Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

WE WANT A FAIR GO FOR OUR AREA, MORE OPPORTUNITIES AND MORE THAN 4 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM

Want to talk all things Wests? Click here for our Facebook Page
Add Reply
Season 2015
Topic Started: Oct 16 2014, 07:59 PM (117,770 Views)
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
ECERLFC
Sep 10 2015, 01:28 PM
This forum has about 10 members and members that don't want to put their name to it hiding behind aliases.

That's a bit rich ECERLFC... or is it 'Narellan Jet', 'Doogie Howser MD' or 'Ronnie', just to name a few.
Moderators have allowed your posts in the East Campbelltown/ Wests JL forum section because you have a good club that plays good footy in a good competition. We encourage you to keep up the posts out of Waminda International.

But we couldn't give two hoots about what you do personally, or your divide and conquer agendas that see you placed as a leading contender for Campbelltown's most reviled person. You are no longer of significance to any of us.
I'm sure everyone in G6 also continues to extend their best personal wishes to you.
Edited by Orana87, Sep 10 2015, 02:28 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
on the sideline
Sep 9 2015, 01:22 PM
Percival
Sep 6 2015, 01:14 AM
tc6_11
Sep 5 2015, 07:35 AM
foal
Sep 4 2015, 03:04 PM
oparnz82
Sep 4 2015, 12:26 PM
Always hard to pick player of the year given its the referees opinion post match for 3.2.1. From what I have heard and seen Ryan Borg has been Camden best although he missed a few games. Mitch Brasington I would imagine polled well leading The Oaks around. Maybe a guy like Thorpe from Mitta polling consistently? Flanno missed too many games. Provost from Picton a chance very underrated. Begovich may have missed too many to poll well. Who knows?
I think all of those guesses are pretty good. My money is on Chris Browne though. I doubt anyone from Picton will get a look in, similar to the last few years there hasn't really been a stand out. Maybe Donny Thompson, he'd be close to leading try scorer, with Letty. And yes Provo has been excellent, I just don't see him polling too many refs points, not flashy enough.
I had this conversation with oparnz last night. I think Browney will be a shoe in
When he got it on 2009 playing on the wing for Camden a lot of people were shocked, myself included, but the guy scored a lot of tries and kicked a lot of goals, and he has a very good relationship with the referees. Not much different to this year.
I don't like the referees voting on player of the year, it's a poor way of hailing the "best" player in group 6.
There is meant to be a group official at each game now, surely they could adjudicate.
Surely the coaches voting 3-2-1 at the end of the season would be a better system. With the coach only giving points to opposition players.
I heard Ben Baker Former group 6 is in the running player of the year in the sydney Shield :correct: :correct: .He got top try scorer with 24 trys and leading point scorer with 224 points . Wonder if he could have done it again this year in g6
I'm sure everyone in G6 extends their best wishes to Ben for the NSWRL presentation.
Ben would probably be the first to admit that he didn't enjoy his footy at Narellan in 2014, and revitalised at a new club, under a good coach in a competition where he had to prove himself again, he has been a revelation.
26 tries and 74 goals; 252 points- 56 ahead of his nearest rival, James Boustani from Hills.
Would be a great achievement to be Player of the Year in Group 6, and the Sydney Shield, in one's career.
I'm hearing Ben may seek a NSWRL club with a RMC- NSW Cup pathway in 2016. I'm sure these stats have put his $$$ value right up. He should be getting the best deal for his young family.


Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
Percival
Sep 3 2015, 01:08 PM
Orana87
Sep 3 2015, 12:50 PM
Tips for this weekend:
U/18Bs: the Roos to roll The Oaks and give us both 18As and 18Bs in the GF, Sunday week at Orana Park.
U/18As: Camden by 4 over Thirlmere, to secure all 3 grades in the GF for the Rammers. First time since 1994?
2nd Div: Robertson (everybody's sentimental faves) to roll defending premiers Narellan.
Reserves: Oakdale to oust Minor Premiers Picton, with too much big game experience.
1sts: Picton to obliterate The Oaks fairytale, and set up what will be the highest quality 1st Grade GF for some time.
From what I saw on the weekend I must agree with you Orana. Only difference maybe Narellan in 2nd div. Hopefully the Oaks can be competitive in 1sts they don't deserve to finish with a flogging.
Tips for this weekend:
U/18Bs: going with my heart, the 'Roos to vanquish the undefeated $1.04 favourites from Mittagong in a great game to start the day.
U/18As: The 'Roos to get the cash, and stop Camden early in the day of levelling the feats of our 1975 teams (all 3 grades premiers).
2nd Div: the Mahn Darley inspired Mt Annan combination to roll defending premiers Narellan.
Reserves: Oakdale 2005 1st Grade in one last great hurrah. TC to claim match winner again.
1sts: Camden, if they can neutralize Michael Lett, to break a 13 year premiership drought.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Rob
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 03:35 PM
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
GF tips Rob?
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
footydad
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Orana87
Sep 10 2015, 03:37 PM
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 03:35 PM
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
GF tips Rob?
MITTAGONG
KANGAROOS
MT ANNAN
OAKDALE
CAMDEN
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
footydad
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
It has been very quiet on here of late.It is GF week, and if we look back at a season in review, its been a great year.Workers and Dragons back in firsts.The Oaks neally got a fairytale, Kangaroos no matter what turned up to play.Reggies has been great this year, the workies old boys, Appins gang back together, Kangaroos would of challenged it if not for injuries in firsts.And Picton all grades strong.2nd division major success on saturday afternoons, will we see an extra team or two in 16.Should be a great day on sunday at Orana park.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Rob
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
footydad
Sep 10 2015, 04:07 PM
Orana87
Sep 10 2015, 03:37 PM
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 03:35 PM
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
GF tips Rob?
MITTAGONG
KANGAROOS
MT ANNAN
OAKDALE
CAMDEN
U/18Bs: Mittagong vs Campbelltown City. MITTA
2nd Division: Mt Annan vs Narellan NARELLAN
U/18As: Campbelltown City vs Camden. CITY
Reserves: Camden vs Oakdale. OAKDALE
1sts: Camden vs Picton. ......

I'd like to see Picton win . Camden who have become abit cocky should be favourites tho!

I'd like to have the money both clubs have spent on players ??? Lol
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
cockpit000
SG Ball
[ *  * ]
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 05:39 PM
footydad
Sep 10 2015, 04:07 PM
Orana87
Sep 10 2015, 03:37 PM
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 03:35 PM
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
GF tips Rob?
MITTAGONG
KANGAROOS
MT ANNAN
OAKDALE
CAMDEN
U/18Bs: Mittagong vs Campbelltown City. MITTA
2nd Division: Mt Annan vs Narellan NARELLAN
U/18As: Campbelltown City vs Camden. CITY
Reserves: Camden vs Oakdale. OAKDALE
1sts: Camden vs Picton. ......

I'd like to see Picton win . Camden who have become abit cocky should be favourites tho!

I'd like to have the money both clubs have spent on players ??? Lol
Mitta
City
Mount Annan
Camden
Camden
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
enhance
Park Footy
[ * ]
Who would of spent the most on players this year?
Thirlmere
Narellan
Camden
Picton
Appin

In that order would be my guess
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
foal
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 03:35 PM
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
Thankfully sanity has prevailed and the two referees idea has been canned. You can't just introduce something like that for a grand final without it ever being trialled before.

Haven't seen a tip for Picton yet, so I'm assuming people are forgetting how they lift for the big game!! Obviously biased, but I think in terms of talent the two teams just about cancel each other out. I just think the black and whites proven ability to perform when it matters will be the difference. If one player were to make the difference I'd nominate Jakiel Mariner. He is simply ridiculous running in the back row.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
tc6_11
Member Avatar
NRL
[ *  *  *  * ]
foal
Sep 10 2015, 09:19 PM
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 03:35 PM
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
Thankfully sanity has prevailed and the two referees idea has been canned. You can't just introduce something like that for a grand final without it ever being trialled before.

Haven't seen a tip for Picton yet, so I'm assuming people are forgetting how they lift for the big game!! Obviously biased, but I think in terms of talent the two teams just about cancel each other out. I just think the black and whites proven ability to perform when it matters will be the difference. If one player were to make the difference I'd nominate Jakiel Mariner. He is simply ridiculous running in the back row.
man crush on Jakiel Mariner?
Picton seem to plateaued (with the exception of the 100-0 victory) and Camden have continued to rise, however Spring is magpie season and winning is a habit.
Camden have the desire, but Picton have the experience, which one will bring forth the glory? I've said Picton all year, so i will stick to that.
Foal, any chance of a bit of a Barney on Sunday? You said both teams don't like each other and with tension at an all time high there could be a chance of some fists flying.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
tc6_11
Sep 11 2015, 06:17 AM
Picton seem to plateaued (with the exception of the 100-0 victory)
That was against five 1st Graders and a combination of brave U/18 and Reserves players who had already played full games.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
foal
Member Avatar
NYC U20's
[ *  * ]
tc6_11
Sep 11 2015, 06:17 AM
foal
Sep 10 2015, 09:19 PM
Rob
Sep 10 2015, 03:35 PM
foal
Sep 9 2015, 06:34 PM
Hey, did anyone hear the one about the group that introduced a two referee system for the first time in a grand final?
yeah 2 refs for 1st grade GF. Dorman and Aaron
Thankfully sanity has prevailed and the two referees idea has been canned. You can't just introduce something like that for a grand final without it ever being trialled before.

Haven't seen a tip for Picton yet, so I'm assuming people are forgetting how they lift for the big game!! Obviously biased, but I think in terms of talent the two teams just about cancel each other out. I just think the black and whites proven ability to perform when it matters will be the difference. If one player were to make the difference I'd nominate Jakiel Mariner. He is simply ridiculous running in the back row.
man crush on Jakiel Mariner?
Picton seem to plateaued (with the exception of the 100-0 victory) and Camden have continued to rise, however Spring is magpie season and winning is a habit.
Camden have the desire, but Picton have the experience, which one will bring forth the glory? I've said Picton all year, so i will stick to that.
Foal, any chance of a bit of a Barney on Sunday? You said both teams don't like each other and with tension at an all time high there could be a chance of some fists flying.
I'd love to see a barney if not for the outrageous automatic send off rule.
Mate, no man crush on Jakiel but it's probably fair to say I wish I was him. Unbelievable talent at footy and a musician! The two things I wanted more than anything else to be!! He's simply too good for this level and he's only 21, it's not like he's had his crack and stuffed it so now he's slumming it here. I really hope for his sake we see him in the NRL next year because his only obstacle is himself. Incidentally Borgy identified him as the danger Man.
As far as the plateau that's a fair call, but you're overlooking the first semi (at least the opening 40) where they were 40-0 up against Narellan at half time before putting the queue in the rack.
Again obviously I'm biased, Camden are absolutely outstanding. It will be a shame that only one team will be remembered in years to come because no one temembers the runner up.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
footydad
Sep 10 2015, 04:14 PM
It has been very quiet on here of late.It is GF week, and if we look back at a season in review, its been a great year.Workers and Dragons back in firsts.The Oaks neally got a fairytale, Kangaroos no matter what turned up to play.Reggies has been great this year, the workies old boys, Appins gang back together, Kangaroos would of challenged it if not for injuries in firsts.And Picton all grades strong.2nd division major success on saturday afternoons, will we see an extra team or two in 16.Should be a great day on sunday at Orana park.
Good idea footydad. Here's my report card prior to the Grand Finals:

Oakdale: great to see them back on the 1st Grade park in 2015. A fine effort by all to raise a competitive team that was imbued with the Oakdale spirit very quickly. Some superb wins and were never humiliated. The Reserves was obviously a shining light for the Club all season, and are now rewarded on Sunday with the Club being present on the biggest day of the season. Coaching situation ended in turmoil. Challenges ahead for 2016.
Grade: B

City: a superb rebuilding year from a Board perspective, bar four games (Picton/ Camden both rounds) in which we couldn't/ didn't compete. Two U/18 teams in the GF, Reserve Grade knocked out in first semi by Oakdale at Oakdale (who'll win it), and 1sts could easily have been an Oaks like cinderella story if not for a plague of injuries, which seem to follow me across the Northern Rd. Drew Dalton did a wonderful job "putting the 2013 band back together", with the addition of the 'Army boys', making the team competitive when it looked like we were gone in early February, especially after losing Russ Aitken in October 2014.
Grade: C

Thirlmere: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. Given their roster, the disappointment of the competition, failing to fire in 2015. Appeared to be an emotionless/ passionless team bar the U/18 kids that Greeney used, and who were their shining lights. I've heard it spoke that when Picton is strong, Thirlmere isn't and the obverse true. An interesting off-season awaits, but if the Trotters are raring to go, they will be the glue needed to get this team firing.
Grade: D-

Moss Vale: full credit to Michael Sutton and Robbie Payne for the quality of their 1st Grade team in 2015. Was it a one year wonder? Sutto put an enormous amount of energy into getting the off-field right. It can't be glossed over that this was an imported team, and that the cavalry is not coming from the lower grades. Both Mittagong and Moss Vale reggies are suffering from the plethora of 2nd Division clubs they are ringed by. I hope I'm wrong.
Grade: B-

Mittagong: appear now to be in decline. Was a massive effort the rise of 2011-2014; taking a toll on volunteers, officials and playing group alike. The history of the Group suggests that Mittagong rise every twenty years. In saying this, were my surprise packet though. Even though the loss of the Borgs meant a GF appearance was beyond them, they still remained ultra competitive, almost toppling Picton in the last round to snatch a semi final spot. Ultimately, two shellackings by Campbelltown City cost them a spot in the Top 3. Mark Thomas did very well with what was available to him. Another interesting off-season to watch player movement.
Grade: B-

Appin: had the roster to challenge for 3rd. Cruelled by lack of depth, injuries, ill- discipline and suspensions. Having seasoned pros hurts when everyone realises that Camden/ Picton were Man City/ Chelsea in 2015. Not having an U/18 team hurts, especially as a developing club. It looks as though Rob & Co. have been swift to wright the ship and have already confronted these issues.
Grade: C

Narellan: started incredibly slowly. Plagued by coaching instability, but came good in the end to nab a Top 3 spot, before being sacrificed to Picton in the Major Prelim. Full credit to President Clint McKinnon in spearheading the juniors- first policy, in the face of stern intra- club opposition. Ultra strong lower grades. The competition's sleeping giant, Narellan could easily sweep 18s- 2nd Div- Reserves and 1sts in one season, very shortly.
Grade: B

The Oaks: as they say in Caddyshack, the 'Cinderella Story'. First time in a 5 team finals since 2002 and won the 'Premiership' for 3rd in 2015. Very well coached by the Brasingtons, and with a quality front row, were always going to be hard to beat. Something is building at Dudley Chesham and selective, top-up recruitment for 2016 may see that premiership drought challenged.
Grade: A

Picton: defending premiers who recruited even better again to improve their roster. Sunday would see the feats of 1985-87 levelled, a magnificent achievement for locals Poisel and Dowse.
Grade: A+ (with a plus pending for Sunday)

Camden: said on here some time ago that Camden's great eras had been built around champion U/18 teams. The same has proven correct again, with a standout committtee raising the necessary funds to entice the right leadership and coaching. Selective recruiting of Insenio and Collis to neutralise and surpass Picton's threats was astute, and now has them on the cusp of ending a 13 season premiership drought. The pressure is bizarrely on Camden in this one.
Grade: A+ (with a plus or minus pending for Sunday)


Reserve Grade Competition Of the highest standard for some time. Even Appin and Thirlmere, who missed the finals, were more than capable on their day. Not a struck match between the top 5 teams. The Oaks improved vastly when Rumsby came into the team. Only Moss Vale and Mittagong were also-rans.

2nd Division Competition spot on footydad. The Saturday nature of this League has improved it. Full marks to Narellan on fielding two teams. Mt Annan doing well under Mahn Darley, but a 1st Grade return would be unlikely? A lot of 2nd Division clubs in the South, to the detriment of 1st Division clubs it is argued, but with the population explosion here in the north no doubt more teams will be looking to join this league, with places as far north as West Bardia, Willowdale and Leppington all in Group boundaries. Word is Marulan is set to hold a public meeting to form a 2nd Division team and footy club- with Marulan just inside the Group. The light flickered at the great Bowral club, but again they ended in turmoil.
Edited by Orana87, Sep 11 2015, 09:27 AM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
rustynail
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
Orana87
Sep 11 2015, 09:18 AM
footydad
Sep 10 2015, 04:14 PM
It has been very quiet on here of late.It is GF week, and if we look back at a season in review, its been a great year.Workers and Dragons back in firsts.The Oaks neally got a fairytale, Kangaroos no matter what turned up to play.Reggies has been great this year, the workies old boys, Appins gang back together, Kangaroos would of challenged it if not for injuries in firsts.And Picton all grades strong.2nd division major success on saturday afternoons, will we see an extra team or two in 16.Should be a great day on sunday at Orana park.
Good idea footydad. Here's my report card prior to the Grand Finals:

Oakdale: great to see them back on the 1st Grade park in 2015. A fine effort by all to raise a competitive team that was imbued with the Oakdale spirit very quickly. Some superb wins and were never humiliated. The Reserves was obviously a shining light for the Club all season, and are now rewarded on Sunday with the Club being present on the biggest day of the season. Coaching situation ended in turmoil. Challenges ahead for 2016.
Grade: B

City: a superb rebuilding year from a Board perspective, bar four games (Picton/ Camden both rounds) in which we couldn't/ didn't compete. Two U/18 teams in the GF, Reserve Grade knocked out in first semi by Oakdale at Oakdale (who'll win it), and 1sts could easily have been an Oaks like cinderella story if not for a plague of injuries, which seem to follow me across the Northern Rd. Drew Dalton did a wonderful job "putting the 2013 band back together", with the addition of the 'Army boys', making the team competitive when it looked like we were gone in early February, especially after losing Russ Aitken in October 2014.
Grade: C

Thirlmere: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. Given their roster, the disappointment of the competition, failing to fire in 2015. Appeared to be an emotionless/ passionless team bar the U/18 kids that Greeney used, and who were their shining lights. I've heard it spoke that when Picton is strong, Thirlmere isn't and the obverse true. An interesting off-season awaits, but if the Trotters are raring to go, they will be the glue needed to get this team firing.
Grade: D-

Moss Vale: full credit to Michael Sutton and Robbie Payne for the quality of their 1st Grade team in 2015. Was it a one year wonder? Sutto put an enormous amount of energy into getting the off-field right. It can't be glossed over that this was an imported team, and that the cavalry is not coming from the lower grades. Both Mittagong and Moss Vale reggies are suffering from the plethora of 2nd Division clubs they are ringed by. I hope I'm wrong.
Grade: B-

Mittagong: appear now to be in decline. Was a massive effort the rise of 2011-2014; taking a toll on volunteers, officials and playing group alike. The history of the Group suggests that Mittagong rise every twenty years. In saying this, were my surprise packet though. Even though the loss of the Borgs meant a GF appearance was beyond them, they still remained ultra competitive, almost toppling Picton in the last round to snatch a semi final spot. Ultimately, two shellackings by Campbelltown City cost them a spot in the Top 3. Mark Thomas did very well with what was available to him. Another interesting off-season to watch player movement.
Grade: B-

Appin: had the roster to challenge for 3rd. Cruelled by lack of depth, injuries, ill- discipline and suspensions. Having seasoned pros hurts when everyone realises that Camden/ Picton were Man City/ Chelsea in 2015. Not having an U/18 team hurts, especially as a developing club. It looks as though Rob & Co. have been swift to wright the ship and have already confronted these issues.
Grade: C

Narellan: started incredibly slowly. Plagued by coaching instability, but came good in the end to nab a Top 3 spot, before being sacrificed to Picton in the Major Prelim. Full credit to President Clint McKinnon in spearheading the juniors- first policy, in the face of stern intra- club opposition. Ultra strong lower grades. The competition's sleeping giant, Narellan could easily sweep 18s- 2nd Div- Reserves and 1sts in one season, very shortly.
Grade: B

The Oaks: as they say in Caddyshack, the 'Cinderella Story'. First time in a 5 team finals since 2002 and won the 'Premiership' for 3rd in 2015. Very well coached by the Brasingtons, and with a quality front row, were always going to be hard to beat. Something is building at Dudley Chesham and selective, top-up recruitment for 2016 may see that premiership drought challenged.
Grade: A

Picton: defending premiers who recruited even better again to improve their roster. Sunday would see the feats of 1985-87 levelled, a magnificent achievement for locals Poisel and Dowse.
Grade: A+ (with a plus pending for Sunday)

Camden: said on here some time ago that Camden's great eras had been built around champion U/18 teams. The same has proven correct again, with a standout committtee raising the necessary funds to entice the right leadership and coaching. Selective recruiting of Insenio and Collis to neutralise and surpass Picton's threats was astute, and now has them on the cusp of ending a 13 season premiership drought. The pressure is bizarrely on Camden in this one.
Grade: A+ (with a plus or minus pending for Sunday)


Reserve Grade Competition Of the highest standard for some time. Even Appin and Thirlmere, who missed the finals, were more than capable on their day. Not a struck match between the top 5 teams. The Oaks improved vastly when Rumsby came into the team. Only Moss Vale and Mittagong were also-rans.

2nd Division Competition spot on footydad. The Saturday nature of this League has improved it. Full marks to Narellan on fielding two teams. Mt Annan doing well under Mahn Darley, but a 1st Grade return would be unlikely? A lot of 2nd Division clubs in the South, to the detriment of 1st Division clubs it is argued, but with the population explosion here in the north no doubt more teams will be looking to join this league, with places as far north as West Bardia, Willowdale and Leppington all in Group boundaries. Word is Marulan is set to hold a public meeting to form a 2nd Division team and footy club- with Marulan just inside the Group. The light flickered at the great Bowral club, but again they ended in turmoil.
Pretty good summation of the year. Your comments re 2nd division sides in the southern end of the group is definitely something the group needs to look at. The south doesn't have the population like the north does and cannot continue to support all the these clubs to the detriment of the 1st grade clubs. Moss Vale and Mittagong are pushing it uphill trying to keep their juniors when the players can take an easy option and have a run around at either Bowral, Robbo or Bundanoon without committing too much. Maybe Bargo is impacting on Thirlmere??? I know there has been discussion between the clubs over the years for maybe one of the clubs becoming say Mossy's Reserve Grade and the players are portable between the 2 grades but it always falls over. Maybe its time the Group "enforced" or aligned these 2nd div clubs with a 1st grade club. Other wise it may see the demise of 1st grade footy in the south in the near future
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
footydad
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
rustynail
Sep 11 2015, 11:20 AM
Orana87
Sep 11 2015, 09:18 AM
footydad
Sep 10 2015, 04:14 PM
It has been very quiet on here of late.It is GF week, and if we look back at a season in review, its been a great year.Workers and Dragons back in firsts.The Oaks neally got a fairytale, Kangaroos no matter what turned up to play.Reggies has been great this year, the workies old boys, Appins gang back together, Kangaroos would of challenged it if not for injuries in firsts.And Picton all grades strong.2nd division major success on saturday afternoons, will we see an extra team or two in 16.Should be a great day on sunday at Orana park.
Good idea footydad. Here's my report card prior to the Grand Finals:

Oakdale: great to see them back on the 1st Grade park in 2015. A fine effort by all to raise a competitive team that was imbued with the Oakdale spirit very quickly. Some superb wins and were never humiliated. The Reserves was obviously a shining light for the Club all season, and are now rewarded on Sunday with the Club being present on the biggest day of the season. Coaching situation ended in turmoil. Challenges ahead for 2016.
Grade: B

City: a superb rebuilding year from a Board perspective, bar four games (Picton/ Camden both rounds) in which we couldn't/ didn't compete. Two U/18 teams in the GF, Reserve Grade knocked out in first semi by Oakdale at Oakdale (who'll win it), and 1sts could easily have been an Oaks like cinderella story if not for a plague of injuries, which seem to follow me across the Northern Rd. Drew Dalton did a wonderful job "putting the 2013 band back together", with the addition of the 'Army boys', making the team competitive when it looked like we were gone in early February, especially after losing Russ Aitken in October 2014.
Grade: C

Thirlmere: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. Given their roster, the disappointment of the competition, failing to fire in 2015. Appeared to be an emotionless/ passionless team bar the U/18 kids that Greeney used, and who were their shining lights. I've heard it spoke that when Picton is strong, Thirlmere isn't and the obverse true. An interesting off-season awaits, but if the Trotters are raring to go, they will be the glue needed to get this team firing.
Grade: D-

Moss Vale: full credit to Michael Sutton and Robbie Payne for the quality of their 1st Grade team in 2015. Was it a one year wonder? Sutto put an enormous amount of energy into getting the off-field right. It can't be glossed over that this was an imported team, and that the cavalry is not coming from the lower grades. Both Mittagong and Moss Vale reggies are suffering from the plethora of 2nd Division clubs they are ringed by. I hope I'm wrong.
Grade: B-

Mittagong: appear now to be in decline. Was a massive effort the rise of 2011-2014; taking a toll on volunteers, officials and playing group alike. The history of the Group suggests that Mittagong rise every twenty years. In saying this, were my surprise packet though. Even though the loss of the Borgs meant a GF appearance was beyond them, they still remained ultra competitive, almost toppling Picton in the last round to snatch a semi final spot. Ultimately, two shellackings by Campbelltown City cost them a spot in the Top 3. Mark Thomas did very well with what was available to him. Another interesting off-season to watch player movement.
Grade: B-

Appin: had the roster to challenge for 3rd. Cruelled by lack of depth, injuries, ill- discipline and suspensions. Having seasoned pros hurts when everyone realises that Camden/ Picton were Man City/ Chelsea in 2015. Not having an U/18 team hurts, especially as a developing club. It looks as though Rob & Co. have been swift to wright the ship and have already confronted these issues.
Grade: C

Narellan: started incredibly slowly. Plagued by coaching instability, but came good in the end to nab a Top 3 spot, before being sacrificed to Picton in the Major Prelim. Full credit to President Clint McKinnon in spearheading the juniors- first policy, in the face of stern intra- club opposition. Ultra strong lower grades. The competition's sleeping giant, Narellan could easily sweep 18s- 2nd Div- Reserves and 1sts in one season, very shortly.
Grade: B

The Oaks: as they say in Caddyshack, the 'Cinderella Story'. First time in a 5 team finals since 2002 and won the 'Premiership' for 3rd in 2015. Very well coached by the Brasingtons, and with a quality front row, were always going to be hard to beat. Something is building at Dudley Chesham and selective, top-up recruitment for 2016 may see that premiership drought challenged.
Grade: A

Picton: defending premiers who recruited even better again to improve their roster. Sunday would see the feats of 1985-87 levelled, a magnificent achievement for locals Poisel and Dowse.
Grade: A+ (with a plus pending for Sunday)

Camden: said on here some time ago that Camden's great eras had been built around champion U/18 teams. The same has proven correct again, with a standout committtee raising the necessary funds to entice the right leadership and coaching. Selective recruiting of Insenio and Collis to neutralise and surpass Picton's threats was astute, and now has them on the cusp of ending a 13 season premiership drought. The pressure is bizarrely on Camden in this one.
Grade: A+ (with a plus or minus pending for Sunday)


Reserve Grade Competition Of the highest standard for some time. Even Appin and Thirlmere, who missed the finals, were more than capable on their day. Not a struck match between the top 5 teams. The Oaks improved vastly when Rumsby came into the team. Only Moss Vale and Mittagong were also-rans.

2nd Division Competition spot on footydad. The Saturday nature of this League has improved it. Full marks to Narellan on fielding two teams. Mt Annan doing well under Mahn Darley, but a 1st Grade return would be unlikely? A lot of 2nd Division clubs in the South, to the detriment of 1st Division clubs it is argued, but with the population explosion here in the north no doubt more teams will be looking to join this league, with places as far north as West Bardia, Willowdale and Leppington all in Group boundaries. Word is Marulan is set to hold a public meeting to form a 2nd Division team and footy club- with Marulan just inside the Group. The light flickered at the great Bowral club, but again they ended in turmoil.
Pretty good summation of the year. Your comments re 2nd division sides in the southern end of the group is definitely something the group needs to look at. The south doesn't have the population like the north does and cannot continue to support all the these clubs to the detriment of the 1st grade clubs. Moss Vale and Mittagong are pushing it uphill trying to keep their juniors when the players can take an easy option and have a run around at either Bowral, Robbo or Bundanoon without committing too much. Maybe Bargo is impacting on Thirlmere??? I know there has been discussion between the clubs over the years for maybe one of the clubs becoming say Mossy's Reserve Grade and the players are portable between the 2 grades but it always falls over. Maybe its time the Group "enforced" or aligned these 2nd div clubs with a 1st grade club. Other wise it may see the demise of 1st grade footy in the south in the near future
Great to see everyone on here getting in the spirit of the GF.Rustynail you are correct, there is too many 2nd division clubs in the highlands.There is huge talk that Oran Park will be trying to field a 2nd division side in 2016, obviously with group approval, but word is they will be financially backed by one of the biggest home building and concrete company's in the south west.Also can add truth to the Marulan one as well have heard this several times.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
rustynail
Member Avatar
Harold Matthews
[ *  * ]
footydad
Sep 11 2015, 11:46 AM
rustynail
Sep 11 2015, 11:20 AM
Orana87
Sep 11 2015, 09:18 AM
footydad
Sep 10 2015, 04:14 PM
It has been very quiet on here of late.It is GF week, and if we look back at a season in review, its been a great year.Workers and Dragons back in firsts.The Oaks neally got a fairytale, Kangaroos no matter what turned up to play.Reggies has been great this year, the workies old boys, Appins gang back together, Kangaroos would of challenged it if not for injuries in firsts.And Picton all grades strong.2nd division major success on saturday afternoons, will we see an extra team or two in 16.Should be a great day on sunday at Orana park.
Good idea footydad. Here's my report card prior to the Grand Finals:

Oakdale: great to see them back on the 1st Grade park in 2015. A fine effort by all to raise a competitive team that was imbued with the Oakdale spirit very quickly. Some superb wins and were never humiliated. The Reserves was obviously a shining light for the Club all season, and are now rewarded on Sunday with the Club being present on the biggest day of the season. Coaching situation ended in turmoil. Challenges ahead for 2016.
Grade: B

City: a superb rebuilding year from a Board perspective, bar four games (Picton/ Camden both rounds) in which we couldn't/ didn't compete. Two U/18 teams in the GF, Reserve Grade knocked out in first semi by Oakdale at Oakdale (who'll win it), and 1sts could easily have been an Oaks like cinderella story if not for a plague of injuries, which seem to follow me across the Northern Rd. Drew Dalton did a wonderful job "putting the 2013 band back together", with the addition of the 'Army boys', making the team competitive when it looked like we were gone in early February, especially after losing Russ Aitken in October 2014.
Grade: C

Thirlmere: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. Given their roster, the disappointment of the competition, failing to fire in 2015. Appeared to be an emotionless/ passionless team bar the U/18 kids that Greeney used, and who were their shining lights. I've heard it spoke that when Picton is strong, Thirlmere isn't and the obverse true. An interesting off-season awaits, but if the Trotters are raring to go, they will be the glue needed to get this team firing.
Grade: D-

Moss Vale: full credit to Michael Sutton and Robbie Payne for the quality of their 1st Grade team in 2015. Was it a one year wonder? Sutto put an enormous amount of energy into getting the off-field right. It can't be glossed over that this was an imported team, and that the cavalry is not coming from the lower grades. Both Mittagong and Moss Vale reggies are suffering from the plethora of 2nd Division clubs they are ringed by. I hope I'm wrong.
Grade: B-

Mittagong: appear now to be in decline. Was a massive effort the rise of 2011-2014; taking a toll on volunteers, officials and playing group alike. The history of the Group suggests that Mittagong rise every twenty years. In saying this, were my surprise packet though. Even though the loss of the Borgs meant a GF appearance was beyond them, they still remained ultra competitive, almost toppling Picton in the last round to snatch a semi final spot. Ultimately, two shellackings by Campbelltown City cost them a spot in the Top 3. Mark Thomas did very well with what was available to him. Another interesting off-season to watch player movement.
Grade: B-

Appin: had the roster to challenge for 3rd. Cruelled by lack of depth, injuries, ill- discipline and suspensions. Having seasoned pros hurts when everyone realises that Camden/ Picton were Man City/ Chelsea in 2015. Not having an U/18 team hurts, especially as a developing club. It looks as though Rob & Co. have been swift to wright the ship and have already confronted these issues.
Grade: C

Narellan: started incredibly slowly. Plagued by coaching instability, but came good in the end to nab a Top 3 spot, before being sacrificed to Picton in the Major Prelim. Full credit to President Clint McKinnon in spearheading the juniors- first policy, in the face of stern intra- club opposition. Ultra strong lower grades. The competition's sleeping giant, Narellan could easily sweep 18s- 2nd Div- Reserves and 1sts in one season, very shortly.
Grade: B

The Oaks: as they say in Caddyshack, the 'Cinderella Story'. First time in a 5 team finals since 2002 and won the 'Premiership' for 3rd in 2015. Very well coached by the Brasingtons, and with a quality front row, were always going to be hard to beat. Something is building at Dudley Chesham and selective, top-up recruitment for 2016 may see that premiership drought challenged.
Grade: A

Picton: defending premiers who recruited even better again to improve their roster. Sunday would see the feats of 1985-87 levelled, a magnificent achievement for locals Poisel and Dowse.
Grade: A+ (with a plus pending for Sunday)

Camden: said on here some time ago that Camden's great eras had been built around champion U/18 teams. The same has proven correct again, with a standout committtee raising the necessary funds to entice the right leadership and coaching. Selective recruiting of Insenio and Collis to neutralise and surpass Picton's threats was astute, and now has them on the cusp of ending a 13 season premiership drought. The pressure is bizarrely on Camden in this one.
Grade: A+ (with a plus or minus pending for Sunday)


Reserve Grade Competition Of the highest standard for some time. Even Appin and Thirlmere, who missed the finals, were more than capable on their day. Not a struck match between the top 5 teams. The Oaks improved vastly when Rumsby came into the team. Only Moss Vale and Mittagong were also-rans.

2nd Division Competition spot on footydad. The Saturday nature of this League has improved it. Full marks to Narellan on fielding two teams. Mt Annan doing well under Mahn Darley, but a 1st Grade return would be unlikely? A lot of 2nd Division clubs in the South, to the detriment of 1st Division clubs it is argued, but with the population explosion here in the north no doubt more teams will be looking to join this league, with places as far north as West Bardia, Willowdale and Leppington all in Group boundaries. Word is Marulan is set to hold a public meeting to form a 2nd Division team and footy club- with Marulan just inside the Group. The light flickered at the great Bowral club, but again they ended in turmoil.
Pretty good summation of the year. Your comments re 2nd division sides in the southern end of the group is definitely something the group needs to look at. The south doesn't have the population like the north does and cannot continue to support all the these clubs to the detriment of the 1st grade clubs. Moss Vale and Mittagong are pushing it uphill trying to keep their juniors when the players can take an easy option and have a run around at either Bowral, Robbo or Bundanoon without committing too much. Maybe Bargo is impacting on Thirlmere??? I know there has been discussion between the clubs over the years for maybe one of the clubs becoming say Mossy's Reserve Grade and the players are portable between the 2 grades but it always falls over. Maybe its time the Group "enforced" or aligned these 2nd div clubs with a 1st grade club. Other wise it may see the demise of 1st grade footy in the south in the near future
Great to see everyone on here getting in the spirit of the GF.Rustynail you are correct, there is too many 2nd division clubs in the highlands.There is huge talk that Oran Park will be trying to field a 2nd division side in 2016, obviously with group approval, but word is they will be financially backed by one of the biggest home building and concrete company's in the south west.Also can add truth to the Marulan one as well have heard this several times.
Premiership tips
City to win the 2 18's
Narellan- 2 Div
Oakdale- Res
Picton- 1st

Camden like Mitta 2 yrs ago to lose all 3 GF's on the day. Picton "threepeat" and will go down as one the best sides seen in Grp 6 over past 30 years since I have been watching Group 6 footy
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
cockpit000
SG Ball
[ *  * ]
rustynail
Sep 11 2015, 12:02 PM
footydad
Sep 11 2015, 11:46 AM
rustynail
Sep 11 2015, 11:20 AM
Orana87
Sep 11 2015, 09:18 AM
footydad
Sep 10 2015, 04:14 PM
It has been very quiet on here of late.It is GF week, and if we look back at a season in review, its been a great year.Workers and Dragons back in firsts.The Oaks neally got a fairytale, Kangaroos no matter what turned up to play.Reggies has been great this year, the workies old boys, Appins gang back together, Kangaroos would of challenged it if not for injuries in firsts.And Picton all grades strong.2nd division major success on saturday afternoons, will we see an extra team or two in 16.Should be a great day on sunday at Orana park.
Good idea footydad. Here's my report card prior to the Grand Finals:

Oakdale: great to see them back on the 1st Grade park in 2015. A fine effort by all to raise a competitive team that was imbued with the Oakdale spirit very quickly. Some superb wins and were never humiliated. The Reserves was obviously a shining light for the Club all season, and are now rewarded on Sunday with the Club being present on the biggest day of the season. Coaching situation ended in turmoil. Challenges ahead for 2016.
Grade: B

City: a superb rebuilding year from a Board perspective, bar four games (Picton/ Camden both rounds) in which we couldn't/ didn't compete. Two U/18 teams in the GF, Reserve Grade knocked out in first semi by Oakdale at Oakdale (who'll win it), and 1sts could easily have been an Oaks like cinderella story if not for a plague of injuries, which seem to follow me across the Northern Rd. Drew Dalton did a wonderful job "putting the 2013 band back together", with the addition of the 'Army boys', making the team competitive when it looked like we were gone in early February, especially after losing Russ Aitken in October 2014.
Grade: C

Thirlmere: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. Given their roster, the disappointment of the competition, failing to fire in 2015. Appeared to be an emotionless/ passionless team bar the U/18 kids that Greeney used, and who were their shining lights. I've heard it spoke that when Picton is strong, Thirlmere isn't and the obverse true. An interesting off-season awaits, but if the Trotters are raring to go, they will be the glue needed to get this team firing.
Grade: D-

Moss Vale: full credit to Michael Sutton and Robbie Payne for the quality of their 1st Grade team in 2015. Was it a one year wonder? Sutto put an enormous amount of energy into getting the off-field right. It can't be glossed over that this was an imported team, and that the cavalry is not coming from the lower grades. Both Mittagong and Moss Vale reggies are suffering from the plethora of 2nd Division clubs they are ringed by. I hope I'm wrong.
Grade: B-

Mittagong: appear now to be in decline. Was a massive effort the rise of 2011-2014; taking a toll on volunteers, officials and playing group alike. The history of the Group suggests that Mittagong rise every twenty years. In saying this, were my surprise packet though. Even though the loss of the Borgs meant a GF appearance was beyond them, they still remained ultra competitive, almost toppling Picton in the last round to snatch a semi final spot. Ultimately, two shellackings by Campbelltown City cost them a spot in the Top 3. Mark Thomas did very well with what was available to him. Another interesting off-season to watch player movement.
Grade: B-

Appin: had the roster to challenge for 3rd. Cruelled by lack of depth, injuries, ill- discipline and suspensions. Having seasoned pros hurts when everyone realises that Camden/ Picton were Man City/ Chelsea in 2015. Not having an U/18 team hurts, especially as a developing club. It looks as though Rob & Co. have been swift to wright the ship and have already confronted these issues.
Grade: C

Narellan: started incredibly slowly. Plagued by coaching instability, but came good in the end to nab a Top 3 spot, before being sacrificed to Picton in the Major Prelim. Full credit to President Clint McKinnon in spearheading the juniors- first policy, in the face of stern intra- club opposition. Ultra strong lower grades. The competition's sleeping giant, Narellan could easily sweep 18s- 2nd Div- Reserves and 1sts in one season, very shortly.
Grade: B

The Oaks: as they say in Caddyshack, the 'Cinderella Story'. First time in a 5 team finals since 2002 and won the 'Premiership' for 3rd in 2015. Very well coached by the Brasingtons, and with a quality front row, were always going to be hard to beat. Something is building at Dudley Chesham and selective, top-up recruitment for 2016 may see that premiership drought challenged.
Grade: A

Picton: defending premiers who recruited even better again to improve their roster. Sunday would see the feats of 1985-87 levelled, a magnificent achievement for locals Poisel and Dowse.
Grade: A+ (with a plus pending for Sunday)

Camden: said on here some time ago that Camden's great eras had been built around champion U/18 teams. The same has proven correct again, with a standout committtee raising the necessary funds to entice the right leadership and coaching. Selective recruiting of Insenio and Collis to neutralise and surpass Picton's threats was astute, and now has them on the cusp of ending a 13 season premiership drought. The pressure is bizarrely on Camden in this one.
Grade: A+ (with a plus or minus pending for Sunday)


Reserve Grade Competition Of the highest standard for some time. Even Appin and Thirlmere, who missed the finals, were more than capable on their day. Not a struck match between the top 5 teams. The Oaks improved vastly when Rumsby came into the team. Only Moss Vale and Mittagong were also-rans.

2nd Division Competition spot on footydad. The Saturday nature of this League has improved it. Full marks to Narellan on fielding two teams. Mt Annan doing well under Mahn Darley, but a 1st Grade return would be unlikely? A lot of 2nd Division clubs in the South, to the detriment of 1st Division clubs it is argued, but with the population explosion here in the north no doubt more teams will be looking to join this league, with places as far north as West Bardia, Willowdale and Leppington all in Group boundaries. Word is Marulan is set to hold a public meeting to form a 2nd Division team and footy club- with Marulan just inside the Group. The light flickered at the great Bowral club, but again they ended in turmoil.
Pretty good summation of the year. Your comments re 2nd division sides in the southern end of the group is definitely something the group needs to look at. The south doesn't have the population like the north does and cannot continue to support all the these clubs to the detriment of the 1st grade clubs. Moss Vale and Mittagong are pushing it uphill trying to keep their juniors when the players can take an easy option and have a run around at either Bowral, Robbo or Bundanoon without committing too much. Maybe Bargo is impacting on Thirlmere??? I know there has been discussion between the clubs over the years for maybe one of the clubs becoming say Mossy's Reserve Grade and the players are portable between the 2 grades but it always falls over. Maybe its time the Group "enforced" or aligned these 2nd div clubs with a 1st grade club. Other wise it may see the demise of 1st grade footy in the south in the near future
Great to see everyone on here getting in the spirit of the GF.Rustynail you are correct, there is too many 2nd division clubs in the highlands.There is huge talk that Oran Park will be trying to field a 2nd division side in 2016, obviously with group approval, but word is they will be financially backed by one of the biggest home building and concrete company's in the south west.Also can add truth to the Marulan one as well have heard this several times.
Premiership tips
City to win the 2 18's
Narellan- 2 Div
Oakdale- Res
Picton- 1st

Camden like Mitta 2 yrs ago to lose all 3 GF's on the day. Picton "threepeat" and will go down as one the best sides seen in Grp 6 over past 30 years since I have been watching Group 6 footy
Mitta - 18's
City - 18's
Mount Annan 2nds
Camden reserves
Camden firsts
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Orana87
Member Avatar
NSW Cup
[ *  *  * ]
1976
1977
2015
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Fully Featured & Customizable Free Forums
Learn More · Register Now
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · CRL Group 6 · Next Topic »
Add Reply


www.wests.co.nr is an unofficial forum run by volunteer Rugby League Supporters
Posts, messages, views, expressions or opinions on this forum DO NOT represent the official view of ANY Football Club.

Free Domains Hosting at .co.nr