Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

WE WANT A FAIR GO FOR OUR AREA, MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND MORE THAN 4 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM

Want to talk all things Wests? Click here for our Facebook Page
Locked Topic
Wests JRL Seniors Competition 2011; On Field Discussion ONLY - Other posts will be deleted -
Topic Started: Apr 4 2011, 09:42 AM (59,337 Views)
ctownlad
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Highlander
Sep 15 2011, 09:50 AM
ctownlad
Sep 15 2011, 07:23 AM
lovinfooty
Sep 14 2011, 08:58 PM
Blue Devil
Sep 13 2011, 10:29 PM
charlie boy
Sep 13 2011, 09:58 PM
lovinfooty
Sep 13 2011, 06:49 PM
If the players were looking for cash to play they would head out to Group 6 but as has been seen in the last few years some players asking for overs and having to come back to the Wests comp as with the point system out there they will start to pick and choose players. I could only think of 2 clubs in the Wests that could afford / would offer to pay "some" players, not all.
Unfortunatly for the Wests comp it isn't marketable as it gets no press past Casula and no name players to attract any attention. I can't remember the last ex-first grader that came back to the Wests Comp, can anyone else?
ray cashmere.... mac saints... a grade???
Ray Cashmere played for Mac Saints before he played for the Wests Tigers, so no he wasnt an ex NRL player playing in the Wests competition, If you want the answer Ronald Jones played for Collies in 2006, with the cashed up Stockwell, he would be the only ex NRL player in the Wests Juniors A Grade for 15 years, cannot remember anymore then him. :correct:
Ray wasn't even known when he played for Mac Saints and only his family would know what he is doing now! :dunno:

I forgot about that Collies team. Your right though, no one else of mention. Until they can get some more names or more than 5 teams (in A Grade) the comp isn't really a comp and can't be marketable, it is disappointing as a local.
Very True and West A grade has always been a 5 to 6 team competition with the false hope of more teams that never happen i have some questions as a local rate payer that follows local footy.

1 . why are our grounds so poor riddled with cricket pitches?why dont council do enough for rugby league look at Harliquins and Gunners soccer grounds to ours :nono:
2. why cant we get a better comp and attract decent players not thugs?
3. is management really doing a good job?
4. why did the combined comp not work are west management to blame?
5. why can group 6 run seniors yet west struggle.
6. if wests have a big junior base why does this not filter through to senior level? why why why??
7. why so many ugly incidents and are they dealt with properly?
8.why do we have 3 local teams playing in group 6 with plenty of media coverage yet west get none.
9. why are eagles so successful and yet no other local clubs bar City can match them.
10. why are players leaving west for group 6 is it better football or better disciplined?

I could go on and on yes bobcat west had A grade and reserve grade but look at it 5 team A grade?? is that a real comp where all teams make semi finals i mean West Tigers played semis and got the wooden spoon and a put together team at that? the whole west comp needs an overhaul and i know Highlander,Disco will jump on and say come on give them a go which is ok when your from down south in the highlands but what about the locals guys dont we deserve better and some answers why it doesn't work?? enough is enough when will it improve :angry:
Mate i might live in the highlands but played in ctown from 1987 till 2001 so dont think for one second i dont know what im talking about!!!

Hell i used to be the waterboy for the mighty claymore panthers back in 1993 when there was a decent firsts reserve comp!!!

W only ask everything to stay calm as we have had legal threats against this forum and 2 years ago it was shut down for a preiod of about 4 months!! Is this what you want?????? then you have no voice

Understand we are trying to keep the forum alive and not get any hassles as its meant to be for local football we know things aint perfect BUT what can we do
love the history lesson Highlander on your ctown background and dont want the forum shut down just asking why its so bad out here but easy to see why with people like bobcat and pigs head involved in the West comp i cant believe over the water line you have a semi pro comp yet we get thug league on dirt ridden cricket pitches with no future of promise just more of the same last 20 years :finger: cant believe we let the combined comp go its killed senior footy in ctown
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Highlander
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
The clubs need to lobby hard on the cricket pitches and with all new subdivisions there should be new grounds built so all sports covered!!

I know that Bowral, mittagong and moss vales grounds all once had cricket pithces but were fased out and all the clubs were happy as new wickets were built elsewhere to cover these!!

It shouldnt be so hard IMO but for some reason council dont get it right!!!

How fullwood res was lost to soccer is a discrace that was a top field to play on!!! :finger:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
macbull
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Pigshead
Sep 15 2011, 11:20 AM
ctownlad
Sep 15 2011, 07:23 AM
lovinfooty
Sep 14 2011, 08:58 PM
Blue Devil
Sep 13 2011, 10:29 PM
charlie boy
Sep 13 2011, 09:58 PM
lovinfooty
Sep 13 2011, 06:49 PM
If the players were looking for cash to play they would head out to Group 6 but as has been seen in the last few years some players asking for overs and having to come back to the Wests comp as with the point system out there they will start to pick and choose players. I could only think of 2 clubs in the Wests that could afford / would offer to pay "some" players, not all.
Unfortunatly for the Wests comp it isn't marketable as it gets no press past Casula and no name players to attract any attention. I can't remember the last ex-first grader that came back to the Wests Comp, can anyone else?
ray cashmere.... mac saints... a grade???
Ray Cashmere played for Mac Saints before he played for the Wests Tigers, so no he wasnt an ex NRL player playing in the Wests competition, If you want the answer Ronald Jones played for Collies in 2006, with the cashed up Stockwell, he would be the only ex NRL player in the Wests Juniors A Grade for 15 years, cannot remember anymore then him. :correct:
Ray wasn't even known when he played for Mac Saints and only his family would know what he is doing now! :dunno:

I forgot about that Collies team. Your right though, no one else of mention. Until they can get some more names or more than 5 teams (in A Grade) the comp isn't really a comp and can't be marketable, it is disappointing as a local.
Very True and West A grade has always been a 5 to 6 team competition with the false hope of more teams that never happen i have some questions as a local rate payer that follows local footy.

1 . why are our grounds so poor riddled with cricket pitches?why dont council do enough for rugby league look at Harliquins and Gunners soccer grounds to ours :nono:
2. why cant we get a better comp and attract decent players not thugs?
3. is management really doing a good job?
4. why did the combined comp not work are west management to blame?
5. why can group 6 run seniors yet west struggle.
6. if wests have a big junior base why does this not filter through to senior level? why why why??
7. why so many ugly incidents and are they dealt with properly?
8.why do we have 3 local teams playing in group 6 with plenty of media coverage yet west get none.
9. why are eagles so successful and yet no other local clubs bar City can match them.
10. why are players leaving west for group 6 is it better football or better disciplined?

I could go on and on yes bobcat west had A grade and reserve grade but look at it 5 team A grade?? is that a real comp where all teams make semi finals i mean West Tigers played semis and got the wooden spoon and a put together team at that? the whole west comp needs an overhaul and i know Highlander,Disco will jump on and say come on give them a go which is ok when your from down south in the highlands but what about the locals guys dont we deserve better and some answers why it doesn't work?? enough is enough when will it improve :angry:
Their is nothing wrong with the Wests Competition, you guys bagging it just can t handle that you have been thrown out of the area and we dont want you back, If ESA cant handle this years comp when there was nothing wrong with it, see ya :hey: People have worked hard and the structure has been formed and able to build on for many years, we dont need Group 6 or anyone from this area that wants to jump, and its typical of people that cant commit to the good people that has worked dam hard down at the Junior League head quatters.

All I can say to you guys Eagles, Roos and Bulls, you have no area, Campbelltown or Macquarie Fields dont want you, we dont care what you do and the Wests Competition has shown Group 6 which is the better product, "what your playing a Grand Final at Camden" we had a massive day at the Stadium, you cant better that, you guys will return with your tail between you legs, Oakdale will smash Eagles this week, Go Oakdale! the Bulls couldnt even beat Warragamba :laughing: well City say no more :laughing:
another keyboard warrior dribbler :drool: :drool: :drool:
as for mac fields not wanting us not sure what thats all about mac fields club doesnt even want itself they are glenquarie all stars now and the local buisnesses still sponsor us but figure that out glenquarie hotel wanted us but we declined and went with Ingleburn Hotel best pour in town :drink: we have 2 local mac fields buisness on board the pizza box for one if anyone wants a good feed call Dave from the pizza box
watch for us next year pigshead yotu will be quite surprised my friend ;) ;) ;)
Edited by disco stu, Sep 15 2011, 01:43 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
parra eels
Member Avatar
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
macbull
Sep 15 2011, 12:44 PM
Pigshead
Sep 15 2011, 11:20 AM
ctownlad
Sep 15 2011, 07:23 AM
lovinfooty
Sep 14 2011, 08:58 PM
Blue Devil
Sep 13 2011, 10:29 PM
charlie boy
Sep 13 2011, 09:58 PM
lovinfooty
Sep 13 2011, 06:49 PM
If the players were looking for cash to play they would head out to Group 6 but as has been seen in the last few years some players asking for overs and having to come back to the Wests comp as with the point system out there they will start to pick and choose players. I could only think of 2 clubs in the Wests that could afford / would offer to pay "some" players, not all.
Unfortunatly for the Wests comp it isn't marketable as it gets no press past Casula and no name players to attract any attention. I can't remember the last ex-first grader that came back to the Wests Comp, can anyone else?
ray cashmere.... mac saints... a grade???
Ray Cashmere played for Mac Saints before he played for the Wests Tigers, so no he wasnt an ex NRL player playing in the Wests competition, If you want the answer Ronald Jones played for Collies in 2006, with the cashed up Stockwell, he would be the only ex NRL player in the Wests Juniors A Grade for 15 years, cannot remember anymore then him. :correct:
Ray wasn't even known when he played for Mac Saints and only his family would know what he is doing now! :dunno:

I forgot about that Collies team. Your right though, no one else of mention. Until they can get some more names or more than 5 teams (in A Grade) the comp isn't really a comp and can't be marketable, it is disappointing as a local.
Very True and West A grade has always been a 5 to 6 team competition with the false hope of more teams that never happen i have some questions as a local rate payer that follows local footy.

1 . why are our grounds so poor riddled with cricket pitches?why dont council do enough for rugby league look at Harliquins and Gunners soccer grounds to ours :nono:
2. why cant we get a better comp and attract decent players not thugs?
3. is management really doing a good job?
4. why did the combined comp not work are west management to blame?
5. why can group 6 run seniors yet west struggle.
6. if wests have a big junior base why does this not filter through to senior level? why why why??
7. why so many ugly incidents and are they dealt with properly?
8.why do we have 3 local teams playing in group 6 with plenty of media coverage yet west get none.
9. why are eagles so successful and yet no other local clubs bar City can match them.
10. why are players leaving west for group 6 is it better football or better disciplined?

I could go on and on yes bobcat west had A grade and reserve grade but look at it 5 team A grade?? is that a real comp where all teams make semi finals i mean West Tigers played semis and got the wooden spoon and a put together team at that? the whole west comp needs an overhaul and i know Highlander,Disco will jump on and say come on give them a go which is ok when your from down south in the highlands but what about the locals guys dont we deserve better and some answers why it doesn't work?? enough is enough when will it improve :angry:
Their is nothing wrong with the Wests Competition, you guys bagging it just can t handle that you have been thrown out of the area and we dont want you back, If ESA cant handle this years comp when there was nothing wrong with it, see ya :hey: People have worked hard and the structure has been formed and able to build on for many years, we dont need Group 6 or anyone from this area that wants to jump, and its typical of people that cant commit to the good people that has worked dam hard down at the Junior League head quatters.

All I can say to you guys Eagles, Roos and Bulls, you have no area, Campbelltown or Macquarie Fields dont want you, we dont care what you do and the Wests Competition has shown Group 6 which is the better product, "what your playing a Grand Final at Camden" we had a massive day at the Stadium, you cant better that, you guys will return with your tail between you legs, Oakdale will smash Eagles this week, Go Oakdale! the Bulls couldnt even beat Warragamba :laughing: well City say no more :laughing:
another keyboard warrior dribbler :drool: :drool: :drool:
as for mac fields not wanting us not sure what thats all about mac fields club doesnt even want itself they are glenquarie all stars now and the local buisnesses still sponsor us but figure that out glenquarie hotel wanted us but we declined and went with Ingleburn Hotel best pour in town :drink: we have 2 local mac fields buisness on board the pizza box for one if anyone wants a good feed call Dave from the pizza box
watch for us next year pigshead yotu will be quite surprised my friend ;) ;) ;)
Pigs head bulls do have an area Camden and just for the record u wait and watch what we unleash next year :winner: :winner: :winner:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
charlie boy
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Pigshead
Sep 15 2011, 11:20 AM
ctownlad
Sep 15 2011, 07:23 AM
lovinfooty
Sep 14 2011, 08:58 PM
Blue Devil
Sep 13 2011, 10:29 PM
charlie boy
Sep 13 2011, 09:58 PM
lovinfooty
Sep 13 2011, 06:49 PM
If the players were looking for cash to play they would head out to Group 6 but as has been seen in the last few years some players asking for overs and having to come back to the Wests comp as with the point system out there they will start to pick and choose players. I could only think of 2 clubs in the Wests that could afford / would offer to pay "some" players, not all.
Unfortunatly for the Wests comp it isn't marketable as it gets no press past Casula and no name players to attract any attention. I can't remember the last ex-first grader that came back to the Wests Comp, can anyone else?
ray cashmere.... mac saints... a grade???
Ray Cashmere played for Mac Saints before he played for the Wests Tigers, so no he wasnt an ex NRL player playing in the Wests competition, If you want the answer Ronald Jones played for Collies in 2006, with the cashed up Stockwell, he would be the only ex NRL player in the Wests Juniors A Grade for 15 years, cannot remember anymore then him. :correct:
Ray wasn't even known when he played for Mac Saints and only his family would know what he is doing now! :dunno:

I forgot about that Collies team. Your right though, no one else of mention. Until they can get some more names or more than 5 teams (in A Grade) the comp isn't really a comp and can't be marketable, it is disappointing as a local.
Very True and West A grade has always been a 5 to 6 team competition with the false hope of more teams that never happen i have some questions as a local rate payer that follows local footy.

1 . why are our grounds so poor riddled with cricket pitches?why dont council do enough for rugby league look at Harliquins and Gunners soccer grounds to ours :nono:
2. why cant we get a better comp and attract decent players not thugs?
3. is management really doing a good job?
4. why did the combined comp not work are west management to blame?
5. why can group 6 run seniors yet west struggle.
6. if wests have a big junior base why does this not filter through to senior level? why why why??
7. why so many ugly incidents and are they dealt with properly?
8.why do we have 3 local teams playing in group 6 with plenty of media coverage yet west get none.
9. why are eagles so successful and yet no other local clubs bar City can match them.
10. why are players leaving west for group 6 is it better football or better disciplined?

I could go on and on yes bobcat west had A grade and reserve grade but look at it 5 team A grade?? is that a real comp where all teams make semi finals i mean West Tigers played semis and got the wooden spoon and a put together team at that? the whole west comp needs an overhaul and i know Highlander,Disco will jump on and say come on give them a go which is ok when your from down south in the highlands but what about the locals guys dont we deserve better and some answers why it doesn't work?? enough is enough when will it improve :angry:
Their is nothing wrong with the Wests Competition, you guys bagging it just can t handle that you have been thrown out of the area and we dont want you back, If ESA cant handle this years comp when there was nothing wrong with it, see ya :hey: People have worked hard and the structure has been formed and able to build on for many years, we dont need Group 6 or anyone from this area that wants to jump, and its typical of people that cant commit to the good people that has worked dam hard down at the Junior League head quatters.

All I can say to you guys Eagles, Roos and Bulls, you have no area, Campbelltown or Macquarie Fields dont want you, we dont care what you do and the Wests Competition has shown Group 6 which is the better product, "what your playing a Grand Final at Camden" we had a massive day at the Stadium, you cant better that, you guys will return with your tail between you legs, Oakdale will smash Eagles this week, Go Oakdale! the Bulls couldnt even beat Warragamba :laughing: well City say no more :laughing:
hahaha a stadium that has more empty sits then a a-league soccer match :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: mate u need to get out to the group 6 grand final and see how many people support their clubs and then u can rate whats a better atmosphere ????
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
FootyMum
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
Ozzy
Sep 15 2011, 08:54 AM
FootyMum
Sep 14 2011, 03:28 PM
Ronny
Sep 14 2011, 11:45 AM
What i cannot believe is how in the hell do they put ESA on the backpage of the paper, they were involved in an discusting fight, they have all but wipped out the 18's comp with all there rep players, they have whinged all year about the competition and when they finally get some real competition they start throwing punches to win the game, remember this side was down to 7 players, that isnt determination and skill, it is ill decipline.
and to make it worse, all there players have bragged about leaving the area going to Group 6, well what i seen on Sunday, see ya later Good Riddance!
:angry: Get over yourself, "they got real competition and they start throwing punches to win a game", grow up it wasn't a one sided fight mate and if you were there you would of seen that esa didnt throw the first punch, they were 17/18 year old boys who were playing mates and old team mates in a grand final and it got heated, it was also the team that the 16's played last year and beat in the grand final so it was going to be a volitile game to begin with.
And don't give me do-do that it was not determination but ill decipline, none of the 7 players left on the field did anything wrong and the way they made Collies look was embaressing for Colllies for those 10 minutes, and none of our players were ill deciplined to run from the bench and jump a player and get sent from the game...

ESA did not ask to become a team of the rep players that it is, it has been from good coaching and developed talent over many years not from stacking a team with them, and if you ad up the rep players Collies had (including 2 from ESA that went there) it was a pretty close number, so how dare you say we wiped out the comp. And if any of the players have been saying that they are going to Group 6 it is only because they have just completed a 16 round comp I believe and only played 9 games and are sick of not being able to play footy every week.

Really if you are going to come out and bag a bunch of kids and a club so badly have the gust to say who you are and where are you from... and if you are so worried about who was on the back page of the paper take out an advertisment and have whatever team you want in there
Ronny, you are a Joke. obviously a sore loser from Collies, yes OUR 18's are going to GROUP 6, why wouldnt we, look at what we got dished up this year and then we have to deal with your club Grand Final day, our boys will follow Dennis to a new club where we can play footy every week, and everyone knows it was your club that cost everyone the combined competition! Pull your head in mate, we won and that was with 7 MEN
Ozzy I do not believe you are a member or player of ESA, in previous comments of yours on this forum you have either questioned the club on it's plans or told me our executive are to blame for the position the 18's were in this year.
You are in no position to assume or to say where OUR 18's will be next year or who they will follow as no decision has been made by the club or the players, this will be made when the JL let us no soon what position and where the competition will be in next year.
I apreciate the support of the team now but please do not come on here stirring the pot for ESA or Dennis.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
ctownlad
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
FootyMum
Sep 15 2011, 03:09 PM
Ozzy
Sep 15 2011, 08:54 AM
FootyMum
Sep 14 2011, 03:28 PM
Ronny
Sep 14 2011, 11:45 AM
What i cannot believe is how in the hell do they put ESA on the backpage of the paper, they were involved in an discusting fight, they have all but wipped out the 18's comp with all there rep players, they have whinged all year about the competition and when they finally get some real competition they start throwing punches to win the game, remember this side was down to 7 players, that isnt determination and skill, it is ill decipline.
and to make it worse, all there players have bragged about leaving the area going to Group 6, well what i seen on Sunday, see ya later Good Riddance!
:angry: Get over yourself, "they got real competition and they start throwing punches to win a game", grow up it wasn't a one sided fight mate and if you were there you would of seen that esa didnt throw the first punch, they were 17/18 year old boys who were playing mates and old team mates in a grand final and it got heated, it was also the team that the 16's played last year and beat in the grand final so it was going to be a volitile game to begin with.
And don't give me do-do that it was not determination but ill decipline, none of the 7 players left on the field did anything wrong and the way they made Collies look was embaressing for Colllies for those 10 minutes, and none of our players were ill deciplined to run from the bench and jump a player and get sent from the game...

ESA did not ask to become a team of the rep players that it is, it has been from good coaching and developed talent over many years not from stacking a team with them, and if you ad up the rep players Collies had (including 2 from ESA that went there) it was a pretty close number, so how dare you say we wiped out the comp. And if any of the players have been saying that they are going to Group 6 it is only because they have just completed a 16 round comp I believe and only played 9 games and are sick of not being able to play footy every week.

Really if you are going to come out and bag a bunch of kids and a club so badly have the gust to say who you are and where are you from... and if you are so worried about who was on the back page of the paper take out an advertisment and have whatever team you want in there
Ronny, you are a Joke. obviously a sore loser from Collies, yes OUR 18's are going to GROUP 6, why wouldnt we, look at what we got dished up this year and then we have to deal with your club Grand Final day, our boys will follow Dennis to a new club where we can play footy every week, and everyone knows it was your club that cost everyone the combined competition! Pull your head in mate, we won and that was with 7 MEN
Ozzy I do not believe you are a member or player of ESA, in previous comments of yours on this forum you have either questioned the club on it's plans or told me our executive are to blame for the position the 18's were in this year.
You are in no position to assume or to say where OUR 18's will be next year or who they will follow as no decision has been made by the club or the players, this will be made when the JL let us no soon what position and where the competition will be in next year.
I apreciate the support of the team now but please do not come on here stirring the pot for ESA or Dennis.
Footymum west will do the same old spin about more teams and the likes and wont deliver :nono: take your boys where they can get good clean football where that is has to be better then what is dished up out our way you will only be going backwards in west is my thoughts on it.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
ctownlad
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
FootyMum
Sep 15 2011, 03:09 PM
Ozzy
Sep 15 2011, 08:54 AM
FootyMum
Sep 14 2011, 03:28 PM
Ronny
Sep 14 2011, 11:45 AM
What i cannot believe is how in the hell do they put ESA on the backpage of the paper, they were involved in an discusting fight, they have all but wipped out the 18's comp with all there rep players, they have whinged all year about the competition and when they finally get some real competition they start throwing punches to win the game, remember this side was down to 7 players, that isnt determination and skill, it is ill decipline.
and to make it worse, all there players have bragged about leaving the area going to Group 6, well what i seen on Sunday, see ya later Good Riddance!
:angry: Get over yourself, "they got real competition and they start throwing punches to win a game", grow up it wasn't a one sided fight mate and if you were there you would of seen that esa didnt throw the first punch, they were 17/18 year old boys who were playing mates and old team mates in a grand final and it got heated, it was also the team that the 16's played last year and beat in the grand final so it was going to be a volitile game to begin with.
And don't give me do-do that it was not determination but ill decipline, none of the 7 players left on the field did anything wrong and the way they made Collies look was embaressing for Colllies for those 10 minutes, and none of our players were ill deciplined to run from the bench and jump a player and get sent from the game...

ESA did not ask to become a team of the rep players that it is, it has been from good coaching and developed talent over many years not from stacking a team with them, and if you ad up the rep players Collies had (including 2 from ESA that went there) it was a pretty close number, so how dare you say we wiped out the comp. And if any of the players have been saying that they are going to Group 6 it is only because they have just completed a 16 round comp I believe and only played 9 games and are sick of not being able to play footy every week.

Really if you are going to come out and bag a bunch of kids and a club so badly have the gust to say who you are and where are you from... and if you are so worried about who was on the back page of the paper take out an advertisment and have whatever team you want in there
Ronny, you are a Joke. obviously a sore loser from Collies, yes OUR 18's are going to GROUP 6, why wouldnt we, look at what we got dished up this year and then we have to deal with your club Grand Final day, our boys will follow Dennis to a new club where we can play footy every week, and everyone knows it was your club that cost everyone the combined competition! Pull your head in mate, we won and that was with 7 MEN
Ozzy I do not believe you are a member or player of ESA, in previous comments of yours on this forum you have either questioned the club on it's plans or told me our executive are to blame for the position the 18's were in this year.
You are in no position to assume or to say where OUR 18's will be next year or who they will follow as no decision has been made by the club or the players, this will be made when the JL let us no soon what position and where the competition will be in next year.
I apreciate the support of the team now but please do not come on here stirring the pot for ESA or Dennis.
wont matter what the club says or does players will follow where they believe is best for thier footy not the club.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
footylover
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Pigshead
Sep 15 2011, 11:20 AM
ctownlad
Sep 15 2011, 07:23 AM
lovinfooty
Sep 14 2011, 08:58 PM
Blue Devil
Sep 13 2011, 10:29 PM
charlie boy
Sep 13 2011, 09:58 PM
lovinfooty
Sep 13 2011, 06:49 PM
If the players were looking for cash to play they would head out to Group 6 but as has been seen in the last few years some players asking for overs and having to come back to the Wests comp as with the point system out there they will start to pick and choose players. I could only think of 2 clubs in the Wests that could afford / would offer to pay "some" players, not all.
Unfortunatly for the Wests comp it isn't marketable as it gets no press past Casula and no name players to attract any attention. I can't remember the last ex-first grader that came back to the Wests Comp, can anyone else?
ray cashmere.... mac saints... a grade???
Ray Cashmere played for Mac Saints before he played for the Wests Tigers, so no he wasnt an ex NRL player playing in the Wests competition, If you want the answer Ronald Jones played for Collies in 2006, with the cashed up Stockwell, he would be the only ex NRL player in the Wests Juniors A Grade for 15 years, cannot remember anymore then him. :correct:
Ray wasn't even known when he played for Mac Saints and only his family would know what he is doing now! :dunno:

I forgot about that Collies team. Your right though, no one else of mention. Until they can get some more names or more than 5 teams (in A Grade) the comp isn't really a comp and can't be marketable, it is disappointing as a local.
Very True and West A grade has always been a 5 to 6 team competition with the false hope of more teams that never happen i have some questions as a local rate payer that follows local footy.

1 . why are our grounds so poor riddled with cricket pitches?why dont council do enough for rugby league look at Harliquins and Gunners soccer grounds to ours :nono:
2. why cant we get a better comp and attract decent players not thugs?
3. is management really doing a good job?
4. why did the combined comp not work are west management to blame?
5. why can group 6 run seniors yet west struggle.
6. if wests have a big junior base why does this not filter through to senior level? why why why??
7. why so many ugly incidents and are they dealt with properly?
8.why do we have 3 local teams playing in group 6 with plenty of media coverage yet west get none.
9. why are eagles so successful and yet no other local clubs bar City can match them.
10. why are players leaving west for group 6 is it better football or better disciplined?

I could go on and on yes bobcat west had A grade and reserve grade but look at it 5 team A grade?? is that a real comp where all teams make semi finals i mean West Tigers played semis and got the wooden spoon and a put together team at that? the whole west comp needs an overhaul and i know Highlander,Disco will jump on and say come on give them a go which is ok when your from down south in the highlands but what about the locals guys dont we deserve better and some answers why it doesn't work?? enough is enough when will it improve :angry:
Their is nothing wrong with the Wests Competition, you guys bagging it just can t handle that you have been thrown out of the area and we dont want you back, If ESA cant handle this years comp when there was nothing wrong with it, see ya :hey: People have worked hard and the structure has been formed and able to build on for many years, we dont need Group 6 or anyone from this area that wants to jump, and its typical of people that cant commit to the good people that has worked dam hard down at the Junior League head quatters.

All I can say to you guys Eagles, Roos and Bulls, you have no area, Campbelltown or Macquarie Fields dont want you, we dont care what you do and the Wests Competition has shown Group 6 which is the better product, "what your playing a Grand Final at Camden" we had a massive day at the Stadium, you cant better that, you guys will return with your tail between you legs, Oakdale will smash Eagles this week, Go Oakdale! the Bulls couldnt even beat Warragamba :laughing: well City say no more :laughing:
Tell me this then if campbelltown dosent want us then why do we have so many sponsers from the area and they didn't sponser any of the wests clubs ??? We would put 40 on minto and how can you say you had a good comp have a think about the year you had and if you think that was good then you don't know to much about footy do you ...
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
ctownlad
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Mate of mine says Minto boys have all mostly retired and the team will disbaned in 2012 is that right does anyone know and be a shame being west best team.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
ctownlad
Sep 14 2011, 02:07 PM
bobcat
Sep 14 2011, 01:47 PM
disco stu
Sep 14 2011, 09:31 AM
Wests chairman Wayne Hardy-Smith said the quality and standard of rugby league on both days was exceptional as was the the sportsmanship displayed by all involved. “It was a credit to everyone: the players, coaches, managers, officials and spectators,” he said.

He thanked Campbelltown Council for preparing the stadium and also Wests Tigers recruitment officer Warren McDonnell, development officer Ben Rogers and fitness coach John Skandalis for adding their support and encouragment with their presence.
Great work by the Wests JL to get the seniors up and running. Of course losing the combined competition made it tough on everyone, but the loyal clubs got through it and were rewarded on GF day.
:clap: Minto are a real good A Grade team and deserved there win. But great work by Titans in there first year and All Saints who stayed strong and turned down Group 6's attempts to turn them as well.
LCC, first go in seniors and a competition win over local arch rivals Titans. Old Darcy just can't jag a win, but he's there every year and that says a lot about him and his coaching, particularly to do what a new club has done in first year of operation. Titans are easy the club of the year in Wests :winner: :winner:
LCC will be the new seniors power in Wests I predict.
ESA hopefully will hold it together because with all those great young juniors they have to be able to come through for you. Great win in the 18s- magnificent 7 great call- & whispers are that Collies are back in A Grade and Reserves in 2012.
The Chairman is correct. New teams will come in 2012, I'd like to see U/19s or 20s going as well.
And as for the Cascades Eagles & Leppington Kangaroos, whose smiling now?? :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

5 team a grade to 6 team agrade great call bobcat :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: how many juniors will titans steal from All Saints next year bobcat and will that cripple them in 2-3 years???? yes west got a comp all be it 5 teams and struggled along all year but the on and off field voilence is all that most people will remember sadly people still talking about the pres getting snotted :fight: and all ins and what not will this all be cleaned up next year bobcat or will it be swept under the rug like all other ugly incidents :nono:
we wonder why the combined comp ended :finger: let group 6 run seniors and west the kiddies problem solved :winner:
You shouldn’t write anymore postings Bobdown, you look like a flip, who is laughing? we have had a great year, actually best ever in the clubs 50th Anniversary year :clap: You should come to terms with the facts and that is we are not coming back, leave us out of your pathetic remarks, we are a Group 6 Club, our players have had a great year, the Rugby League has been the best we have ever seen. We have had great support from the Group and we couldnt be happier :)

One more note, your talent to pick a good coach in the Wests competition has a lot to be desired, everyone you mention choked, you should of said what great coach's Nedel Saleh from Minto is and Warren Higbid from LCC, what a great turn around from both of these guys, Well Done :winner:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Black&White
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Pigshead
Sep 15 2011, 11:20 AM
Their is nothing wrong with the Wests Competition, you guys bagging it just can t handle that you have been thrown out of the area and we dont want you back, If ESA cant handle this years comp when there was nothing wrong with it, see ya :hey: People have worked hard and the structure has been formed and able to build on for many years, we dont need Group 6 or anyone from this area that wants to jump, and its typical of people that cant commit to the good people that has worked dam hard down at the Junior League head quatters.

All I can say to you guys Eagles, Roos and Bulls, you have no area, Campbelltown or Macquarie Fields dont want you, we dont care what you do and the Wests Competition has shown Group 6 which is the better product, "what your playing a Grand Final at Camden" we had a massive day at the Stadium, you cant better that, you guys will return with your tail between you legs, Oakdale will smash Eagles this week, Go Oakdale! the Bulls couldnt even beat Warragamba :laughing: well City say no more :laughing:
:rofl: :rofl: Every time I read this forum I find something hysterical to laugh about! :rofl: :rofl:

:rofl: :rofl: I don't know about running a football comp but West sure has some good comedians! :rofl: :rofl:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Black&White
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Blue Devil
Sep 15 2011, 05:46 PM
ctownlad
Sep 14 2011, 02:07 PM
bobcat
Sep 14 2011, 01:47 PM
disco stu
Sep 14 2011, 09:31 AM
Wests chairman Wayne Hardy-Smith said the quality and standard of rugby league on both days was exceptional as was the the sportsmanship displayed by all involved. “It was a credit to everyone: the players, coaches, managers, officials and spectators,” he said.

He thanked Campbelltown Council for preparing the stadium and also Wests Tigers recruitment officer Warren McDonnell, development officer Ben Rogers and fitness coach John Skandalis for adding their support and encouragment with their presence.
Great work by the Wests JL to get the seniors up and running. Of course losing the combined competition made it tough on everyone, but the loyal clubs got through it and were rewarded on GF day.
:clap: Minto are a real good A Grade team and deserved there win. But great work by Titans in there first year and All Saints who stayed strong and turned down Group 6's attempts to turn them as well.
LCC, first go in seniors and a competition win over local arch rivals Titans. Old Darcy just can't jag a win, but he's there every year and that says a lot about him and his coaching, particularly to do what a new club has done in first year of operation. Titans are easy the club of the year in Wests :winner: :winner:
LCC will be the new seniors power in Wests I predict.
ESA hopefully will hold it together because with all those great young juniors they have to be able to come through for you. Great win in the 18s- magnificent 7 great call- & whispers are that Collies are back in A Grade and Reserves in 2012.
The Chairman is correct. New teams will come in 2012, I'd like to see U/19s or 20s going as well.
And as for the Cascades Eagles & Leppington Kangaroos, whose smiling now?? :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

5 team a grade to 6 team agrade great call bobcat :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: how many juniors will titans steal from All Saints next year bobcat and will that cripple them in 2-3 years???? yes west got a comp all be it 5 teams and struggled along all year but the on and off field voilence is all that most people will remember sadly people still talking about the pres getting snotted :fight: and all ins and what not will this all be cleaned up next year bobcat or will it be swept under the rug like all other ugly incidents :nono:
we wonder why the combined comp ended :finger: let group 6 run seniors and west the kiddies problem solved :winner:
You shouldn’t write anymore postings Bobdown, you look like a flip, who is laughing? we have had a great year, actually best ever in the clubs 50th Anniversary year :clap: You should come to terms with the facts and that is we are not coming back, leave us out of your pathetic remarks, we are a Group 6 Club, our players have had a great year, the Rugby League has been the best we have ever seen. We have had great support from the Group and we couldnt be happier :)

One more note, your talent to pick a good coach in the Wests competition has a lot to be desired, everyone you mention choked, you should of said what great coach's Nedel Saleh from Minto is and Warren Higbid from LCC, what a great turn around from both of these guys, Well Done :winner:
Wooooo! Spooky Blue Devil.
I posted just after you. Maybe I am you!!!!! :rofl:
I have been accused of that before. :rofl: :rofl:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Fence sitter
Sep 15 2011, 09:10 AM
ctownlad
Sep 15 2011, 07:23 AM
lovinfooty
Sep 14 2011, 08:58 PM
Blue Devil
Sep 13 2011, 10:29 PM
charlie boy
Sep 13 2011, 09:58 PM
lovinfooty
Sep 13 2011, 06:49 PM
If the players were looking for cash to play they would head out to Group 6 but as has been seen in the last few years some players asking for overs and having to come back to the Wests comp as with the point system out there they will start to pick and choose players. I could only think of 2 clubs in the Wests that could afford / would offer to pay "some" players, not all.
Unfortunatly for the Wests comp it isn't marketable as it gets no press past Casula and no name players to attract any attention. I can't remember the last ex-first grader that came back to the Wests Comp, can anyone else?
ray cashmere.... mac saints... a grade???
Ray Cashmere played for Mac Saints before he played for the Wests Tigers, so no he wasnt an ex NRL player playing in the Wests competition, If you want the answer Ronald Jones played for Collies in 2006, with the cashed up Stockwell, he would be the only ex NRL player in the Wests Juniors A Grade for 15 years, cannot remember anymore then him. :correct:
Ray wasn't even known when he played for Mac Saints and only his family would know what he is doing now! :dunno:

I forgot about that Collies team. Your right though, no one else of mention. Until they can get some more names or more than 5 teams (in A Grade) the comp isn't really a comp and can't be marketable, it is disappointing as a local.
Very True and West A grade has always been a 5 to 6 team competition with the false hope of more teams that never happen i have some questions as a local rate payer that follows local footy.

1 . why are our grounds so poor riddled with cricket pitches?why dont council do enough for rugby league look at Harliquins and Gunners soccer grounds to ours :nono:
2. why cant we get a better comp and attract decent players not thugs?
3. is management really doing a good job?
4. why did the combined comp not work are west management to blame?
5. why can group 6 run seniors yet west struggle.
6. if wests have a big junior base why does this not filter through to senior level? why why why??
7. why so many ugly incidents and are they dealt with properly?
8.why do we have 3 local teams playing in group 6 with plenty of media coverage yet west get none.
9. why are eagles so successful and yet no other local clubs bar City can match them.
10. why are players leaving west for group 6 is it better football or better disciplined?

I could go on and on yes bobcat west had A grade and reserve grade but look at it 5 team A grade?? is that a real comp where all teams make semi finals i mean West Tigers played semis and got the wooden spoon and a put together team at that? the whole west comp needs an overhaul and i know Highlander,Disco will jump on and say come on give them a go which is ok when your from down south in the highlands but what about the locals guys dont we deserve better and some answers why it doesn't work?? enough is enough when will it improve :angry:
CTownLad, you write and sound like Blue Devil, are you a devil in disguise?
No young Fency, just because someone does a very good write up about whats wrong in the local competition, doesnt mean its me. once again I would swear on my family on this, this Campbelltown Lad is not me, I must agree on a lot of what he has written though, we have argued many of these points in the past :correct:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Black&White
Sep 15 2011, 05:49 PM
Pigshead
Sep 15 2011, 11:20 AM
Their is nothing wrong with the Wests Competition, you guys bagging it just can t handle that you have been thrown out of the area and we dont want you back, If ESA cant handle this years comp when there was nothing wrong with it, see ya :hey: People have worked hard and the structure has been formed and able to build on for many years, we dont need Group 6 or anyone from this area that wants to jump, and its typical of people that cant commit to the good people that has worked dam hard down at the Junior League head quatters.

All I can say to you guys Eagles, Roos and Bulls, you have no area, Campbelltown or Macquarie Fields dont want you, we dont care what you do and the Wests Competition has shown Group 6 which is the better product, "what your playing a Grand Final at Camden" we had a massive day at the Stadium, you cant better that, you guys will return with your tail between you legs, Oakdale will smash Eagles this week, Go Oakdale! the Bulls couldnt even beat Warragamba :laughing: well City say no more :laughing:
:rofl: :rofl: Every time I read this forum I find something hysterical to laugh about! :rofl: :rofl:

:rofl: :rofl: I don't know about running a football comp but West sure has some good comedians! :rofl: :rofl:
You are a funny man Piggy, are you Bobcats twin brother? It’s your competition and you can have it, we don’t want to come back and we won’t be coming back with our tails between our legs, we opted to play in a strong competition that suited our needs of 5 grades, we love the grounds we play at and the clubs we play against, our players, supporters and officials love our Sunday footy and we are already planning for life in Group 6 for 2012. You should do the comedy act at the Wests Juniors Presentation night, Get a grip on yourself :laughing:

To my alter ego Black and White, well I just posted before and after you, so maybe you are me, but if you are me who am I? I once played for Picton so I have a soft spot for the Black and Whites, so maybe I am Black and white so who are you? :cstars:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Highlander
Sep 15 2011, 11:55 AM
The clubs need to lobby hard on the cricket pitches and with all new subdivisions there should be new grounds built so all sports covered!!

I know that Bowral, mittagong and moss vales grounds all once had cricket pithces but were fased out and all the clubs were happy as new wickets were built elsewhere to cover these!!

It shouldnt be so hard IMO but for some reason council dont get it right!!!

How fullwood res was lost to soccer is a discrace that was a top field to play on!!! :finger:
We have tried this Highlander but to no avail, we offered to give the Cricket Waminda Oval number 1 as a full time Cricket Field, if we could transform Waminda Oval Number 2 into a full time Rugby League Field (No Cricket Pitch) some people don’t understand they are 2 different games played on 2 different surfaces, would you play Rugby League on a baseball field? We have also offered to Fence Waminda Oval Number 2 at the cost of the club, and yes it was a shame to see Fullwood Reserve given to soccer, played many games there myself and it was probably the best surface in Campbelltown, atmosphere was always scary :laughing:
Edited by Blue Devil, Sep 15 2011, 10:16 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Warriors78
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
busy old day on the forum
just got back from the rusey :cheers: :drink: :drink:
good luck bd and the eagles this sunday
do CAMPBELLTOWN proud!!!!!!!
Edited by Warriors78, Sep 15 2011, 08:12 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
ctownlad
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
got told Appin 3rd grade and Collies 18s have alliened for next year to play as Collies A grade and reserve grade in the West comp and the mail is very strong west offered free rego and boys i was talking to last night said something about Appin players leaving cause they were told they will be in first grade group 6 next year and have been told to deny they are going by west so group 6 dont know till after the grand final sunday,this is good new shows that we can attract teams to west and maybe the start of more to come.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Highlander
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Well the cat is out of the bag now IF TRUE
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
ctownlad
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Highlander
Sep 16 2011, 07:00 AM
Well the cat is out of the bag now IF TRUE
although it will be denied by Appin put money on it thats what ive been told ;) ;)
Edited by ctownlad, Sep 16 2011, 07:06 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · W.S.D.J.R.L · Next Topic »
Locked Topic


www.wests.co.nr is an unofficial forum run by volunteer Rugby League Supporters
Posts, messages, views, expressions or opinions on this forum DO NOT represent the official view of ANY Football Club.

Free Domains Hosting at .co.nr