Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

WE WANT A FAIR GO FOR OUR AREA, MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND MORE THAN 4 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM

Want to talk all things Wests? Click here for our Facebook Page
Poll Only
Group 6 - Season 2011
Topic Started: Nov 5 2010, 09:46 AM (134,484 Views)
disco stu
Member Avatar
Country Origin
[ *  *  *  *  * ]

Grand final replay

http://www.wollondillyadvertiser.com.au/news/local/sport/rugby-league/grand-final-replay/2252842.aspx

Posted Image
Catching up: Thirlmere/Tahmoor's premiership-winning team from 2001.

THIRLMERE/TAHMOOR Rugby League Football Club will host a 10-year reunion for the inaugural first grade premiership-winning team from 2001. The big day on Saturday starts at Thirlmere Sportsground and later at the Welcome Inn Hotel for a post-match function.
The reserve grade team will start proceedings against Oakdale at 2pm, followed by the first grade clash against Oakdale at 3.30pm — a rematch of the 2001 grand final in which the Roosters won 20-16.

Tickets can be purchased from the Welcome Inn Hotel or from the Thirlmere-Tahmoor club. They will cost $50 each and include entry to the match day games, entry into the marquee at the ground and the post-match function.

Details: Peter Palmer on 4684 1864.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Spud
Ball Boy
[ * ]
The people on here seem to know what's going on and are prepared to say what they know.
I have asked my club and they don't know
So I will ask here

What is the points system. I think I know how it applies to my club,but how does it apply to the bulls, eagles and Roos

They are really strong.from what I have seen they have huge depth
If all there players were cleared from another district which they were I checked the sporting pulse rant they 25 points or 10 points

My club says we can't stock up on new players as we are close, but if you go 10 for 60 players that's way over

I am not winging, but if am going to get beat, I want to get beat fair

Can someone help please
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
oparnz82
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Of course it doesnt matter where you play your semi final, whether its home ground advantage or not. The point is why is the group now trying to allocate venues based on where the home team finishes? If thats the way they want to play it, then the highest ranking team should get a home semi. (as is the case in almost every other sporting comp) Easts should get the major semi at onslow, Oakdale should get the 2 v 3 semi at sid sharpe and either mitta, picton or thirlmere whoever finishes 4th should get the elimination semi. This approach seems like more of a commonsense approach plus teams get a little reward for consistency during the season with the home semi. If that isnt the way to go, then set the venues early (like every other year) and whoever finishes 1st, 2nd, 3rd etc plays at the allocated venue regardless of whos home ground it is. To use the excuse of maximising profits is folly, its a semi final game with multiple teams/supporters etc, the gates will be the same regardless. Is there something fishy going on again? :dunno:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
footylover
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Spud
Aug 11 2011, 11:10 AM
The people on here seem to know what's going on and are prepared to say what they know.
I have asked my club and they don't know
So I will ask here

What is the points system. I think I know how it applies to my club,but how does it apply to the bulls, eagles and Roos

They are really strong.from what I have seen they have huge depth
If all there players were cleared from another district which they were I checked the sporting pulse rant they 25 points or 10 points

My club says we can't stock up on new players as we are close, but if you go 10 for 60 players that's way over

I am not winging, but if am going to get beat, I want to get beat fair

Can someone help please
If you go back through th pages this discussion has been had a few times at easts we have alot of 2 point players with juionrs and players that have been with the club for 4 years or more which makes room for the couple of 40 piont players we have ...
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
macbull
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Spud
Aug 11 2011, 11:10 AM
The people on here seem to know what's going on and are prepared to say what they know.
I have asked my club and they don't know
So I will ask here

What is the points system. I think I know how it applies to my club,but how does it apply to the bulls, eagles and Roos

They are really strong.from what I have seen they have huge depth
If all there players were cleared from another district which they were I checked the sporting pulse rant they 25 points or 10 points

My club says we can't stock up on new players as we are close, but if you go 10 for 60 players that's way over

I am not winging, but if am going to get beat, I want to get beat fair

Can someone help please
Welcome Spud - have you seen Bulls play alot this year? last 5 games we have played with under 17 palyers of the allowed 20 a game, some games with only 15 due to injury and suspension - we have a squad of 25 players to choose from and being a new club we had most players as 2 point players and a few transfers from Group clubs as 25 point players - our max points used i think this year has been 70 points of the 180 allocated to 2 nd div - we sit in 3rd been beat by lower placed teams this year and also beat higher teams not overly strong really and playing in a division that suits us :correct:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Spud
Aug 11 2011, 11:10 AM
The people on here seem to know what's going on and are prepared to say what they know.
I have asked my club and they don't know
So I will ask here

What is the points system. I think I know how it applies to my club,but how does it apply to the bulls, eagles and Roos

They are really strong.from what I have seen they have huge depth
If all there players were cleared from another district which they were I checked the sporting pulse rant they 25 points or 10 points

My club says we can't stock up on new players as we are close, but if you go 10 for 60 players that's way over

I am not winging, but if am going to get beat, I want to get beat fair

Can someone help please
We have been the most investigated club in the Group, :correct: the group secretary looked at our junior records East and admitted that no other club would have the records we have kept. our senior club has been built with a lot of hard work in the past 6 years, if you have a look we dont loss to many players and that's a good sign that players have been looked after and enjoy playing for the club.

October last year we started contacting Juniors from our club to play and to keep under the point system which we have done all year, we have been open and transparent regarding any questions about the point system even going to the extreme that our points are on every program at every home game, we even forward our points to the opposing club when we send our team list through for the program. cant get anymore open than that. :correct:

But if you are trying to undermined the great competition the Group 6 is, you have to have a bit more of a clue on whats going on in the group, maybe stick to the Wests Junior League side :laughing:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
macbull
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Blue Devil
Aug 11 2011, 01:38 PM
Spud
Aug 11 2011, 11:10 AM
The people on here seem to know what's going on and are prepared to say what they know.
I have asked my club and they don't know
So I will ask here

What is the points system. I think I know how it applies to my club,but how does it apply to the bulls, eagles and Roos

They are really strong.from what I have seen they have huge depth
If all there players were cleared from another district which they were I checked the sporting pulse rant they 25 points or 10 points

My club says we can't stock up on new players as we are close, but if you go 10 for 60 players that's way over

I am not winging, but if am going to get beat, I want to get beat fair

Can someone help please
We have been the most investigated club in the Group, :correct: the group secretary looked at our junior records East and admitted that no other club would have the records we have kept. our senior club has been built with a lot of hard work in the past 6 years, if you have a look we dont loss to many players and that's a good sign that players have been looked after and enjoy playing for the club.

October last year we started contacting Juniors from our club to play and to keep under the point system which we have done all year, we have been open and transparent regarding any questions about the point system even going to the extreme that our points are on every program at every home game, we even forward our points to the opposing club when we send our team list through for the program. cant get anymore open than that. :correct:

But if you are trying to undermined the great competition the Group 6 is, you have to have a bit more of a clue on whats going on in the group, maybe stick to the Wests Junior League side :laughing:
What club are you associated with Spud :dunno:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
What a great backpage story from Sean Cunningham and a game worthy of a great writeup, but read the comments from one BOBCAT, will someone give this bloke a rope!

http://www.macarthuradvertiser.com.au/news/local/sport/rugby-league/eagles-set-to-swoop/2254592.aspx
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
disco stu
Member Avatar
Country Origin
[ *  *  *  *  * ]
Blue Devil
Aug 11 2011, 02:03 PM
What a great backpage story from Sean Cunningham and a game worthy of a great writeup, but read the comments from one BOBCAT, will someone give this bloke a rope!

http://www.macarthuradvertiser.com.au/news/local/sport/rugby-league/eagles-set-to-swoop/2254592.aspx
Well he's obviously commenting there because he is in the sin bin on this forum for bagging out clubs. People have been warned about bagging out clubs on this forum :finger: , if he continues on his return he will be banned for good, he wont be the first to be banned for this either if he does continue , just ask some of the appin stirrers that arent here now.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Spud
Ball Boy
[ * ]
macbull
Aug 11 2011, 01:55 PM
Blue Devil
Aug 11 2011, 01:38 PM
Spud
Aug 11 2011, 11:10 AM
The people on here seem to know what's going on and are prepared to say what they know.
I have asked my club and they don't know
So I will ask here

What is the points system. I think I know how it applies to my club,but how does it apply to the bulls, eagles and Roos

They are really strong.from what I have seen they have huge depth
If all there players were cleared from another district which they were I checked the sporting pulse rant they 25 points or 10 points

My club says we can't stock up on new players as we are close, but if you go 10 for 60 players that's way over

I am not winging, but if am going to get beat, I want to get beat fair

Can someone help please
We have been the most investigated club in the Group, :correct: the group secretary looked at our junior records East and admitted that no other club would have the records we have kept. our senior club has been built with a lot of hard work in the past 6 years, if you have a look we dont loss to many players and that's a good sign that players have been looked after and enjoy playing for the club.

October last year we started contacting Juniors from our club to play and to keep under the point system which we have done all year, we have been open and transparent regarding any questions about the point system even going to the extreme that our points are on every program at every home game, we even forward our points to the opposing club when we send our team list through for the program. cant get anymore open than that. :correct:

But if you are trying to undermined the great competition the Group 6 is, you have to have a bit more of a clue on whats going on in the group, maybe stick to the Wests Junior League side :laughing:
What club are you associated with Spud :dunno:
I was going to put my club Dow but not now
Jesse all I du
I'd was ask a question and try to learn and then I get bashed as undermining our comp by devil
Maybe devil should remember that yo were invited in OUR comp
The reason I asked is I was told you were a new club and do not have juniors
If you are a new club then all players are new players under what I read
Camden get 2 point players from Camden
Moss vale get 2point players from moss vale
If you do not have juniors how can you get 2 point players

Pretty simple question

But if the rules are allowing it the ok then

But don't bash me for asking a question I am nit undermining anything
You say you develop devil then Why don't you let me learn and not bash me
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
disco stu
Aug 11 2011, 07:44 AM
tc6_11
Aug 10 2011, 09:58 PM
I think in the forum rules it says you cannot bag the organisers of the comp, well i'm not going to do that, but the way in which the finals series is being conducted is nothing short of a joke.
The Group has failed to set which fixtures will be played at which ground. From what we know, in week 1 Saturday night will be played at Picton, and Sunday will be hosted by Camden.
Normally the saturday night fixture is elimination 4 v 5 and Sunday is 2 v 3.
But the only thing that is guaranteed is that Picton will get a home game on the Saturday night, because the Group want to maximise Gate Takings, Nevermind the side that toils away all year and finishes well ahead of them. So when Oakdale finish 2nd, and Picton finish 3rd, Picton will host Oakdale on a Saturday night (Dejavu). Or when Picton finish 4th and Mittagong finish 5th, Picton will host Mittagong.
I certainly hope that this nonsense is not going to continue into week 2.
It is extremely un-professional
I think your a bit paranoid tc, maybe your more worried about history repeating. At the end of the day it doesn't matter where you play its about how a team mentally prepares for a game, a footy field is the same no matter where you play :correct:
There is no paranoia about it Disco!
You've got your head in the sand mate, Your quick to defend are you a board member?
I am annoyed that the games haven't been determined as yet, and that the thought process is to wait and see who finishes where.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
footylover
Aug 11 2011, 09:16 AM
disco stu
Aug 11 2011, 07:44 AM
tc6_11
Aug 10 2011, 09:58 PM
I think in the forum rules it says you cannot bag the organisers of the comp, well i'm not going to do that, but the way in which the finals series is being conducted is nothing short of a joke.
The Group has failed to set which fixtures will be played at which ground. From what we know, in week 1 Saturday night will be played at Picton, and Sunday will be hosted by Camden.
Normally the saturday night fixture is elimination 4 v 5 and Sunday is 2 v 3.
But the only thing that is guaranteed is that Picton will get a home game on the Saturday night, because the Group want to maximise Gate Takings, Nevermind the side that toils away all year and finishes well ahead of them. So when Oakdale finish 2nd, and Picton finish 3rd, Picton will host Oakdale on a Saturday night (Dejavu). Or when Picton finish 4th and Mittagong finish 5th, Picton will host Mittagong.
I certainly hope that this nonsense is not going to continue into week 2.
It is extremely un-professional
I think your a bit paranoid tc, maybe your more worried about history repeating. At the end of the day it doesn't matter where you play its about how a team mentally prepares for a game, a footy field is the same no matter where you play :correct:
Well we at the eagles haven't had a home game all year so it won't matter to us were we play ... And the game between 2nd and3rd is not elimination any so what does it matter ???
Geez some people amaze me.
Does it matter?????
Nah mate it don't, because a 2 v 3 victory gets you to 1 win away from a grand final, and a 2 v 3 loss gets you to within 1 game of elimination.
Just book it in already.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
footylover
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
tc6_11
Aug 11 2011, 04:41 PM
footylover
Aug 11 2011, 09:16 AM
disco stu
Aug 11 2011, 07:44 AM
tc6_11
Aug 10 2011, 09:58 PM
I think in the forum rules it says you cannot bag the organisers of the comp, well i'm not going to do that, but the way in which the finals series is being conducted is nothing short of a joke.
The Group has failed to set which fixtures will be played at which ground. From what we know, in week 1 Saturday night will be played at Picton, and Sunday will be hosted by Camden.
Normally the saturday night fixture is elimination 4 v 5 and Sunday is 2 v 3.
But the only thing that is guaranteed is that Picton will get a home game on the Saturday night, because the Group want to maximise Gate Takings, Nevermind the side that toils away all year and finishes well ahead of them. So when Oakdale finish 2nd, and Picton finish 3rd, Picton will host Oakdale on a Saturday night (Dejavu). Or when Picton finish 4th and Mittagong finish 5th, Picton will host Mittagong.
I certainly hope that this nonsense is not going to continue into week 2.
It is extremely un-professional
I think your a bit paranoid tc, maybe your more worried about history repeating. At the end of the day it doesn't matter where you play its about how a team mentally prepares for a game, a footy field is the same no matter where you play :correct:
Well we at the eagles haven't had a home game all year so it won't matter to us were we play ... And the game between 2nd and3rd is not elimination any so what does it matter ???
Geez some people amaze me.
Does it matter?????
Nah mate it don't, because a 2 v 3 victory gets you to 1 win away from a grand final, and a 2 v 3 loss gets you to within 1 game of elimination.
Just book it in already.
Of course it's a big game but I don't think having a home game is going to help to much apart from the road trip to mossvale ...
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
oparnz82
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
I dont think the point is whether or not there is a home ground advantage! thats not the point here!. Its more a case of why is the group holding off on naming which venue will be used for each semi. Name the venues and if ur lucky enough to have a home game thats great, but by doing what they are doing is not really ethical or equitable on principal and can even be seen as a conflict of interest or favouritism. This course of action is unprecedented in group 6 , anyone care to disagree or comment?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Black&White
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
It's all about the money as far as the Group is concerned this year.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
macbull
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Spud
Aug 11 2011, 04:34 PM
macbull
Aug 11 2011, 01:55 PM
Blue Devil
Aug 11 2011, 01:38 PM
Spud
Aug 11 2011, 11:10 AM
The people on here seem to know what's going on and are prepared to say what they know.
I have asked my club and they don't know
So I will ask here

What is the points system. I think I know how it applies to my club,but how does it apply to the bulls, eagles and Roos

They are really strong.from what I have seen they have huge depth
If all there players were cleared from another district which they were I checked the sporting pulse rant they 25 points or 10 points

My club says we can't stock up on new players as we are close, but if you go 10 for 60 players that's way over

I am not winging, but if am going to get beat, I want to get beat fair

Can someone help please
We have been the most investigated club in the Group, :correct: the group secretary looked at our junior records East and admitted that no other club would have the records we have kept. our senior club has been built with a lot of hard work in the past 6 years, if you have a look we dont loss to many players and that's a good sign that players have been looked after and enjoy playing for the club.

October last year we started contacting Juniors from our club to play and to keep under the point system which we have done all year, we have been open and transparent regarding any questions about the point system even going to the extreme that our points are on every program at every home game, we even forward our points to the opposing club when we send our team list through for the program. cant get anymore open than that. :correct:

But if you are trying to undermined the great competition the Group 6 is, you have to have a bit more of a clue on whats going on in the group, maybe stick to the Wests Junior League side :laughing:
What club are you associated with Spud :dunno:
I was going to put my club Dow but not now
Jesse all I du
I'd was ask a question and try to learn and then I get bashed as undermining our comp by devil
Maybe devil should remember that yo were invited in OUR comp
The reason I asked is I was told you were a new club and do not have juniors
If you are a new club then all players are new players under what I read
Camden get 2 point players from Camden
Moss vale get 2point players from moss vale
If you do not have juniors how can you get 2 point players

Pretty simple question

But if the rules are allowing it the ok then

But don't bash me for asking a question I am nit undermining anything
You say you develop devil then Why don't you let me learn and not bash me
so what club are you aligned with spud? or you just trolling :dunno:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
foal
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
tc6_11
Aug 10 2011, 09:58 PM
I think in the forum rules it says you cannot bag the organisers of the comp, well i'm not going to do that, but the way in which the finals series is being conducted is nothing short of a joke.
The Group has failed to set which fixtures will be played at which ground. From what we know, in week 1 Saturday night will be played at Picton, and Sunday will be hosted by Camden.
Normally the saturday night fixture is elimination 4 v 5 and Sunday is 2 v 3.
But the only thing that is guaranteed is that Picton will get a home game on the Saturday night, because the Group want to maximise Gate Takings, Nevermind the side that toils away all year and finishes well ahead of them. So when Oakdale finish 2nd, and Picton finish 3rd, Picton will host Oakdale on a Saturday night (Dejavu). Or when Picton finish 4th and Mittagong finish 5th, Picton will host Mittagong.
I certainly hope that this nonsense is not going to continue into week 2.
It is extremely un-professional
TC! Loving that we may get you on a Saturday night at Picton. Loving it! And loving that there is a sense of deja vu about it. Here's hoping history repeats itself. We do love to play the Workers in Semi Finals!

However, regarding the actual point you're making - you are absolutely correct. The way this is handled these days is completely unethical, and downright wrong. I see nothing wrong with the old system, where various semi-finals were awarded to various clubs, early in the season. Just another in a long list of farcical decisions our group has come up with of late. It's a shame, because the standard of footy, across the board, is so good and we don't need these controversies detracting from it.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
oparnz82
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Foal its refreshing to see that someone on this forum has intelligence, common sense, morality, vision and an impartial view of what is going on. It seems to be missing a lot of the time on this forum. Although it is entertaining and all opinions are valued here, the game/comp is bigger than a handful of people making decisions that affect all clubs with little or no consultation with group 6 club committee members. Surely these decisions need to be made in consultation with all clubs via meetings beforehand and voted on. Not dictated to clubs (via meetings) AFTER all important decisions are made. Please people any thoughts..
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
foal
Aug 11 2011, 09:50 PM
tc6_11
Aug 10 2011, 09:58 PM
I think in the forum rules it says you cannot bag the organisers of the comp, well i'm not going to do that, but the way in which the finals series is being conducted is nothing short of a joke.
The Group has failed to set which fixtures will be played at which ground. From what we know, in week 1 Saturday night will be played at Picton, and Sunday will be hosted by Camden.
Normally the saturday night fixture is elimination 4 v 5 and Sunday is 2 v 3.
But the only thing that is guaranteed is that Picton will get a home game on the Saturday night, because the Group want to maximise Gate Takings, Nevermind the side that toils away all year and finishes well ahead of them. So when Oakdale finish 2nd, and Picton finish 3rd, Picton will host Oakdale on a Saturday night (Dejavu). Or when Picton finish 4th and Mittagong finish 5th, Picton will host Mittagong.
I certainly hope that this nonsense is not going to continue into week 2.
It is extremely un-professional
TC! Loving that we may get you on a Saturday night at Picton. Loving it! And loving that there is a sense of deja vu about it. Here's hoping history repeats itself. We do love to play the Workers in Semi Finals!

However, regarding the actual point you're making - you are absolutely correct. The way this is handled these days is completely unethical, and downright wrong. I see nothing wrong with the old system, where various semi-finals were awarded to various clubs, early in the season. Just another in a long list of farcical decisions our group has come up with of late. It's a shame, because the standard of footy, across the board, is so good and we don't need these controversies detracting from it.
LOL, i was merely citing an example and the dejavu thing was a bit of a dramatisation.
I'm sure i wont be complaining if it's us that gets the home ground advantage in week 3 of the finals, because the games are played at Oakdale in week 3. But that is my point, week 3 is set in concrete, it doesn't matter who is playing, the game will be to determine the last grand final spot, no ifs, no buts.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Mad Tiger
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Guys,

Heard a few whispers that Bargo will be entering a new side into the Group 6 competition next season, Any truth to this???

Keen to find out as just bought a house down there and with the young bloke starting playing next season (u 6's) was hoping he could play for his local club... If not whats the closest club to Bargo, Picton????
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · CRL Group 6 · Next Topic »
Poll Only


www.wests.co.nr is an unofficial forum run by volunteer Rugby League Supporters
Posts, messages, views, expressions or opinions on this forum DO NOT represent the official view of ANY Football Club.

Free Domains Hosting at .co.nr