Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

WE WANT A FAIR GO FOR OUR AREA, MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND MORE THAN 4 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM

Want to talk all things Wests? Click here for our Facebook Page
Locked Topic
Season 2014
Topic Started: Nov 12 2013, 06:21 PM (126,293 Views)
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
Tik
Jul 4 2014, 07:45 AM
I'm hearing des hasler has signed frazer on a 3 year deal before June 30 and he won't see out the season with narellan. Apparently his been rushed straight into their 20's, can this be confirmed jetter ???
Dasha Politis has said this is true, Fraser to Dogs. Was way too good for G6 anyhow.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
pastrami
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Vossy
Jul 3 2014, 05:48 PM
pastrami
Jul 2 2014, 05:27 PM
Do these players count in the points?

I think it has been stated on here that they dont carry any points :letmesee: ANY club could in realty out bid another club for their services if they are available for the whole season.

In the big picture i believe those excess players should travel back to their junior club, and as stats show the majority of players in NRL/NYC are from CRL and parking them in the city takes them away from CRL comps. Pathways can be cruel to CRL clubs.
What club are you directing this too? Don't start the dreaded points system again, I'm sure these clubs are abiding by the rules. If its a matter of two or three excess jersey flegg players, really wouldn't make a huge difference. Appin should be able to use more players from Wests without the interference from points as they don't have a huge junior base to feed from.
Your argument is flawed - if Appin can't survive or compete without Wests players then what happens when there is no Wests players?? I understand these players need footy and Group 6 is strengthened by their presence, but it is artificial and can be counter productive. And having no juniors is in itself a recipe for disaster.....

A few excess NYC players are still handy players that other clubs do not have access to - that's inequality and if they don't count in the points then it makes a mockery of the system.

I don't think the Roosters (NRL 2013 Premiers) would let the Eels (2013 wooden spooners) have salary cap concessions to be competitive - they are all on the same level playing field with the same rules.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
We just received sad news that a great friend of our football club, and Rugby League in the Macarthur, former Macarthur Advertiser journalist Sean Cunningham lost his lovely partner Carol yesterday. Carol's funeral will be at Forest Lawn Leppington, Tuesday at 11.45pm. Our heartfelt condolences go out to Sean and the Quinn family.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Gal
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
pastrami
Jul 4 2014, 09:09 AM
Vossy
Jul 3 2014, 05:48 PM
pastrami
Jul 2 2014, 05:27 PM
Do these players count in the points?

I think it has been stated on here that they dont carry any points :letmesee: ANY club could in realty out bid another club for their services if they are available for the whole season.

In the big picture i believe those excess players should travel back to their junior club, and as stats show the majority of players in NRL/NYC are from CRL and parking them in the city takes them away from CRL comps. Pathways can be cruel to CRL clubs.
What club are you directing this too? Don't start the dreaded points system again, I'm sure these clubs are abiding by the rules. If its a matter of two or three excess jersey flegg players, really wouldn't make a huge difference. Appin should be able to use more players from Wests without the interference from points as they don't have a huge junior base to feed from.
Your argument is flawed - if Appin can't survive or compete without Wests players then what happens when there is no Wests players?? I understand these players need footy and Group 6 is strengthened by their presence, but it is artificial and can be counter productive. And having no juniors is in itself a recipe for disaster.....

A few excess NYC players are still handy players that other clubs do not have access to - that's inequality and if they don't count in the points then it makes a mockery of the system.

I don't think the Roosters (NRL 2013 Premiers) would let the Eels (2013 wooden spooners) have salary cap concessions to be competitive - they are all on the same level playing field with the same rules.
Pastrami you have no idea!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Jetter
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Tik
Jul 4 2014, 07:45 AM
I'm hearing des hasler has signed frazer on a 3 year deal before June 30 and he won't see out the season with narellan. Apparently his been rushed straight into their 20's, can this be confirmed jetter ???
Frazer has signed with the Bulldogs for the rest of 2014 to play NYC. No 3 year deal though.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
A big congratulations to the Kangaroos on knocking off Narellan yesterday.
After the tumultuous season they've had it would have been easy to just turn it up, but a good win for them, something to build on possibly for next year.
I heard there was a bit of drama in the game however, can anyone elaborate?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
tc6_11
Jul 7 2014, 06:12 AM
A big congratulations to the Kangaroos on knocking off Narellan yesterday.
After the tumultuous season they've had it would have been easy to just turn it up, but a good win for them, something to build on possibly for next year.
I heard there was a bit of drama in the game however, can anyone elaborate?
Cheers TC. Been 'Days of our Lives' at Fullwood this year. Good reward for everyone at the club, and in Russ Aitken, we've found the right man to steer our fortunes for the next few seasons. Highly impressive debut by Luke Swain, first time we've rolled Jets since 2010.
I wasn't there, but four sent off. Big George and Manu from us, not sure who the Jets players are. May be prudent of the Group to schedule hearings on separate nights, apparently Manu had his $6 More Chilli feature eyes rolling around...
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Gal
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
Narellan being there old grubby selves. Maybe they are frustrated now that Fraser has left.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
Gal
Jul 7 2014, 08:53 AM
Narellan being there old grubby selves. Maybe they are frustrated now that Fraser has left.
A lot of $$$ spent at Narellan for not even a GF appearance, I'm sure an inquisition won't be too far off if they miss the target again in 2014.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
foal
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
foal
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Not sure of how the games looked out at the Oaks, I was busy getting beaten in 3rd grade at Bargo. Apart from Picton winning fairly comfortably and the weather being shite, I can't report much. Donnie Thompson got our players player, I know that.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
pastrami
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Gal
Jul 4 2014, 06:07 PM
pastrami
Jul 4 2014, 09:09 AM
Vossy
Jul 3 2014, 05:48 PM
pastrami
Jul 2 2014, 05:27 PM
Do these players count in the points?

I think it has been stated on here that they dont carry any points :letmesee: ANY club could in realty out bid another club for their services if they are available for the whole season.

In the big picture i believe those excess players should travel back to their junior club, and as stats show the majority of players in NRL/NYC are from CRL and parking them in the city takes them away from CRL comps. Pathways can be cruel to CRL clubs.
What club are you directing this too? Don't start the dreaded points system again, I'm sure these clubs are abiding by the rules. If its a matter of two or three excess jersey flegg players, really wouldn't make a huge difference. Appin should be able to use more players from Wests without the interference from points as they don't have a huge junior base to feed from.
Your argument is flawed - if Appin can't survive or compete without Wests players then what happens when there is no Wests players?? I understand these players need footy and Group 6 is strengthened by their presence, but it is artificial and can be counter productive. And having no juniors is in itself a recipe for disaster.....

A few excess NYC players are still handy players that other clubs do not have access to - that's inequality and if they don't count in the points then it makes a mockery of the system.

I don't think the Roosters (NRL 2013 Premiers) would let the Eels (2013 wooden spooners) have salary cap concessions to be competitive - they are all on the same level playing field with the same rules.
Pastrami you have no idea!
:rofl:

I have no idea, but Appin has no Reggies and no juniors.

How many times has Appin appeared and then disappeared within a few years??

Relying on a false source of players will leave you guys on the edge of a cliff until a steady stream of juniors flows through - or the cheque book remains open.

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Vossy
Club Footy
[ * ]
How good to see City knock off the Jets, Jets getting to their own grubby antics once again when they get behind, city dominated them all over the park, then the grubs came out to play. Very lucky city's big men didn't knock their heads off. Dasher Pollitis needs to spend a bit more cash, because Narellan looked very average. I would still like to know how in the hell Narellan are under their points, not too many juniors there.
Edited by Vossy, Jul 7 2014, 01:30 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Vossy
Club Footy
[ * ]
pastrami
Jul 7 2014, 12:53 PM
Gal
Jul 4 2014, 06:07 PM
pastrami
Jul 4 2014, 09:09 AM
Vossy
Jul 3 2014, 05:48 PM
pastrami
Jul 2 2014, 05:27 PM
Do these players count in the points?

I think it has been stated on here that they dont carry any points :letmesee: ANY club could in realty out bid another club for their services if they are available for the whole season.

In the big picture i believe those excess players should travel back to their junior club, and as stats show the majority of players in NRL/NYC are from CRL and parking them in the city takes them away from CRL comps. Pathways can be cruel to CRL clubs.
What club are you directing this too? Don't start the dreaded points system again, I'm sure these clubs are abiding by the rules. If its a matter of two or three excess jersey flegg players, really wouldn't make a huge difference. Appin should be able to use more players from Wests without the interference from points as they don't have a huge junior base to feed from.
Your argument is flawed - if Appin can't survive or compete without Wests players then what happens when there is no Wests players?? I understand these players need footy and Group 6 is strengthened by their presence, but it is artificial and can be counter productive. And having no juniors is in itself a recipe for disaster.....

A few excess NYC players are still handy players that other clubs do not have access to - that's inequality and if they don't count in the points then it makes a mockery of the system.

I don't think the Roosters (NRL 2013 Premiers) would let the Eels (2013 wooden spooners) have salary cap concessions to be competitive - they are all on the same level playing field with the same rules.
Pastrami you have no idea!
:rofl:

I have no idea, but Appin has no Reggies and no juniors.

How many times has Appin appeared and then disappeared within a few years??

Relying on a false source of players will leave you guys on the edge of a cliff until a steady stream of juniors flows through - or the cheque book remains open.

Appin has a huge population growth that will see plenty of Juniors, they have more future than Oakdale so why wouldn't you want to see Appin excel, the club has done a great job considering what was placed on them by the Group, it wasn't Appin's fault that they didn't have a Reserve Grade, Wooden has done well starting from scratch and the Group needs Appin
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
Vossy
Jul 7 2014, 01:29 PM
pastrami
Jul 7 2014, 12:53 PM
Gal
Jul 4 2014, 06:07 PM
pastrami
Jul 4 2014, 09:09 AM
Vossy
Jul 3 2014, 05:48 PM
pastrami
Jul 2 2014, 05:27 PM
Do these players count in the points?

I think it has been stated on here that they dont carry any points :letmesee: ANY club could in realty out bid another club for their services if they are available for the whole season.

In the big picture i believe those excess players should travel back to their junior club, and as stats show the majority of players in NRL/NYC are from CRL and parking them in the city takes them away from CRL comps. Pathways can be cruel to CRL clubs.
What club are you directing this too? Don't start the dreaded points system again, I'm sure these clubs are abiding by the rules. If its a matter of two or three excess jersey flegg players, really wouldn't make a huge difference. Appin should be able to use more players from Wests without the interference from points as they don't have a huge junior base to feed from.
Your argument is flawed - if Appin can't survive or compete without Wests players then what happens when there is no Wests players?? I understand these players need footy and Group 6 is strengthened by their presence, but it is artificial and can be counter productive. And having no juniors is in itself a recipe for disaster.....

A few excess NYC players are still handy players that other clubs do not have access to - that's inequality and if they don't count in the points then it makes a mockery of the system.

I don't think the Roosters (NRL 2013 Premiers) would let the Eels (2013 wooden spooners) have salary cap concessions to be competitive - they are all on the same level playing field with the same rules.
Pastrami you have no idea!
:rofl:

I have no idea, but Appin has no Reggies and no juniors.

How many times has Appin appeared and then disappeared within a few years??

Relying on a false source of players will leave you guys on the edge of a cliff until a steady stream of juniors flows through - or the cheque book remains open.

Appin has a huge population growth that will see plenty of Juniors, they have more future than Oakdale so why wouldn't you want to see Appin excel, the club has done a great job considering what was placed on them by the Group, it wasn't Appin's fault that they didn't have a Reserve Grade, Wooden has done well starting from scratch and the Group needs Appin
Population Growth.
You'd think the same about Mt Annan, but there is always a key ingredient missing
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Jetter
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Congrats to City on their first win (that's the proper use of 'their' Gal). No excuses as Jets played poorly and the Roos got the upper hand.

Were you at the game Vossy? Gal?

For the record Vossy yesterday the jets had 7 starting juniors plus Baker, so get the facts right before dribbling. I had a quick look at other clubs and surprise they have similar junior:import ratios as well. Camdens whole pack are from other clubs, Mittagong have 5 that I can see that started elsewhere, Appin 75/25 at best and The Oaks likewise. Even Picton have their share of superstars and they are the benchmark of using their juniors for maximum effect. The difference is the jets recruit from outside the group whilst other clubs cannibalise each other, leading to situations where Oakdale have to play Reggies. Last time I looked it is a professional game.

(Source is the gr 6 program's so the figures may be slightly different to the run on teams but the gist is still the same)


Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Gal
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
I love everyone bagging Appin, it means people are worried about our success!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
enhance
Park Footy
[ * ]
Jetter
Jul 7 2014, 04:18 PM
Congrats to City on their first win (that's the proper use of 'their' Gal). No excuses as Jets played poorly and the Roos got the upper hand.

Were you at the game Vossy? Gal?

For the record Vossy yesterday the jets had 7 starting juniors plus Baker, so get the facts right before dribbling. I had a quick look at other clubs and surprise they have similar junior:import ratios as well. Camdens whole pack are from other clubs, Mittagong have 5 that I can see that started elsewhere, Appin 75/25 at best and The Oaks likewise. Even Picton have their share of superstars and they are the benchmark of using their juniors for maximum effect. The difference is the jets recruit from outside the group whilst other clubs cannibalise each other, leading to situations where Oakdale have to play Reggies. Last time I looked it is a professional game.

(Source is the gr 6 program's so the figures may be slightly different to the run on teams but the gist is still the same)


Camden played 10 actually juniors not just people that are 2 points. Then add on Ben weir who was playing for the club back in 2008 at least. Thats a bit better then jetter let on.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Footyfanatic14
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
enhance
Jul 7 2014, 04:47 PM
Jetter
Jul 7 2014, 04:18 PM
Congrats to City on their first win (that's the proper use of 'their' Gal). No excuses as Jets played poorly and the Roos got the upper hand.

Were you at the game Vossy? Gal?

For the record Vossy yesterday the jets had 7 starting juniors plus Baker, so get the facts right before dribbling. I had a quick look at other clubs and surprise they have similar junior:import ratios as well. Camdens whole pack are from other clubs, Mittagong have 5 that I can see that started elsewhere, Appin 75/25 at best and The Oaks likewise. Even Picton have their share of superstars and they are the benchmark of using their juniors for maximum effect. The difference is the jets recruit from outside the group whilst other clubs cannibalise each other, leading to situations where Oakdale have to play Reggies. Last time I looked it is a professional game.

(Source is the gr 6 program's so the figures may be slightly different to the run on teams but the gist is still the same)


Camden played 10 actually juniors not just people that are 2 points. Then add on Ben weir who was playing for the club back in 2008 at least. Thats a bit better then jetter let on.
Jetter Ur kidding yourself you blokes buy yourself a team year in year out but still doesn't win u a grand final and won't be any different this year .. The whole points system is a joke some teams follow it and others don't and the group don't inforce it may aswell scrap it completely.. Goodluck to appin this year because unfortunantly I don't think they will be around in 2015 the group should have tried harder to keep oakdale who actually have a reserve grade and will be around for years to come.mittagong are really what clubs should be looking at plenty of local and a few qaulity imports Picton much the same thirlmere should be on the same boat but have no idea clearly.. Camdens full of local juniors from
Reserves through firsts should be no question marks around them at all
Edited by Footyfanatic14, Jul 7 2014, 05:38 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Tik
Bundy Cup
[ *  * ]
Gal
Jul 7 2014, 08:53 AM
Narellan being there old grubby selves. Maybe they are frustrated now that Fraser has left.
didn't narellan thump appin without frazer ?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · CRL Group 6 · Next Topic »
Locked Topic


www.wests.co.nr is an unofficial forum run by volunteer Rugby League Supporters
Posts, messages, views, expressions or opinions on this forum DO NOT represent the official view of ANY Football Club.

Free Domains Hosting at .co.nr