Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to BS Zelda. We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Storyline section Final update
Topic Started: Jun 28 2012, 11:29 PM (2,799 Views)
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Duke Serkol,Aug 11 2013
07:20 PM
Tuf, it's over. Hyrule Historia makes it pointless to debate the storyline. Just... let it go.

I'll just repost this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i1TSpfPFNlE
My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Duke Serkol
Member Avatar
Where'd that Princess go?
Admin
You're preaching to the choir. I consider the Official Timeline wrong too, but too many people are blindly accepting it and new games will be made with that timeline in mind, so what you and I think makes little difference.
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Duke Serkol,Aug 14 2013
04:06 AM
You're preaching to the choir. I consider the Official Timeline wrong too, but too many people are blindly accepting it and new games will be made with that timeline in mind, so what you and I think makes little difference.


Well, @least we both agree that we disagree with the official timeline...

Also, this reminds me:

http://www.zeldauniverse.net/forums/groups...-believers.html

WE HAVE COMPANY!! ;) :D

My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Duke Serkol
Member Avatar
Where'd that Princess go?
Admin
Yeah, like, ten more people Posted Image

But anyway, since we are on the topic again... what's your timeline now?

Mine hasn't changed, but just for old time's sake...

SWS -> tMC -> OoT -> split

adult timeline -> TWW/NT -> PH -> ST

child timeline -> MM -> TP (+LCT) -> FS -> FSA -> ALttP -> LA/AST -> OoX -> ALBW -> LoZ -> G&W -> AoL


Just tell me the order in which you put the games, like I did. Don't bother writing four pages explaining why you place Oracles after AoL or stuff like that because I'm not going to read it.
Don't make me regret asking, 'k? :P
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Duke Serkol,Aug 15 2013
07:27 PM
Yeah, like, ten more people Posted Image

But anyway, since we are on the topic again... what's your timeline now?

Mine hasn't changed, but just for old time's sake...

SWS -> tMC -> OoT -> split

adult timeline -> TWW -> PH -> ST

child timeline -> MM -> TP (+LCT) -> FS -> FSA -> ALttP -> LA/AST -> OoX -> ALBW -> LoZ -> G&W -> AoL


Just tell me the order in which you put the games, like I did. Don't bother writing four pages explaining why you place Oracles after AoL or stuff like that because I'm not going to read it.
Don't make me regret asking, 'k? :P


Pre split: exactly the same as yours.. ;) (although I haven't yet played SWS, yet, I'm afraid)...

Adult Timeline: TWW -> PH -> TT -> ST

...&...

Child Timeline: MM -> ALTTPGBA -> FS -> FSA -> SC2 -> ALBW -> LA/AST -> (BS)LOZ -> AOL -> OOX
My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Duke Serkol
Member Avatar
Where'd that Princess go?
Admin
Ah yes, I forgot to list Navi Trackers... but let me tell you it most likely occurs before Phantom Hourglass, not after it.

Also haven't you forgotten something rather important?

Anyway, I imagine that everyone in that group you linked in the above post will have their own timeline, right? Or has a general consensus been reached between the most of them?
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Duke Serkol,Aug 16 2013
01:37 PM
Ah yes, I forgot to list Navi Trackers... but let me tell you it most likely occurs before Phantom Hourglass, not after it.

Also haven't you forgotten something rather important?

Anyway, I imagine that everyone in that group you linked in the above post will have their own timeline, right? Or has a general consensus been reached between the most of them?


1) Glad I could refresh your memory... ;) :D

2) I think TP/LCT happen on a parallel timeline, (perhaps a duplicate of the CT), if that's what you're reffering to...

I would have said so in my last post, but was afraid you might count it as something that might cause you to have regretted asking me...

3) Maybe: I'll have to start a discussion...

Also, probably should have listed the G&W... -_-
My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Duke Serkol
Member Avatar
Where'd that Princess go?
Admin
Tuf Pic,Aug 16 2013
11:07 PM
I think TP/LCT happen on a parallel timeline, (perhaps a duplicate of the CT), if that's what you're reffering to...

Mh, well you should have listed a third branch then.

Is it alone on this third timeline?

Quote:
 
Maybe: I'll have to start a discussion...

Good luck with that (odds are everyone will have a different persuasion)

Quote:
 
Also, probably should have listed the G&W... -_-

Eh, most people tend to forget it. Even I do sometimes and I'm like its number one fan.
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Duke Serkol,Aug 17 2013
07:35 PM
Tuf Pic,Aug 16 2013
11:07 PM
I think TP/LCT happen on a parallel timeline, (perhaps a duplicate of the CT), if that's what you're reffering to...

Mh, well you should have listed a third branch then.

Is it alone on this third timeline?

Quote:
 
Maybe: I'll have to start a discussion...

Good luck with that (odds are everyone will have a different persuasion)

Quote:
 
Also, probably should have listed the G&W... -_-

Eh, most people tend to forget it. Even I do sometimes and I'm like its number one fan.


1) Sorry about that...

2) As of yet, NO-ONE HAS RESPONDED... :stalfos: :(

3) Glad to hear that I'm normal, @least in that respect!! :D
My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Duke Serkol
Member Avatar
Where'd that Princess go?
Admin
Tuf Pic,Aug 23 2013
10:59 PM
Duke Serkol,Aug 17 2013
07:35 PM
Tuf Pic,Aug 16 2013
11:07 PM
I think TP/LCT happen on a parallel timeline, (perhaps a duplicate of the CT), if that's what you're reffering to...

Mh, well you should have listed a third branch then.

Is it alone on this third timeline?

1) Sorry about that...

No problem. You still haven't said what happens (or fails to happen) in this third branch though.

Quote:
 
2) As of yet, NO-ONE HAS RESPONDED... :stalfos: :(

Methinks a few more people have given up on this whole "boycott Hyrule Historia" thing :P

Quote:
 
3) Glad to hear that I'm normal, @least in that respect!! :D


...
I don't even need to make any jokes this time, do I?
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Duke Serkol,Aug 24 2013
02:24 PM
Tuf Pic,Aug 23 2013
10:59 PM
Duke Serkol,Aug 17 2013
07:35 PM
Tuf Pic,Aug 16 2013
11:07 PM
I think TP/LCT happen on a parallel timeline, (perhaps a duplicate of the CT), if that's what you're reffering to...

Mh, well you should have listed a third branch then.

Is it alone on this third timeline?

1) Sorry about that...

No problem. You still haven't said what happens (or fails to happen) in this third branch though.

Quote:
 
2) As of yet, NO-ONE HAS RESPONDED... :stalfos: :(

Methinks a few more people have given up on this whole "boycott Hyrule Historia" thing :P

Quote:
 
3) Glad to hear that I'm normal, @least in that respect!! :D


...
I don't even need to make any jokes this time, do I?


1) Haven't played much of Twilight Princess, but I'll let you know when I think of something that would split the timeline...

2) Most of them have not been online in a while...

That's probably why...

...&...

3) @_@
My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Tuf Pic quoting from deleted (incomplete) post
 
*NECRO-BUMP*: :stalfos:

I'm sorry, but I recently viewed:

This video, which (briefly), defends Hyrule Historia, & then goes on to tell you why the poster doesn't believe it anyways...

Why am I bringing this up?!

Well, towards the end he says something about how if the fan translations of Hyrule Historia are to be believed, that even Aounuma says that fans aren't required to give up on their timelines/theories, just because Nintendo says something different, as they have changed their minds, from time to time... (Which they have)...

...(Skip to 4:34 to hear that part)...

...So there MIGHT BE SOME HOPE FOR US AFTER ALL!! ;)

Also, wanted to take this chance to rearrange my timeline somewhat:

Pre-Split: SWS ->TMC -> OOTURA/OOT

Adult Timeline: TWW -> PH -> TT/NT -> ST

Child Timeline#1: OOTURA -> MM -> ALTTPGBA -> FS (possibly the Anniversary Edition), -> FSA -> SC2 ->  LADX/AST -> BSLOZ -> AOL -> OOX

Child Timeline#2: Regular OOT -> MM -> ALTTPSNES -> FS -> FSA -> LAB&W -> OOX -> ALBW -> LOZ  ->G&W -> AOL (Is it possible to switch the order of which game goes before which, from timeline to timeline)?!

...&...

Twilight/Duplicate Child Timeline #3: TP->LCT

The other general media/games have their timelines as well, (yes, even the Tingle games/Mangas/Comic Books/CD-I Games/Cartoons), but I can't think of how to place those, @least @the moment...

EDIT: Anything else that I should add?!


...Slight oversight on my part: Meant to mention Phantom Hourglass, but I forgot...

-_- :head explodes: :bomb:

...FIXED...
My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Duke Serkol
Member Avatar
Where'd that Princess go?
Admin
You just grave dug a topic by quoting a post in which you did the very same thing.

I am honestly left with no words here.
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Tuf Pic
Member Avatar
*The Thread Necromancer*!!!! :stalfos:
Duke Serkol,Dec 30 2013
02:51 PM
You just grave dug a topic by quoting a post in which you did the very same thing.

I am honestly left with no words here.


Well, I have something else to say, although I doubt I'll say anything else after it:

I made another mistake in my last post...

I should have placed Oracles BEFORE LAB&W, on the 2nd version of the Child Timeline, but oh well...

The rest of my post I still stand by, however!!
My Viewpoints
 
"Nothing you can say will ever convince me that the Zelda, Link & Impa of OOTURA, ALTTPGBA, SC2, BSLOZ, & OOX are different characters, or that Link isn't part Kokiri, FOR SOME Zelda Universes and that the mangas aren't canon FOR SOME alternate realities."

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · The Legend of Zelda Series · Next Topic »
Add Reply