor, he was at the Bulldogs playing premier league but was dropped to Bankstown Sports in Bundy cup, he is a Picton Junior and has signed with Oakdale, his father also coach G6 rep team the past 2 years, see dad knows everything!
Would you waste 40 points on a winger ???
I originally would agree with that, but when you think about the amount of work wingers do these days, it is a critical role.
Scoots, edge defense, speed, and getting under the high ball.
Doesn't matter now anyways, looks like he has backed out.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Once again i believe the 3rd grade thread is necessary. This garbage is clogging up the place.
But i do have an opinion on it.
For all you Appin bashers out there, don't get bitter, get better.
I seriously hope that the group lets them keep this player, they should be allowed to build for next year. If they don't take the step up next year, then banish the club.
Enough said hey?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
disco stu
Member Avatar
Country Origin
[ *  *  *  *  * ]
This Appin talk is going around in circles, let it go. I they are under the points then what does it matter ? Sounds like a case of tall poppy syndrome , there's a benchmark team in all grades, mitta u/18's ,eagles 1st grade etc , appin 3rds, accept it and meet the challenge.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Fence sitter
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
tc6_11
Jun 5 2011, 11:53 AM
Once again i believe the 3rd grade thread is necessary. This garbage is clogging up the place.
But i do have an opinion on it.
For all you Appin bashers out there, don't get bitter, get better.
I seriously hope that the group lets them keep this player, they should be allowed to build for next year. If they don't take the step up next year, then banish the club.
Enough said hey?
Your right about the 3rd grade comments, is clogging up the system like Mick Robbo after a greasy kabab 3 in the morning, but Appin has had what 3 or 4 years to step up, but they continue to concentrate on 3rd grade premierships, I'm all for clubs stepping up and congratulate the Oaks for doing so, but having close to the same side as last year and adding more strenght ain't helping 3rd Grade, anyway the powers to be will sort it out for what's best for the Group, not Appin!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
disco stu
Member Avatar
Country Origin
[ *  *  *  *  * ]
Results from rnd 9. Picton & Eagles game scores unavailable.

Dudley Chesham The Oaks
u/18 Moss Vale 16 v The Oaks 10
Reserve Grade Moss Vale 12 v The Oaks 38
First Grade Moss Vale 30 v The Oaks 41


Onslow Park Camden
u/18 C/T City Kangaroos 22 v Mittagong 46
2nd Div C/T/City Kangaroos 6 v C/T Eagles 64
Reserve Grade C/T City Kangaroos 18 v Mittagong 36
First Grade C/T City Kangaroos 20 v Mittagong 32

Wonson Park Appin
u/18 Warragamba 44 v C/T Eagles 14
2nd Div Warragamba 12 v Macarthur Bulls 28
2nd Div Appin 32 v Bowral 10

Narellan Sportsground
Reserve Grade Narellan 25 v Oakdale 36
First Grade Narellan 22 v Oakdale 58

Kirkham PARK Camden
u/18 Camden 46 v Thirlmere 0
Reserve Grade Camden 46 v Thirlmere 0
First Grade Camden 20 v Thirlmere 30

Robertson Showground
u/18-2 Robertson 23 v Mt Annan 30
2nd Div Robertson 24 v The Oaks 24
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Fence sitter
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
Well done Disco, I cannot believe how fast the results are posted, tell you, Dad is impressed! Hey where is the Picton Eagles details, anyone know the results, Dad at $50 on Picton with a 10 and a half head start!
Edited by Fence sitter, Jun 5 2011, 05:30 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Join the millions that use us for their forum communities. Create your own forum today.
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · CRL Group 6 · Next Topic »
Poll Only


www.wests.co.nr is an unofficial forum run by volunteer Rugby League Supporters
Posts, messages, views, expressions or opinions on this forum DO NOT represent the official view of ANY Football Club.

Free Domains Hosting at .co.nr