|
2012 Senior Comp
|
|
Topic Started: Dec 5 2011, 08:25 AM (72,965 Views)
|
|
Tommy Magpie
|
May 10 2012, 12:04 PM
Post #601
|
- Posts:
- 251
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,584
- Joined:
- 17 February 2010
|
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 07:51 AM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 05:23 AM
- galahs
- May 10 2012, 02:55 AM
I have read the disgusting well distributed email that Wests Junior League has sent to the NSWRL demanding the decision be overturned. The common sense decision to allow the 3 clubs from Campbelltown Group 6 clubs be allowed to play and train in Campbelltown.
The way the letter was written and the language used in it is not of any standard that you would ever expect from a professional sporting body.
It was close to being a written tantrum.
It's time to grow up, stop throwing the toys out of the cot and start looking after your clubs in the ICCC and the game you claim to have at heart.
It's now time we all just got on with the football.
If you can't do that, then resign and let someone else run the local game that will.
Which makes me think who is really calling the shots out there and hiring a complete doofus who cant write a simple letter detailing an obvious plight.Are they hiring people to help the magpie cause or hinder the magpie cause.Put simply is a person at Wests with Wests best interest at heart in charge or is it a humphreys led muppet.Who actually wrote the stupid letter Galahs.
Tommy, there a seperate issues here, wests jrl have no association with the wests magpies district league club. Wests jrl are getting upset over a decision handed down by nswrl, let's not drag the magpies into this , its nothing to do with them.
Where do Wests magpies get all their Harold Matts and SG Ball players from?
|
|
|
| |
|
nothappyjan
|
May 10 2012, 12:21 PM
Post #602
|
- Posts:
- 26
- Group:
- Member
- Member
- #1,980
- Joined:
- 7 May 2012
|
- galahs
- May 10 2012, 02:55 AM
I have read the disgusting well distributed email that Wests Junior League has sent to the NSWRL demanding the decision be overturned. The common sense decision to allow the 3 clubs from Campbelltown Group 6 clubs be allowed to play and train in Campbelltown.
The way the letter was written and the language used in it is not of any standard that you would ever expect from a professional sporting body.
It was close to being a written tantrum.
It's time to grow up, stop throwing the toys out of the cot and start looking after your clubs in the ICCC and the game you claim to have at heart.
It's now time we all just got on with the football.
If you can't do that, then resign and let someone else run the local game that will. Mr Syznal,
You should of all people not of had acess to a private email and i think its unprofessional that it was allowed to be passed into your hands given you have been so anti WSDJRL and even went to the extend of promoting a protest rally via this web site.
Yourself along with your biased moderators need to shut this forum done as its only purpose is to slander and dafame the WSDJRL and its operations.
Also i ask you Mr Syznal why would WSDJRL be content housing 3 clubs in its district when all these 3 clubs have done is defame/slander and abuse the board and volunteers of WSDJRL for many years right up until this current day.
Its all about 3 clubs wanting to destroy what the WSDJRL has successfully run for many years and nothing more they care little for the players its all ego driven and they wont stop until they have seen the WSDJRL fall over which will never happen.
From what i am told the NSWRL decision is not over the line at all and we could see it overturned by the wekend which is how it should have been all along.
Regards
Jan
|
|
|
| |
|
Black&White
|
May 10 2012, 01:29 PM
Post #603
|
- Posts:
- 1,130
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,442
- Joined:
- 28 May 2009
|
- nothappyjan
- May 10 2012, 12:21 PM
- galahs
- May 10 2012, 02:55 AM
I have read the disgusting well distributed email that Wests Junior League has sent to the NSWRL demanding the decision be overturned. The common sense decision to allow the 3 clubs from Campbelltown Group 6 clubs be allowed to play and train in Campbelltown.
The way the letter was written and the language used in it is not of any standard that you would ever expect from a professional sporting body.
It was close to being a written tantrum.
It's time to grow up, stop throwing the toys out of the cot and start looking after your clubs in the ICCC and the game you claim to have at heart.
It's now time we all just got on with the football.
If you can't do that, then resign and let someone else run the local game that will.
Mr Syznal, You should of all people not of had acess to a private email and i think its unprofessional that it was allowed to be passed into your hands given you have been so anti WSDJRL and even went to the extend of promoting a protest rally via this web site. Yourself along with your biased moderators need to shut this forum done as its only purpose is to slander and dafame the WSDJRL and its operations. Also i ask you Mr Syznal why would WSDJRL be content housing 3 clubs in its district when all these 3 clubs have done is defame/slander and abuse the board and volunteers of WSDJRL for many years right up until this current day. Its all about 3 clubs wanting to destroy what the WSDJRL has successfully run for many years and nothing more they care little for the players its all ego driven and they wont stop until they have seen the WSDJRL fall over which will never happen. From what i am told the NSWRL decision is not over the line at all and we could see it overturned by the wekend which is how it should have been all along. Regards Jan Private email !? You cc -ed it to half the country!
|
|
|
| |
|
disco stu
|
May 10 2012, 02:02 PM
Post #604
|
- Posts:
- 2,518
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #142
- Joined:
- 31 March 2007
|
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 12:04 PM
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 07:51 AM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 05:23 AM
- galahs
- May 10 2012, 02:55 AM
I have read the disgusting well distributed email that Wests Junior League has sent to the NSWRL demanding the decision be overturned. The common sense decision to allow the 3 clubs from Campbelltown Group 6 clubs be allowed to play and train in Campbelltown.
The way the letter was written and the language used in it is not of any standard that you would ever expect from a professional sporting body.
It was close to being a written tantrum.
It's time to grow up, stop throwing the toys out of the cot and start looking after your clubs in the ICCC and the game you claim to have at heart.
It's now time we all just got on with the football.
If you can't do that, then resign and let someone else run the local game that will.
Which makes me think who is really calling the shots out there and hiring a complete doofus who cant write a simple letter detailing an obvious plight.Are they hiring people to help the magpie cause or hinder the magpie cause.Put simply is a person at Wests with Wests best interest at heart in charge or is it a humphreys led muppet.Who actually wrote the stupid letter Galahs.
Tommy, there a seperate issues here, wests jrl have no association with the wests magpies district league club. Wests jrl are getting upset over a decision handed down by nswrl, let's not drag the magpies into this , its nothing to do with them.
Where do Wests magpies get all their Harold Matts and SG Ball players from? They come from all areas & clubs tommy.
|
|
|
| |
|
disco stu
|
May 10 2012, 02:45 PM
Post #605
|
- Posts:
- 2,518
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #142
- Joined:
- 31 March 2007
|
No one is immune from scrutiny on here so Jan you seem to know alot about the wests jrl so can you answer these questions in the interest for those out there as you or wests jrl do no favours by remaining silent. Most of these concerns have been raised but no one seems to know or wont answer.
1-Who is wests jrl governing body ? Western Suburbs District Rugby League Football Club (The Magpies) constitution which is ratified bt the nswrl have clauses in it regarding the running and control of the Wests Junior League??? Geoff Carr says they affiliated to the nswrl via the wests tigers others say they are a rogue association so which is it ?
2-When did Wests Tigers become affiliated with the NSWRL? Wests Tigers, as it currently operates, is a company, not a district rugby league club, as required udner the NSWRL constitution. Can you please advise when Wests Tigers became a district club or, failing this, when the NSWRL changed its constitution to allow private companies to affiliate with it.
3-How was Western Suburbs Junior League allowed to operate the junior league competitions during the years when they were not affiliated with either the NSWRL or their district club. Is this permissible under the NSWRL constitution?
4-When the Wests Junior League refused to affiliate why wasn't their license to operate withdrawn and a new administrator installed?
5-Why wasn't the WSDRLFC (The Magpies) board informed immediately when the Junior League affiliated with the Wests Tigers?
6-The Wests jrl full name is WESTERN SUBURBS DISTRICT JUNIOR RUGBY LEAGUE LIMITED - the word limited meaning they are an Australian Public Company. Being a limited as opposed to Pty Ltd company means they would need to have board elections - is that correct? They would need shareholders - is that correct? They would need to have shareholders meetings - is that correct?
7-You talk of possible litigation to get a decision you dont like to be overturned , where will this money come from ? What do your shareholders think about this ?
These clubs you seem so vindictive against have said it is the actual players that made the decision to go to Group 6 as they just want to play in a stable competition, one where violence on and off the field is not tolerated and a competition with good administration. Something that they haven't had in the Wests Junior League for at least 15 years.You seem to want these clubs penalised for wanting to enjoy their football in a safe environment.Its already been documented that the 3 clubs were fed up with the violence, the unstable nature and poor administration of the Wests Junior League . NSWRL also agrees that the Wests Junior League snr comp on its own doesn't offer a high enough level of competition for these clubs hence the play/train rule overturned.
Now i have taken time to pose these questions ,i hope you take the time to answer them, i'll await your response.
|
|
|
| |
|
Maverick
|
May 10 2012, 07:12 PM
Post #606
|
- Posts:
- 1,081
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #526
- Joined:
- 14 April 2008
|
Seems not Disco.
|
|
|
| |
|
Tommy Magpie
|
May 10 2012, 08:29 PM
Post #607
|
- Posts:
- 251
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,584
- Joined:
- 17 February 2010
|
- nothappyjan
- May 10 2012, 12:21 PM
- galahs
- May 10 2012, 02:55 AM
I have read the disgusting well distributed email that Wests Junior League has sent to the NSWRL demanding the decision be overturned. The common sense decision to allow the 3 clubs from Campbelltown Group 6 clubs be allowed to play and train in Campbelltown.
The way the letter was written and the language used in it is not of any standard that you would ever expect from a professional sporting body.
It was close to being a written tantrum.
It's time to grow up, stop throwing the toys out of the cot and start looking after your clubs in the ICCC and the game you claim to have at heart.
It's now time we all just got on with the football.
If you can't do that, then resign and let someone else run the local game that will.
Mr Syznal, You should of all people not of had acess to a private email and i think its unprofessional that it was allowed to be passed into your hands given you have been so anti WSDJRL and even went to the extend of promoting a protest rally via this web site. Yourself along with your biased moderators need to shut this forum done as its only purpose is to slander and dafame the WSDJRL and its operations. Also i ask you Mr Syznal why would WSDJRL be content housing 3 clubs in its district when all these 3 clubs have done is defame/slander and abuse the board and volunteers of WSDJRL for many years right up until this current day. Its all about 3 clubs wanting to destroy what the WSDJRL has successfully run for many years and nothing more they care little for the players its all ego driven and they wont stop until they have seen the WSDJRL fall over which will never happen. From what i am told the NSWRL decision is not over the line at all and we could see it overturned by the wekend which is how it should have been all along. Regards Jan
And why Jan are they so slanderous and defamatory.Could it be also that they are also correct.You say biased moderators I and the majority say moderators who give their time and effort towards a public platform for the betterment of the Western Suburbs jrl/group 6 and all the kids and adults duly effected.I admire your honesty jan and your gumption for stating your point of view But making the assumption that your'e a woman(jan) dont you have to admit its an honourable thing these moderators are doing as there core purpose is to see the betterment of wth WSDJRL amongst other things.
|
|
|
| |
|
Tommy Magpie
|
May 10 2012, 08:40 PM
Post #608
|
- Posts:
- 251
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,584
- Joined:
- 17 February 2010
|
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 02:02 PM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 12:04 PM
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 07:51 AM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 05:23 AM
- galahs
- May 10 2012, 02:55 AM
I have read the disgusting well distributed email that Wests Junior League has sent to the NSWRL demanding the decision be overturned. The common sense decision to allow the 3 clubs from Campbelltown Group 6 clubs be allowed to play and train in Campbelltown.
The way the letter was written and the language used in it is not of any standard that you would ever expect from a professional sporting body.
It was close to being a written tantrum.
It's time to grow up, stop throwing the toys out of the cot and start looking after your clubs in the ICCC and the game you claim to have at heart.
It's now time we all just got on with the football.
If you can't do that, then resign and let someone else run the local game that will.
Which makes me think who is really calling the shots out there and hiring a complete doofus who cant write a simple letter detailing an obvious plight.Are they hiring people to help the magpie cause or hinder the magpie cause.Put simply is a person at Wests with Wests best interest at heart in charge or is it a humphreys led muppet.Who actually wrote the stupid letter Galahs.
Tommy, there a seperate issues here, wests jrl have no association with the wests magpies district league club. Wests jrl are getting upset over a decision handed down by nswrl, let's not drag the magpies into this , its nothing to do with them.
Where do Wests magpies get all their Harold Matts and SG Ball players from?
They come from all areas & clubs tommy.
Cmon disco behave
a lot of the players today and even more tomorrow(with a functioning AND EXPANDING WSJRL)will be from WSJRL.Im a little bit unsure why their seems to be so much animosity from certain people on this forum(not from you disco and not directed at me but others)when it comes to g6 and Wsjrl.I think the best result for all involved is a fully functional Wests and group 6 who's juniors play under the Wests Banner and who's seniors operate under the g6 banner.Why is this so hard to Achieve if we can get a Wests board that can do their job.It would give the g6 kids a better chance at getting noticed for junior reps(stepping stones for first grade) and for Wests they get a bigger pool of talent under a better standard competition.It would also improve the senior g6 rep sides and club sides for that matter.Making way for a better spectacle at the local grounds.And a better spectacle means more people paying to watch/drink e.t.c.Meaning more money for the clubs.
|
|
|
| |
|
Highlander
|
May 10 2012, 09:25 PM
Post #609
|
- Posts:
- 1,257
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #134
- Joined:
- 20 March 2007
|
Tommy are you suggesting that wests and group 6 have a similer jnr arrangment that g7 and illawarra have???
has merit BUT why would anyone want to deal with wests Jnrs????
|
|
|
| |
|
Tommy Magpie
|
May 10 2012, 10:01 PM
Post #610
|
- Posts:
- 251
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,584
- Joined:
- 17 February 2010
|
- Highlander
- May 10 2012, 09:25 PM
Tommy are you suggesting that wests and group 6 have a similer jnr arrangment that g7 and illawarra have???
has merit BUT why would anyone want to deal with wests Jnrs????
Yes I am saying that and Lets see a merging of the boards and lets keep the good ones and get rid of the bad ones and replace them with people like on this forum who have Wests and g6 best interest at heart.
|
|
|
| |
|
Black&White
|
May 10 2012, 10:12 PM
Post #611
|
- Posts:
- 1,130
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,442
- Joined:
- 28 May 2009
|
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 10:01 PM
- Highlander
- May 10 2012, 09:25 PM
Tommy are you suggesting that wests and group 6 have a similer jnr arrangment that g7 and illawarra have???
has merit BUT why would anyone want to deal with wests Jnrs????
Yes I am saying that and Lets see a merging of the boards and lets keep the good ones and get rid of the bad ones and replace them with people like on this forum who have Wests and g6 best interest at heart. Both wests juniors & G6 juniors are strong, growing comps and there is absolutely no need for them to be combined.
The problem area is the disfunctional Wests seniors.
|
|
|
| |
|
Tommy Magpie
|
May 10 2012, 11:30 PM
Post #612
|
- Posts:
- 251
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,584
- Joined:
- 17 February 2010
|
- Black&White
- May 10 2012, 10:12 PM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 10:01 PM
- Highlander
- May 10 2012, 09:25 PM
Tommy are you suggesting that wests and group 6 have a similer jnr arrangment that g7 and illawarra have???
has merit BUT why would anyone want to deal with wests Jnrs????
Yes I am saying that and Lets see a merging of the boards and lets keep the good ones and get rid of the bad ones and replace them with people like on this forum who have Wests and g6 best interest at heart.
Both wests juniors & G6 juniors are strong, growing comps and there is absolutely no need for them to be combined. The problem area is the disfunctional Wests seniors.
Let the seniors play under the g6 banner let the juniors play under the wests banner is more the model Im thinking of.Theres been a lot of statements on this forum that would suggest wests juniors arent going that well,true.
|
|
|
| |
|
Black&White
|
May 10 2012, 11:40 PM
Post #613
|
- Posts:
- 1,130
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,442
- Joined:
- 28 May 2009
|
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 11:30 PM
- Black&White
- May 10 2012, 10:12 PM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 10:01 PM
- Highlander
- May 10 2012, 09:25 PM
Tommy are you suggesting that wests and group 6 have a similer jnr arrangment that g7 and illawarra have???
has merit BUT why would anyone want to deal with wests Jnrs????
Yes I am saying that and Lets see a merging of the boards and lets keep the good ones and get rid of the bad ones and replace them with people like on this forum who have Wests and g6 best interest at heart.
Both wests juniors & G6 juniors are strong, growing comps and there is absolutely no need for them to be combined. The problem area is the disfunctional Wests seniors.
Let the seniors play under the g6 banner let the juniors play under the wests banner is more the model Im thinking of.Theres been a lot of statements on this forum that would suggest wests juniors arent going that well,true. There is no way that group 6 will let their juniors go to wests. Management will never allow it and the clubs will fight any movement in that direction.
|
|
|
| |
|
Tommy Magpie
|
May 11 2012, 06:10 AM
Post #614
|
- Posts:
- 251
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #1,584
- Joined:
- 17 February 2010
|
- Black&White
- May 10 2012, 11:40 PM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 11:30 PM
- Black&White
- May 10 2012, 10:12 PM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 10:01 PM
- Highlander
- May 10 2012, 09:25 PM
Tommy are you suggesting that wests and group 6 have a similer jnr arrangment that g7 and illawarra have???
has merit BUT why would anyone want to deal with wests Jnrs????
Yes I am saying that and Lets see a merging of the boards and lets keep the good ones and get rid of the bad ones and replace them with people like on this forum who have Wests and g6 best interest at heart.
Both wests juniors & G6 juniors are strong, growing comps and there is absolutely no need for them to be combined. The problem area is the disfunctional Wests seniors.
Let the seniors play under the g6 banner let the juniors play under the wests banner is more the model Im thinking of.Theres been a lot of statements on this forum that would suggest wests juniors arent going that well,true.
There is no way that group 6 will let their juniors go to wests. Management will never allow it and the clubs will fight any movement in that direction.
Why exactly.What are the major stumbling blocks.I live in the city so my local knowledge on this matter isnt perfect but I certainly want to see whats best for Wests AND g6.
|
|
|
| |
|
disco stu
|
May 11 2012, 08:16 AM
Post #615
|
- Posts:
- 2,518
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #142
- Joined:
- 31 March 2007
|
- Tommy Magpie
- May 11 2012, 06:10 AM
- Black&White
- May 10 2012, 11:40 PM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 11:30 PM
- Black&White
- May 10 2012, 10:12 PM
- Tommy Magpie
- May 10 2012, 10:01 PM
- Highlander
- May 10 2012, 09:25 PM
Tommy are you suggesting that wests and group 6 have a similer jnr arrangment that g7 and illawarra have???
has merit BUT why would anyone want to deal with wests Jnrs????
Yes I am saying that and Lets see a merging of the boards and lets keep the good ones and get rid of the bad ones and replace them with people like on this forum who have Wests and g6 best interest at heart.
Both wests juniors & G6 juniors are strong, growing comps and there is absolutely no need for them to be combined. The problem area is the disfunctional Wests seniors.
Let the seniors play under the g6 banner let the juniors play under the wests banner is more the model Im thinking of.Theres been a lot of statements on this forum that would suggest wests juniors arent going that well,true.
There is no way that group 6 will let their juniors go to wests. Management will never allow it and the clubs will fight any movement in that direction.
Why exactly.What are the major stumbling blocks.I live in the city so my local knowledge on this matter isnt perfect but I certainly want to see whats best for Wests AND g6. I'll clarify, black & white means group 6 won't relinquish control of their jnr competition to the wests jrl. The structures are fine the way they are, there were quite a few kids from group 6 playing for the matts & sg ball squads this year.
|
|
|
| |
|
disco stu
|
May 11 2012, 02:52 PM
Post #616
|
- Posts:
- 2,518
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #142
- Joined:
- 31 March 2007
|
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 02:45 PM
No one is immune from scrutiny on here so Jan you seem to know alot about the wests jrl so can you answer these questions in the interest for those out there as you or wests jrl do no favours by remaining silent. Most of these concerns have been raised but no one seems to know or wont answer.
1-Who is wests jrl governing body ? Western Suburbs District Rugby League Football Club (The Magpies) constitution which is ratified bt the nswrl have clauses in it regarding the running and control of the Wests Junior League??? Geoff Carr says they affiliated to the nswrl via the wests tigers others say they are a rogue association so which is it ?
2-When did Wests Tigers become affiliated with the NSWRL? Wests Tigers, as it currently operates, is a company, not a district rugby league club, as required udner the NSWRL constitution. Can you please advise when Wests Tigers became a district club or, failing this, when the NSWRL changed its constitution to allow private companies to affiliate with it.
3-How was Western Suburbs Junior League allowed to operate the junior league competitions during the years when they were not affiliated with either the NSWRL or their district club. Is this permissible under the NSWRL constitution?
4-When the Wests Junior League refused to affiliate why wasn't their license to operate withdrawn and a new administrator installed?
5-Why wasn't the WSDRLFC (The Magpies) board informed immediately when the Junior League affiliated with the Wests Tigers?
6-The Wests jrl full name is WESTERN SUBURBS DISTRICT JUNIOR RUGBY LEAGUE LIMITED - the word limited meaning they are an Australian Public Company. Being a limited as opposed to Pty Ltd company means they would need to have board elections - is that correct? They would need shareholders - is that correct? They would need to have shareholders meetings - is that correct?
7-You talk of possible litigation to get a decision you dont like to be overturned , where will this money come from ? What do your shareholders think about this ?
These clubs you seem so vindictive against have said it is the actual players that made the decision to go to Group 6 as they just want to play in a stable competition, one where violence on and off the field is not tolerated and a competition with good administration. Something that they haven't had in the Wests Junior League for at least 15 years.You seem to want these clubs penalised for wanting to enjoy their football in a safe environment.Its already been documented that the 3 clubs were fed up with the violence, the unstable nature and poor administration of the Wests Junior League . NSWRL also agrees that the Wests Junior League snr comp on its own doesn't offer a high enough level of competition for these clubs hence the play/train rule overturned.
Now i have taken time to pose these questions ,i hope you take the time to answer them, i'll await your response.
Funny, the rants have stopped but my questions have remained unanswered. Am I or others on here asking too much for some honesty here ?
|
|
|
| |
|
nothappyjan
|
May 11 2012, 03:25 PM
Post #617
|
- Posts:
- 26
- Group:
- Member
- Member
- #1,980
- Joined:
- 7 May 2012
|
- disco stu
- May 11 2012, 02:52 PM
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 02:45 PM
No one is immune from scrutiny on here so Jan you seem to know alot about the wests jrl so can you answer these questions in the interest for those out there as you or wests jrl do no favours by remaining silent. Most of these concerns have been raised but no one seems to know or wont answer.
1-Who is wests jrl governing body ? Western Suburbs District Rugby League Football Club (The Magpies) constitution which is ratified bt the nswrl have clauses in it regarding the running and control of the Wests Junior League??? Geoff Carr says they affiliated to the nswrl via the wests tigers others say they are a rogue association so which is it ?
2-When did Wests Tigers become affiliated with the NSWRL? Wests Tigers, as it currently operates, is a company, not a district rugby league club, as required udner the NSWRL constitution. Can you please advise when Wests Tigers became a district club or, failing this, when the NSWRL changed its constitution to allow private companies to affiliate with it.
3-How was Western Suburbs Junior League allowed to operate the junior league competitions during the years when they were not affiliated with either the NSWRL or their district club. Is this permissible under the NSWRL constitution?
4-When the Wests Junior League refused to affiliate why wasn't their license to operate withdrawn and a new administrator installed?
5-Why wasn't the WSDRLFC (The Magpies) board informed immediately when the Junior League affiliated with the Wests Tigers?
6-The Wests jrl full name is WESTERN SUBURBS DISTRICT JUNIOR RUGBY LEAGUE LIMITED - the word limited meaning they are an Australian Public Company. Being a limited as opposed to Pty Ltd company means they would need to have board elections - is that correct? They would need shareholders - is that correct? They would need to have shareholders meetings - is that correct?
7-You talk of possible litigation to get a decision you dont like to be overturned , where will this money come from ? What do your shareholders think about this ?
These clubs you seem so vindictive against have said it is the actual players that made the decision to go to Group 6 as they just want to play in a stable competition, one where violence on and off the field is not tolerated and a competition with good administration. Something that they haven't had in the Wests Junior League for at least 15 years.You seem to want these clubs penalised for wanting to enjoy their football in a safe environment.Its already been documented that the 3 clubs were fed up with the violence, the unstable nature and poor administration of the Wests Junior League . NSWRL also agrees that the Wests Junior League snr comp on its own doesn't offer a high enough level of competition for these clubs hence the play/train rule overturned.
Now i have taken time to pose these questions ,i hope you take the time to answer them, i'll await your response.
Funny, the rants have stopped but my questions have remained unanswered. Am I or others on here asking too much for some honesty here ? Hello Stuart,
Firstly no need to answer questions that have already been answer, Mr Carr outlined in an email to Mr Synal exactly when and how the WSDJRL was affiliated. If you Stuart go back over this forum you will clearly see Mr Carr clarified the affiliation of the WSDJRL to its NRL partner Wests Tigers so lets not re-live old debates.
Now on a brighter note Campbelltown Eagles will not be playing at Waminda Oval on Sunday Stay tuned and a decision that is starting to turn the tide back.
Concradulations Campbelltown Council for making a firm stand.
Regards,
Jan
|
|
|
| |
|
nothappyjan
|
May 11 2012, 03:27 PM
Post #618
|
- Posts:
- 26
- Group:
- Member
- Member
- #1,980
- Joined:
- 7 May 2012
|
- nothappyjan
- May 11 2012, 03:25 PM
- disco stu
- May 11 2012, 02:52 PM
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 02:45 PM
No one is immune from scrutiny on here so Jan you seem to know alot about the wests jrl so can you answer these questions in the interest for those out there as you or wests jrl do no favours by remaining silent. Most of these concerns have been raised but no one seems to know or wont answer.<br /><br />1-Who is wests jrl governing body ? Western Suburbs District Rugby League Football Club (The Magpies) constitution which is ratified bt the nswrl have clauses in it regarding the running and control of the Wests Junior League??? Geoff Carr says they affiliated to the nswrl via the wests tigers others say they are a rogue association so which is it ?<br /><br />2-When did Wests Tigers become affiliated with the NSWRL?<br />Wests Tigers, as it currently operates, is a company, not a district rugby league club, as required udner the NSWRL constitution. Can you please advise when Wests Tigers became a district club or, failing this, when the NSWRL changed its constitution to allow private companies to affiliate with it.<br /><br /><br />3-How was Western Suburbs Junior League allowed to operate the junior league competitions during the years when they were not affiliated with either the NSWRL or their district club. Is this permissible under the NSWRL constitution?<br /><br />4-When the Wests Junior League refused to affiliate why wasn't their license to operate withdrawn and a new administrator installed?<br /><br />5-Why wasn't the WSDRLFC (The Magpies) board informed immediately when the Junior League affiliated with the Wests Tigers? <br /><br />6-The Wests jrl full name is WESTERN SUBURBS DISTRICT JUNIOR RUGBY LEAGUE LIMITED - the word limited meaning they are an Australian Public Company. Being a limited as opposed to Pty Ltd company means they would need to have board elections - is that correct? They would need shareholders - is that correct? They would need to have shareholders meetings - is that correct?<br /><br />7-You talk of possible litigation to get a decision you dont like to be overturned , where will this money come from ? What do your shareholders think about this ?<br /><br />These clubs you seem so vindictive against have said it is the actual players that made the decision to go to Group 6 as they just want to play in a stable competition, one where violence on and off the field is not tolerated and a competition with good administration. Something that they haven't had in the Wests Junior League for at least 15 years.You seem to want these clubs penalised for wanting to enjoy their football in a safe environment.Its already been documented that the 3 clubs were fed up with the violence, the unstable nature and poor administration of the Wests Junior League . NSWRL also agrees that the Wests Junior League snr comp on its own doesn't offer a high enough level of competition for these clubs hence the play/train rule overturned. <br /><br />Now i have taken time to pose these questions ,i hope you take the time to answer them, i'll await your response.<br /><br /><br /><br />
Funny, the rants have stopped but my questions have remained unanswered. Am I or others on here asking too much for some honesty here ?
Hello Stuart,<br /><br />Firstly no need to answer questions that have already been answer, Mr Carr outlined in an email to Mr Synal exactly when and how the WSDJRL was affiliated.<br />If you Stuart go back over this forum you will clearly see Mr Carr clarified the affiliation of the WSDJRL to its NRL partner Wests Tigers so lets not re-live old debates.<br /><br />Now on a brighter note Campbelltown Eagles will not be playing at Waminda Oval on Sunday  Stay tuned and a decision that is starting to turn the tide back.<br /><br />Concradulations Campbelltown Council for making a firm stand.<br /><br />Regards,<br /><br />Jan
|
|
|
| |
|
Blue Devil
|
May 11 2012, 03:35 PM
Post #619
|
- Posts:
- 1,049
- Group:
- Banned
- Member
- #1,513
- Joined:
- 1 September 2009
|
Nothappyjan, no later than 1 minute from you posting this do-do I had a phone call asking what was going on, the Council hasn't stopped us playing and they won't, if you really must know, we have a Councilor or two turning up to our sponsors day, stop trying to destablize our club and the Group 6 comp!
Yes the game is on at Waminda Oval and yes it will be a big day, hope to see you there nothappyjan!
|
|
|
| |
|
disco stu
|
May 11 2012, 04:15 PM
Post #620
|
- Posts:
- 2,518
- Group:
- Full Member
- Member
- #142
- Joined:
- 31 March 2007
|
- nothappyjan
- May 11 2012, 03:25 PM
- disco stu
- May 11 2012, 02:52 PM
- disco stu
- May 10 2012, 02:45 PM
No one is immune from scrutiny on here so Jan you seem to know alot about the wests jrl so can you answer these questions in the interest for those out there as you or wests jrl do no favours by remaining silent. Most of these concerns have been raised but no one seems to know or wont answer.
1-Who is wests jrl governing body ? Western Suburbs District Rugby League Football Club (The Magpies) constitution which is ratified bt the nswrl have clauses in it regarding the running and control of the Wests Junior League??? Geoff Carr says they affiliated to the nswrl via the wests tigers others say they are a rogue association so which is it ?
2-When did Wests Tigers become affiliated with the NSWRL? Wests Tigers, as it currently operates, is a company, not a district rugby league club, as required udner the NSWRL constitution. Can you please advise when Wests Tigers became a district club or, failing this, when the NSWRL changed its constitution to allow private companies to affiliate with it.
3-How was Western Suburbs Junior League allowed to operate the junior league competitions during the years when they were not affiliated with either the NSWRL or their district club. Is this permissible under the NSWRL constitution?
4-When the Wests Junior League refused to affiliate why wasn't their license to operate withdrawn and a new administrator installed?
5-Why wasn't the WSDRLFC (The Magpies) board informed immediately when the Junior League affiliated with the Wests Tigers?
6-The Wests jrl full name is WESTERN SUBURBS DISTRICT JUNIOR RUGBY LEAGUE LIMITED - the word limited meaning they are an Australian Public Company. Being a limited as opposed to Pty Ltd company means they would need to have board elections - is that correct? They would need shareholders - is that correct? They would need to have shareholders meetings - is that correct?
7-You talk of possible litigation to get a decision you dont like to be overturned , where will this money come from ? What do your shareholders think about this ?
These clubs you seem so vindictive against have said it is the actual players that made the decision to go to Group 6 as they just want to play in a stable competition, one where violence on and off the field is not tolerated and a competition with good administration. Something that they haven't had in the Wests Junior League for at least 15 years.You seem to want these clubs penalised for wanting to enjoy their football in a safe environment.Its already been documented that the 3 clubs were fed up with the violence, the unstable nature and poor administration of the Wests Junior League . NSWRL also agrees that the Wests Junior League snr comp on its own doesn't offer a high enough level of competition for these clubs hence the play/train rule overturned.
Now i have taken time to pose these questions ,i hope you take the time to answer them, i'll await your response.
Funny, the rants have stopped but my questions have remained unanswered. Am I or others on here asking too much for some honesty here ?
Hello Stuart, Firstly no need to answer questions that have already been answer, Mr Carr outlined in an email to Mr Synal exactly when and how the WSDJRL was affiliated. If you Stuart go back over this forum you will clearly see Mr Carr clarified the affiliation of the WSDJRL to its NRL partner Wests Tigers so lets not re-live old debates. Now on a brighter note Campbelltown Eagles will not be playing at Waminda Oval on Sunday  Stay tuned and a decision that is starting to turn the tide back. Concradulations Campbelltown Council for making a firm stand. Regards, Jan Yes but you were affiliated in 2009, who were they affiliated with in the years when they spilit from the wests magpies district rlfc to when they joined with wests tigers. Why hasnt such proof been presented or forthcoming with clubs within the wests jrl district ??
Youve managed to answer one question how about the rest ?
Yes lets not live old debates you sound like a hypocrite .
|
|
|
| |