Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

WE WANT A FAIR GO FOR OUR AREA, MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND MORE THAN 4 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM

Want to talk all things Wests? Click here for our Facebook Page
Locked Topic
Club House; For all Off Field Discussions
Topic Started: May 2 2011, 08:39 PM (19,011 Views)
Maverick
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Well I dont about you Eagle player but my my boys have never shyed away from playing the best. This may or may not be a good thing, but so far I haven't heard any actual complaints from players about playing The Tigers side, and I was worried at first. In fact most players I have spoken to consider it a personal challenge to play them win or lose. The better the competition you play the higher standard of football you need to achieve to be competitive.

My only issue is should they be allowed in the semi's, and take any prizemoney on offer.

There are probably more benefeits for those who play against the Tigers than for those playing with the Tigers as they have to play at their very best to try to compete.

Winning is great but experience is impossible to get unless you go there.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
FootyMum
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
Maverick
May 12 2011, 01:27 PM
Well I dont about you Eagle player but my my boys have never shyed away from playing the best. This may or may not be a good thing, but so far I haven't heard any actual complaints from players about playing The Tigers side, and I was worried at first. In fact most players I have spoken to consider it a personal challenge to play them win or lose. The better the competition you play the higher standard of football you need to achieve to be competitive.

My only issue is should they be allowed in the semi's, and take any prizemoney on offer.

There are probably more benefeits for those who play against the Tigers than for those playing with the Tigers as they have to play at their very best to try to compete.

Winning is great but experience is impossible to get unless you go there.
I think eagleplayer was talking about the 18's when he was said about teams not wanting to play not the a-grade.

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Maverick
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
EaglePlayer
May 12 2011, 12:38 PM
As a player,

and as for the west tigers side in a grade, there talented players that are obviousley on the fringe of the 20s or 1st grade or for other reasons, but these players are talented and are there for a reason, they shouldnt be thrown in a pub comp with blokes who are just trying to get some footy in on a sunday.
its not good for anyone, theres no competitions for them, theres the risk of injury and/or suspension for them for no good reason, there signed to play quality football not pub comps.
I am sure this talks about the West Tigers side Footy Mum
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
DevelopmentCoach
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
footybloke
Club Footy
[ * ]
Coinkydink indeed.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
FootyMum
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
Maverick
May 12 2011, 04:49 PM
EaglePlayer
May 12 2011, 12:38 PM
As a player,

and as for the west tigers side in a grade, there talented players that are obviousley on the fringe of the 20s or 1st grade or for other reasons, but these players are talented and are there for a reason, they shouldnt be thrown in a pub comp with blokes who are just trying to get some footy in on a sunday.
its not good for anyone, theres no competitions for them, theres the risk of injury and/or suspension for them for no good reason, there signed to play quality football not pub comps.
I am sure this talks about the West Tigers side Footy Mum
As a player, this is all a joke, all the ages, 1. the 18's is lopsided, obviousley esa arnt jsut gunna run through the comp, look at the weekend for example against lcc, but what does that mean for esa and lcc, they just play everyweek waiting to play in the grandfinal, wheres the fun in that.
2. teams talking of not playing teams because "there too good"
in the years ive been playing and im sure all yous blokes were the same, if you were coming up agaisnt the top team, there wasnt talk of forfiets, we were told to harden up and get on with it, how are you ment to become a good player or a "tough" player at that if your coach and team believe if there "too good" we wont play em,


The above is what eagleplayer was referring to with teams talking of not playing. He wasnt talking about the agrades not playing the west team but talk of some 18's teams saying they would not play.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
FootyMum
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
EaglePlayer
May 12 2011, 12:38 PM
As a player, this is all a joke, all the ages, 1. the 18's is lopsided, obviousley esa arnt jsut gunna run through the comp, look at the weekend for example against lcc, but what does that mean for esa and lcc, they just play everyweek waiting to play in the grandfinal, wheres the fun in that.
2. teams talking of not playing teams because "there too good"
in the years ive been playing and im sure all yous blokes were the same, if you were coming up agaisnt the top team, there wasnt talk of forfiets, we were told to harden up and get on with it, how are you ment to become a good player or a "tough" player at that if your coach and team believe if there "too good" we wont play em,

if thats what footy was about, sharks wouldnt of been seen for the last couple of years.

and as for the west tigers side in a grade, there talented players that are obviousley on the fringe of the 20s or 1st grade or for other reasons, but these players are talented and are there for a reason, they shouldnt be thrown in a pub comp with blokes who are just trying to get some footy in on a sunday.
its not good for anyone, theres no competitions for them, theres the risk of injury and/or suspension for them for no good reason, there signed to play quality football not pub comps.

The solution to this is maybe take a page from city and easts book( although dont annoy them as much as east.. )
and make a stand to the jl.

and as for the jl, i speak as a player, it seems like we arnt top priorty,
it seems like, power, and being able to make the calls that decide everything seems to be more of an interest to yous then getting us on the field, developing players and making a strong and thriving comp.
Lets make this clear, no impostors, are you an Eagle Vales St Andrews player, or a Campbelltown Eagles player?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
FootyMum
May 12 2011, 07:36 PM
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



So Footy Mum, do you know Eagleplayer and is he a player from ESA or East? I would hate for anyone from our club or an impostor with our clubs name that would bag the comp or junior league, I wouldn't stand for that! :laughing:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Maverick
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
FootyMum
May 12 2011, 07:36 PM
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



Hey footy mum back off.
I come from a soccer back ground having 3 boys that played, one fror 10 years, and I coached and my wife coached little ones. I was also the President of a junior soccer club, and loved doing so. So I was happy to listen to you and was happy to hear your comments and was mostly ageeing with you until now.

This forum has unfortunately become a war of words between clubs that went to G6 and Wests officials. And I hate that. I have 2 sons still playing RL, one for Eagles First Grade and one for All Saints first grade. If you have read any of my earlier posts I have always stated that I am unbiased, which I have to be, to be fair to my kids. Some dodo pretending to be Liverpool Titans got on hear and started bagging my kids club and as any parent would, you stick up for them.

As my son plays for C/Eagles I have nothing against them, in fact I am good friends with some of the officials.

If this young Eagle player is your son I can understand you jumping up and down as I would, but unfortunately he jumped on the forum the same day as I was fuming about comments made by this pretend Titan making comments about my sons club and he was not even from the Titans. (the Titans Have done well to hold their tongues)

If he is a young player I welcome him to the forum and apologise if I have offended him. and look forward to more comments (it would be great to get young peoples opinions instead of just the older heads) But tell him to be careful, as any comment made people can use to their own agenda.

Maybe if he introduced himself as a junior player would have been good.

Again excuse my scepticism but many people on here are not who they pretend to be and if eagle player is a junior I think I can speak for many. Welcome!!!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
footylover
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Blue Devil
May 12 2011, 08:25 PM
FootyMum
May 12 2011, 07:36 PM
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



So Footy Mum, do you know Eagleplayer and is he a player from ESA or East? I would hate for anyone from our club or an impostor with our clubs name that would bag the comp or junior league, I wouldn't stand for that! :laughing:
Yeah no one from easts would bag the jl would they :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Maverick
May 12 2011, 08:33 PM
FootyMum
May 12 2011, 07:36 PM
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



Hey footy mum back off.
I come from a soccer back ground having 3 boys that played, one fror 10 years, and I coached and my wife coached little ones. I was also the President of a junior soccer club, and loved doing so. So I was happy to listen to you and was happy to hear your comments and was mostly ageeing with you until now.

This forum has unfortunately become a war of words between clubs that went to G6 and Wests officials. And I hate that. I have 2 sons still playing RL, one for Eagles First Grade and one for All Saints first grade. If you have read any of my earlier posts I have always stated that I am unbiased, which I have to be, to be fair to my kids. Some dodo pretending to be Liverpool Titans got on hear and started bagging my kids club and as any parent would, you stick up for them.

As my son plays for C/Eagles I have nothing against them, in fact I am good friends with some of the officials.

If this young Eagle player is your son I can understand you jumping up and down as I would, but unfortunately he jumped on the forum the same day as I was fuming about comments made by this pretend Titan making comments about my sons club and he was not even from the Titans. (the Titans Have done well to hold their tongues)

If he is a young player I welcome him to the forum and apologise if I have offended him. and look forward to more comments (it would be great to get young peoples opinions instead of just the older heads) But tell him to be careful, as any comment made people can use to their own agenda.

Maybe if he introduced himself as a junior player would have been good.

Again excuse my scepticism but many people on here are not who they pretend to be and if eagle player is a junior I think I can speak for many. Welcome!!!
Hi Mav, no doubt we will talk about this one on Sunday, but Footymum is with the ESA club and by the sounds of it Eagleplayer is from ESA, not Campbelltown Eagles, probably poor timing for Eagleplayer. this is not an C/Town Eagles player and is someone that has concerns about the comp, good on him for making a stand, well done young whipper snapper, :clap:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Blue Devil
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
footylover
May 12 2011, 08:42 PM
Blue Devil
May 12 2011, 08:25 PM
FootyMum
May 12 2011, 07:36 PM
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



So Footy Mum, do you know Eagleplayer and is he a player from ESA or East? I would hate for anyone from our club or an impostor with our clubs name that would bag the comp or junior league, I wouldn't stand for that! :laughing:
Yeah no one from easts would bag the jl would they :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:
No we wouldnt do that, they do a great job, look how good the competition is going :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
mickrobbo
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
think we need a few beers :drink: in the club house get the mood back in swing :cheers: again lets all get on it :drink: ive just come back from the local gut full and sucking down some VB largies :drink: getting ready to watch the ranga vautin and darrel i got a tonn of guts but cant fight :fight: brohman ah he makes me sick the 5 chin tosser just wanna throw punches :fight: at his head his got me fired up now :angry: hey soccermum i found out what lol means to :laughing: me young bloke told me it means ya laughing :agree: love well im laughing at how no one can tell us if the wests tigers :weststigers: :weststigers: can win the jl comp :winner: was talking to a few old valley boys tonight they would have made sure the tigers never played round 2 well at least a few anyway cause they woulda had no heads the bluddgers :yeah: :yeah: :fight: :fight:
Edited by mickrobbo, May 12 2011, 08:53 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
mickrobbo
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Blue Devil
May 12 2011, 08:51 PM
footylover
May 12 2011, 08:42 PM
Blue Devil
May 12 2011, 08:25 PM
FootyMum
May 12 2011, 07:36 PM
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



So Footy Mum, do you know Eagleplayer and is he a player from ESA or East? I would hate for anyone from our club or an impostor with our clubs name that would bag the comp or junior league, I wouldn't stand for that! :laughing:
Yeah no one from easts would bag the jl would they :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:
No we wouldnt do that, they do a great job, look how good the competition is going :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:
easts bagging the junior league lol :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
FootyMum
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
Maverick
May 12 2011, 08:33 PM
FootyMum
May 12 2011, 07:36 PM
DevelopmentCoach
May 12 2011, 04:54 PM
Hmmm Livo Titan gets called out as a phony, and straight away we have an "EaglePlayer" show up. Coincidence?
Its disapointing to see post like the one above, this forum could be so more popular if others were not so quick to jump on new members without even giving them a chance.

I can vouch that eagleplayer is in no way the same person as Livo Titan, he is an actual junior player in the competition who felt like he wanted to have a say about the comp coming from a players point of view. Yet he was given no welcome on here and some automatically assumed he was someone he wasnt.

I have defended this forum and members on it to others who bag it out and say its nothing but a lot of rumour making troublemakers, I wont be making that mistake again.

Hmmmm so Maverick and footybloke may i suggest maybe next time a new member joins and would like to post what they feel about the comp or anything else just like you all do you might not be so quick to assume its a coincidence and actually welcome someone elses opinion.



Hey footy mum back off.
I come from a soccer back ground having 3 boys that played, one fror 10 years, and I coached and my wife coached little ones. I was also the President of a junior soccer club, and loved doing so. So I was happy to listen to you and was happy to hear your comments and was mostly ageeing with you until now.

This forum has unfortunately become a war of words between clubs that went to G6 and Wests officials. And I hate that. I have 2 sons still playing RL, one for Eagles First Grade and one for All Saints first grade. If you have read any of my earlier posts I have always stated that I am unbiased, which I have to be, to be fair to my kids. Some dodo pretending to be Liverpool Titans got on hear and started bagging my kids club and as any parent would, you stick up for them.

As my son plays for C/Eagles I have nothing against them, in fact I am good friends with some of the officials.

If this young Eagle player is your son I can understand you jumping up and down as I would, but unfortunately he jumped on the forum the same day as I was fuming about comments made by this pretend Titan making comments about my sons club and he was not even from the Titans. (the Titans Have done well to hold their tongues)

If he is a young player I welcome him to the forum and apologise if I have offended him. and look forward to more comments (it would be great to get young peoples opinions instead of just the older heads) But tell him to be careful, as any comment made people can use to their own agenda.

Maybe if he introduced himself as a junior player would have been good.

Again excuse my scepticism but many people on here are not who they pretend to be and if eagle player is a junior I think I can speak for many. Welcome!!!
Firstly let me say to you Maverick, i will back off but when i read your comment and footyblokes i probably jumped up and down a bit to quickly and defensively, and i do apologize for being so harsh (I guess thats the motherly instinct in me) :nono: but I have sat back and watched a lot of the 18's become dismayed with the comp this season because of talk of teams not playing because a side is to good and worried about how many games they will even get to play this season.
Then when one of those players stands up and actually gives his opinion he is shot down or accussed of being an imposter.

I was asked if i knew anything about this forum by a couple of players and i told them that i thought it was pretty good. There seemed to be a few people on here that were all about the future of football in the area, and there were others that would love to see the jl fall apart, so when one of them comes on and gives his opinion, i was disapointed to see how it was taken. :cheers:

I do not come on here to have a war of words with any club, although a bit of bantering can be fun :fight: i respect everybodies opinion, unless i know it to not be a fact, but instead a rumour.

Blue Devil I will confirm that i know who he is and he is not an imposter but i will not confirm if he is junior esa player or an east player as I have never seen anyone else on this forum have to state where they are from, even if everybody can work it out. :laughing: :laughing:

I will from now on take a deep breath and think before i post and go into mother bear mode :rant:

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
galahs
Member Avatar
State of Origin
[ *  *  *  *  *  * ]
So are these Wests Tigers fringe players not quite good enough to make the Magpies NSW Cup or Wests Tigers Under 20's???

If so, its a good case why the region probably needs to look at forming a Bundy Red Team
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Maverick
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Isn't it a bit late in the comp to do that now?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
footybloke
Club Footy
[ * ]
haha robbo, you posts always hurt my eyes!!!! haha
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Maverick
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
If we as a joint venture formed a Bundy side for next year (Wests & G6 ) look out all else. How good would we be? Oh I forgot about the EGO's but food for thought. (maybe Southern Tigers???)

Think about it...A combined side with all players from both comps available for reserves. better than anyting going around now?
Edited by Maverick, May 13 2011, 12:45 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · W.S.D.J.R.L · Next Topic »
Locked Topic


www.wests.co.nr is an unofficial forum run by volunteer Rugby League Supporters
Posts, messages, views, expressions or opinions on this forum DO NOT represent the official view of ANY Football Club.

Free Domains Hosting at .co.nr